# README

This is a subset of the AI annotated VLFeedback dataset.

In ths `jsonl` file, every line is an instance, consists of `id`, `prompt`, `models` (sampled for decoding) and the `completions` for GPT-4V annoatated preference in three aspects. The corresponding images are named as `{id}.jpg` under the `images` directory.

```json
{"id": "svit-complex_reasoning-3182", "prompt": "Why might the bananas have been placed near a water bottle?", "models": ["MMICL-Vicuna-13B", "llava1.5-7b", "llava1.5-7b", "instructblip-vicuna-13b"], "completions": [{"annotations": {"Helpfulness": {"Rating": "2", "Rationale": "The response seems to misinterpret the setting as a store display, which is not supported by the image's content. The focus on the display purpose and appeal to potential customers is a guess and not grounded in visible evidence from the image. It offers less relevance and helpfulness in understanding the context of the photo."}, "Ethical Considerations": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "Despite some inaccuracies in the interpretation, the response is ethical. It does not present any safety, privacy, or fairness issues and is not harmful or offensive."}, "Visual Faithfulness": {"Rating": "2", "Rationale": "This response inaccurately interprets the setting as a store display, which is not evident in the image. The assumptions made about the purpose of the bananas' placement are speculative and not supported by visual cues in the photograph.\n---"}}, "model": "MMICL-Vicuna-13B", "response": "By studying the image, I can confidently state that the answer is for display. Because The bananas are sitting on a table and there ' s no reason to have them near water unless it was done intentionally as part of an advertisement or promotion. also they don't seem like they would be in this location if not meant to be seen by people passing by. therefore i think its because they were placed here for showcasing purposes. . also the bottle could possibly contain some sort of liquid used with the fruit which might make it more appealing to buyers. but overall it seems most likely that these bananas were put out for sale at a store. either way the placement doesn ' t matter too much. it may just be coincidental. the main point being emphasized is how the bananas look visually enticing to potential customers. so the positioning has been carefully thought about to maximize their appeal. otherwise it wouldn ' t be here. therefore the question does not require further specification. it is clear what the purpose is. the brief yet correct response to the question is for display. 0:15 minutes.  Taking into account both the information from the image and my own knowledge"}, {"annotations": {"Helpfulness": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "This response is helpful as it gives a straightforward and plausible explanation for the bananas being near a water bottle, emphasizing convenience and the common practice of pairing food with drinks. It also acknowledges the possibility of coincidence, which is realistic."}, "Ethical Considerations": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "This response is ethical, with no issues regarding safety, privacy, fairness, or harmfulness. It offers a benign explanation without making any assumptions that could lead to ethical concerns."}, "Visual Faithfulness": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "The response is faithful to the image, noting the bananas' proximity to the water bottle and suggesting a practical reason for their placement. It avoids making ungrounded statements that do not align with the image content."}}, "model": "llava1.5-7b", "response": "The bananas might have been placed near a water bottle for convenience or as part of a snack or meal preparation. It is common for people to keep fruits, such as bananas, near a water bottle to have easy access to both items when they need a quick and healthy snack or to incorporate them into a meal. The proximity of the bananas to the water bottle could also be a coincidence, with the bananas being placed there temporarily while the person was organizing or cleaning the area."}, {"annotations": {"Helpfulness": {"Rating": "3", "Rationale": "The response provides a practical rationale for the placement of bananas near the water bottle, focusing on convenience and the commonality of storing food and drink items together. However, the information about water maintaining the moisture content of bananas is not accurate, which impacts the helpfulness of the response."}, "Ethical Considerations": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "The response adheres to ethical guidelines. It does not share any personal information or provide unsafe advice. It maintains a neutral and unbiased perspective."}, "Visual Faithfulness": {"Rating": "3", "Rationale": "The text moderately reflects the visual elements by discussing the proximity of the bananas to the water bottle, a clear aspect of the image. However, the claim about water maintaining the bananas' moisture content is not visually indicated nor factually correct."}}, "model": "llava1.5-7b", "response": "The bananas might have been placed near the water bottle for convenience and easy access. It is common for people to store fruits and other perishable items near water bottles, as they are usually placed in a kitchen or dining area where people frequently consume food and drinks. This arrangement allows for easy access to both the water and the bananas, making it more convenient for individuals to grab a banana as a snack or incorporate it into their meals. Additionally, placing the bananas near the water bottle can also help to keep the bananas fresh by preventing them from getting too ripe or overripe, as the water can help to maintain their moisture content."}, {"annotations": {"Helpfulness": {"Rating": "3", "Rationale": "The response speculates on various reasons why bananas might be placed near a water bottle, which could provide some context to the user. However, it includes speculative information about water preventing ripening, which isn't generally accurate, so while it is moderately helpful, it's not fully reliable."}, "Ethical Considerations": {"Rating": "4", "Rationale": "The response is ethical, as it avoids making any unsafe or privacy-compromising statements. It does not contain any biased or harmful content and is respectful of privacy and fairness."}, "Visual Faithfulness": {"Rating": "3", "Rationale": "The response reflects the image content to a moderate degree by addressing the presence of bananas and a water bottle. However, it inaccurately suggests that water can prevent ripening, which is not a visual element and is factually incorrect."}}, "model": "instructblip-vicuna-13b", "response": "The bananas might have been placed near the water bottle for several reasons. One possibility is that the bananas were being used as a snack, and the water bottle was nearby to quench thirst or provide hydration during the snacking. Another possibility is that the bananas were being used as a decorative element, and the water bottle was placed there to complement the overall aesthetic of the setting. Additionally, the water bottle might have been used to keep the bananas fresh, as water can help to prevent ripening and extend their shelf life. Overall, the placement of the bananas and water bottle could be due to a combination of these factors or other reasons specific to the situation."}]}

```

