{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can be done independently and concurrently with preparing the cake tin in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can be done independently and prior to preparing the cake tin in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, and Step 3 involves lining it with parchment, which can be done in either order as long as both are completed before adding the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing and lining the cake tin, which must be prepared before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not necessarily after beating the butter and sugar in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with parchment, which is necessary to prepare the tin before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, and does not depend on the mixing process in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients (Step 4 onwards) to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cake mixture is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing and lining the cake tin, which needs to be prepared before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not necessarily after adding eggs in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding any mixture to it, as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming the butter, sugar, and vanilla before adding eggs, which is essential for creating a smooth and aerated batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cake mixture is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing and lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not necessarily after mixing in the ground almonds in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin, which is necessary to prepare the tin before adding any ingredients, while Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds into the batter, which is unrelated to the preparation of the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming the butter, sugar, and vanilla, which is a foundational step in cake making that typically precedes the addition of other ingredients like eggs and ground almonds.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the creamed butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before adding dry ingredients like ground almonds in Step 6 for proper cake batter consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cake mixture is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before adding any mixture to it, as outlined in steps 10 and 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding any ingredients into it, as described in steps 10 and 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming the butter, sugar, and vanilla, which is a foundational step in cake making that typically precedes the addition of dry ingredients like flour (Step 7).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the creamed butter and sugar mixture, which must be done before adding flour and milk in Step 7 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds which can be done before adding the flour and milk in steps 7 and 9 to ensure even distribution of almonds throughout the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature when the cake is ready to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing and lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not after mixing ingredients in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding any mixture to it, as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming butter, sugar, and vanilla, which is a separate process from combining the flour and milk in Step 8; these steps do not depend on each other's completion.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the butter mixture, which must occur before Step 8 where the flour and milk are stirred in, as indicated in the procedure.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds which logically precedes the addition and mixing of flour and milk in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding half the flour and milk, which must be combined using a wooden spoon as described in Step 8, thus Step 8 cannot occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 9 to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature when the cake is ready to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not after mixing the ingredients as in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin, which must be done before adding any ingredients into it, as described in Step 10 and 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming the butter, sugar, and vanilla which is essential to form the base of the cake batter before adding other ingredients like flour and milk in steps 7 and 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the creamed butter and sugar mixture, which must occur before adding flour and milk in Steps 7 and 9 to ensure proper mixing and consistency of the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds which is part of preparing the cake batter, while Step 9 involves adding the remaining flour and milk, which should be done after the initial addition of these ingredients in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 and Step 9 are part of the same process of adding flour and milk to the mixture, where Step 7 involves adding the first half and Step 9 involves adding the remaining half.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring in half the flour and milk, and Step 9 involves repeating the process with the remaining flour and milk; the order of these steps can be interchanged without affecting the outcome.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before arranging the apple and adding the mixture in Step 10, to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before adding any ingredients into it, as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with baking parchment, which must be done before adding any ingredients into the tin, as specified in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creaming the butter, sugar, and vanilla, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before arranging the apples in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the batter, which must be done before Step 10 where the apples are arranged in the tin, as the batter needs to be prepared first.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds into the batter, which needs to be done before the batter is spooned into the tin in Step 11, not after arranging the apples in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding flour and milk to the cake batter, which needs to be completed before arranging the apple slices in Step 10 and spooning the mixture into the tin in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring the batter to combine flour and milk, which must be done before adding the batter to the cake tin in Step 11, following the arrangement of apples in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves completing the mixing of the batter, which must be done before arranging the apples and adding the batter to the tin in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 11, spooning the mixture into the tin, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with baking parchment, which must be done before adding any ingredients into it, as specified in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves beating the butter, sugar, and vanilla which is essential to create the cake batter before it can be spooned into the tin in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the batter, which must be done before Step 11 where the batter is spooned into the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds into the batter, which must be done before the batter is spooned into the tin in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding half the flour and milk to the batter, which must be done before Step 11 where the batter is spooned into the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring the initial mixture of flour and milk, which must be done before adding the mixture to the tin in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves completing the mixing of the flour and milk into the batter, which must be done before Step 11 where the batter is spooned into the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves arranging the apple slices in the tin before adding the cake mixture in Step 11, ensuring the apples are at the bottom when the cake is inverted after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before adding any ingredients into it, as described in steps 10 and 11, well before baking in step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with baking parchment, which must be done before adding ingredients and baking as described in later steps, including Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves beating the butter, sugar, and vanilla which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, thus it must occur before Step 12 where the cake is baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the batter, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds into the batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding flour and milk to the batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring the batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding the remaining flour and milk to the batter, which must be completed before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves arranging the apple slices in the cake tin before adding the batter in Step 11, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves spooning the mixture into the tin and smoothing the surface, which must be done before baking the cake as described in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 12, not after the cake has cooled in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before adding ingredients and baking, not after the cake has been baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with baking parchment, which is necessary before adding ingredients and baking, whereas Step 13 involves cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves beating the butter, sugar, and vanilla, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 13 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is essential before baking (Step 12), whereas Step 13 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds into the batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12, and thus cannot occur after the cake has been cooled and served as described in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding flour and milk to the cake batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12, whereas Step 13 involves cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring the batter, which must be done before baking (Step 12) and cooling (Step 13).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding the remaining flour and milk to the cake mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 12, whereas Step 13 involves cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves arranging the apple slices in the cake tin before adding the batter, which must occur before baking (Step 12) and cooling (Step 13).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves spooning the mixture into the tin before baking, which must occur before Step 13, where the cake is cooled and turned onto a plate.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 must happen before Step 13 because the cake needs to be fully baked before it can be set aside to cool.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 12, not after serving it in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the cake tin, which is necessary before adding ingredients and baking, and must occur long before the cake is served as described in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves lining the cake tin with baking parchment, which is necessary before adding ingredients and baking, and must occur before the baking process in Step 12, not after serving the cake in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves beating butter, sugar, and vanilla which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 14 is about serving the cake after it has been baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 12, whereas Step 14 involves serving the cake after it has been baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in ground almonds, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before it is baked in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding flour and milk to the cake batter, which must occur before baking (Step 12) and serving (Step 14).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves stirring the batter, which must be done before baking and serving the cake as described in Steps 12 and 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding the remaining flour and milk to the cake mixture, which must be done before baking in Step 12, and long before serving in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves arranging the apple slices in the cake tin before adding the batter and baking, which must occur before the cake is served in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves spooning the mixture into the tin and smoothing the surface, which must occur before baking (Step 12) and serving (Step 14).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves baking the cake, which must occur before Step 14 where the cake is served; thus, Step 12 cannot happen after Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 0, "title": "almond and apple cake", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.", "Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.", "Line base and side with baking parchment.", "Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).", "Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.", "Stir in ground almonds.", "Add half the flour and half the milk.", "Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.", "Repeat remaining flour and milk.", "Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.", "Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.", "Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.", "Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almond and apple cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 170 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Brush around 22cm (base measurement) cake tin with melted butter to grease.\n3. Line base and side with baking parchment.\n4. Beat butter, caster sugar and vanilla in a bowl for 8 mins or till pale and creamy (by hand or electric beater).\n5. Add the eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.\n6. Stir in ground almonds.\n7. Add half the flour and half the milk.\n8. Use a wooden spoon to stir until well combined.\n9. Repeat remaining flour and milk.\n10. Arrange the apple, slightly overlapping, over the base of the prepared tin.\n11. Spoon mixture into the tin and smooth the surface.\n12. Bake in the oven for 30-35 mins or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.\n13. Set aside in the pan for 10 mins to cool slightly before turning onto a serving plate.\n14. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves cooling the cake slightly in the pan before turning it onto a serving plate, which must occur before Step 14 where the cake is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with greasing the loaf tin as described in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients in Step 3 to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the batter is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the loaf tin which can be done before mixing the ingredients in Step 3, as it only prepares the tin for later use.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients in Step 4 to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the loaf tin, which must be done before adding the batter in Step 5, thus it does not need to follow Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the dry ingredients, which must be done before adding the wet ingredients in Step 4 to ensure proper distribution and consistency in the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before Step 5 where the batter is poured into the tin and needs to be baked immediately in a hot oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the loaf tin, which must be done before pouring the batter into it in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients which must be done before pouring the batter into the tin in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves combining the ingredients to create the batter, which must be done before pouring the batter into the tin in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the banana bread in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the loaf tin, which must be done before pouring the batter in Step 5, and therefore before baking in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the dry ingredients and adding the wet ingredients, which must be done before baking the bread in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves combining the ingredients to make the batter, which must occur before baking the bread in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pouring the batter into the tin, which must occur before baking the bread in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the banana bread in Step 6, and therefore must happen before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves greasing the loaf tin which must be done before pouring the batter in Step 5, and long before cooling the bread in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients which is essential before baking in Step 6, and must occur before the bread is baked and subsequently cooled in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves combining ingredients to create the batter, which must occur before baking (Step 6) and cooling (Step 7).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pouring the batter into the tin, which must occur before baking (Step 6) and cooling (Step 7).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 1, "title": "almost no fat banana bread", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.", "In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.", "Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.", "Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: almost no fat banana bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Lightly grease a 20x10cm (8x4 in) loaf tin.\n3. In a large bowl, stir together flour, sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda and cinnamon.\n4. Add egg whites, bananas and apple pur\u00c3\u00a9e; stir just until combined.\n5. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n6. Bake in preheated oven for 50 to 55 minutes, until a skewer inserted into centre of loaf comes out clean.\n7. Turn out onto wire rack and allow to cool before slicing.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves baking the bread, which must occur before Step 7, where the bread is turned out onto a wire rack to cool.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves mixing the ingredients which must occur before heating the mixture in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining the ingredients which must occur before they can be boiled and simmered as described in Steps 2 and 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 3 as boiling the mixture is necessary before it can be simmered.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining the ingredients which is necessary before boiling, simmering, and storing as described in Steps 2, 3, and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 as it involves boiling the mixture, which is necessary before simmering and storing.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 2, "title": "apple-pumpkin-spread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.", "Bring mixture to the boil.", "Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.", "Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: apple-pumpkin-spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a medium saucepan over medium heat, mix pumpkin puree, apple sauce, apple juice, dark brown soft sugar and spices.\n2. Bring mixture to the boil.\n3. Reduce heat and simmer approximately 1 1/2 hours.\n4. Transfer to sterile containers and chill in the refrigerator until serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the mixture to thicken it, which must occur before transferring it to containers and chilling as described in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the chicken in a dish or bag before Step 2, where the vinaigrette is poured over it for marination.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the chicken in a dish or bag for marinating, which must occur before cooking (Step 3), as the marination process is essential for flavor infusion prior to cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken which needs to be done before cooking, while Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, thus Step 2 does not need to happen after Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the chicken in a dish or bag for marinating, which must occur before removing it from the marinade in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken which must occur before removing the chicken from the marinade and discarding it in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which needs to be done before removing the chicken from the marinade in Step 4 to ensure the pan is ready for immediate saut\u00e9ing.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the chicken in a dish or bag for marinating, which must occur before cooking the chicken in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking it in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the frying pan for cooking, which must occur before Step 5 where the chicken is actually saut\u00e9ed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves removing the chicken from the marinade and discarding the marinade, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the chicken in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the chicken for marination, which must occur before cooking and serving the chicken, as described in Steps 3 through 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking (Step 5), and thus before arranging the chicken on a serving platter (Step 6).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the chicken in Step 5, and therefore before arranging the chicken on a platter in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves discarding the marinade after removing the chicken, which must occur before cooking the chicken in Step 5, and thus before arranging it on a platter in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the chicken, which must be done before arranging it on a serving platter in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the chicken for marination, which is necessary before cooking and topping with mozzarella in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking (Step 5), and well before topping it with mozzarella (Step 7).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the chicken in Step 5, and thus before placing mozzarella on the cooked chicken in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves removing the chicken from the marinade and discarding the marinade, which is necessary before cooking the chicken in Step 5, while Step 7 involves topping the cooked chicken with mozzarella, which occurs after the chicken is cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the chicken, which needs to be done before topping it with mozzarella, basil, and tomato as described in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the cooked chicken on a platter, which does not necessarily need to be done before placing the mozzarella, basil, and tomato on top in Step 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the chicken for marination, which must occur before cooking and assembling with toppings in steps 8 and subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking (Step 5) and assembling the dish (Steps 6-9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the chicken in Step 5, well before arranging toppings in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves discarding the marinade after removing the chicken, which is necessary before cooking the chicken in Step 5, while Step 8 involves topping the cooked chicken with tomato, which occurs after the chicken is cooked and arranged.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the chicken, which needs to be done before topping it with mozzarella, basil, and tomato as described in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the cooked chicken on a platter, which must occur before topping it with mozzarella, basil, and tomato as described in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 does not need to happen after Step 8 because the mozzarella needs to be placed directly on the hot chicken to slightly melt before adding the basil and tomato.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the chicken in a dish or bag for marinating, which is necessary before cooking and serving, thus it must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking (Step 5), and long before the final garnishing and seasoning in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which must occur before the chicken can be saut\u00e9ed in Step 5, well before the final garnishing and seasoning in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves discarding the marinade before cooking the chicken, which must occur before the chicken is cooked, arranged, and garnished as described in steps 5 through 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the chicken, which must be done before topping it with mozzarella, basil, tomato, and balsamic vinegar as described in Steps 7 to 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the cooked chicken on a serving platter, which must occur before adding toppings and drizzling with balsamic vinegar in steps 7, 8, and 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing mozzarella on the chicken, which needs to be done before adding basil and tomato in Step 8, and before drizzling balsamic vinegar in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves arranging basil and tomato on the chicken, which does not necessarily need to occur before drizzling balsamic vinegar in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the chicken for marination, which is necessary before cooking and serving, hence it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves marinating the chicken, which must occur before cooking and serving the chicken as described in steps 3 through 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the pan for cooking, which must occur before cooking the chicken in Step 5, well before serving the dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves discarding the marinade before cooking the chicken, which must occur before serving the dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the chicken, which must be done before it can be served in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the cooked chicken on a serving platter, which must occur before it can be topped with mozzarella, basil, tomato, and balsamic vinegar in the subsequent steps, and before it is served in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing mozzarella on the chicken, which must occur before drizzling balsamic vinegar in Step 9 and serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves assembling the dish by adding basil, cheese, and tomato, which must be completed before drizzling balsamic vinegar and seasoning in Step 9, and serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 3, "title": "balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.", "Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.", "Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.", "Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.", "Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.", "Arrange chicken on a serving platter.", "Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.", "Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.", "Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.", "Serve!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: balsamic-and-mozzarella-chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place chicken in a shallow dish or large resealable plastic bag.\n2. Pour the vinaigrette over it, cover or seal and marinate in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours.\n3. Coat a large frying pan lightly with oil, and set over low heat.\n4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and discard the marinade.\n5. Saute chicken breast fillets over low heat for about 30 minutes, or until juices run clear.\n6. Arrange chicken on a serving platter.\n7. Place a generous slice of fresh mozzarella on top of each piece.\n8. Place a leaf of basil on top of the cheese, and cover with a slice of tomato.\n9. Drizzle balsamic vinegar over the platter, then season with salt and pepper.\n10. Serve!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves drizzling balsamic vinegar and seasoning, which should be done before serving (Step 10) to ensure the chicken is properly flavored when presented.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with or before mixing ingredients in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before Step 3 where the crust is pressed into the tin and needs to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining ingredients to create the base mixture, which must be done before pressing it into the tin in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the base in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base which must be baked (Step 4) before adding toppings, thus it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the mixture into the tin, which must be done before baking it in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, and thus must happen before Step 5 where the base is allowed to cool.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base which needs to be baked and cooled before applying the filling and toppings in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the crust mixture into the tin, which must be done before baking in Step 4 and cooling in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which must occur before it can cool in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, and is unrelated to the mixing of ingredients in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake which must be baked and cooled before applying the filling made in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the base mixture into the tin and baking it, which must be done before preparing and adding the filling in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which must be cooled before applying the filling made in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must happen before Step 6 to ensure the base is cool before spreading the fluffy mixture over it, preventing it from melting or becoming soggy.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before baking the base in Step 4, while Step 7 involves beating the filling which is used after the base is baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake which must be baked and cooled before applying the filling made in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the base mixture into the tin and baking it, which must be completed and cooled before applying the filling made in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which needs to cool before applying the filling made in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the baked base which is necessary before applying the fluffy filling from Step 7, hence it does not need to follow Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves combining ingredients which must be done before they can be beaten as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, well before spreading the filling in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake which must be baked and cooled before applying the filling in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the base mixture into the tin which must be done before baking in Step 4 and before adding the filling in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which must cool before applying the filling in Step 8, thus Step 4 must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 8 as the base needs to be cooled before spreading the fluffy mixture over it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the filling which must be spread over the cooled base in Step 8, thus it needs to be completed before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating the margarine, eggs, and icing sugar mixture until fluffy, which must be completed before spreading it over the cooled base in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, well before arranging bananas on the filling in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake, which must be done and baked (Steps 3 and 4) before adding toppings like bananas and pineapple in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the base mixture into the tin, which must be done before baking and cooling the base, necessary before adding toppings in steps 8 and 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which needs to be cooled before adding toppings in steps 8-11, and does not depend on the arrangement of bananas or other toppings done in step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the baked base and must occur before applying the filling in Step 8, which precedes arranging bananas in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the filling which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before the bananas and other toppings are added (Steps 9 and 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating the margarine, eggs, and icing sugar mixture to create a fluffy filling, which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before arranging the bananas and other toppings (Steps 9 and 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves spreading the fluffy mixture over the cooled base, which can be done before arranging the bananas and pineapple in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, and thus must happen before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake, which must be done and baked before adding toppings like bananas and strawberries in steps 9 and 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the crust mixture into the tin, which must be done before baking and adding toppings, thus it cannot occur after Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base of the cake, which must be done before adding toppings like bananas and strawberries in steps 9 and 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves cooling the baked base, must occur before applying the filling and toppings in steps 6-11, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the filling which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before layering the fruits (Steps 9 and 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating the margarine, eggs, and icing sugar mixture to create a fluffy filling, which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before arranging the fruit layers (Steps 9 and 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves spreading the fluffy mixture over the cooled base, which must occur before arranging the bananas and other fruits (Steps 9 and 10) on top of it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves arranging bananas and topping with pineapple, which can be done independently before layering strawberries in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the base in Step 4, and thus must happen before Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the base of the cake, which must be done before adding toppings and fillings in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves pressing the base mixture into the tin, which must occur before baking and adding toppings, thus it cannot happen after Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the base which must be done before adding toppings in subsequent steps, including Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before steps 8 through 11 to ensure the base is cool enough to apply the subsequent layers without them melting or becoming misshapen.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the filling which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before the fruits and whipped cream are added in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating the margarine, eggs, and icing sugar mixture to create a fluffy filling which must be spread over the cooled base (Step 8) before layering the fruits and whipped cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves spreading the fluffy mixture over the cooled base, which must occur before adding the fruit layers and whipped cream in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves arranging bananas and pineapple on the filling, which must be done before covering with whipped cream in Step 11 to ensure proper layering of the cake.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 4, "title": "banana-split-cake", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.", "In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.", "Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.", "Remove from oven and allow to cool.", "In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.", "Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.", "Spread over cooled base.", "Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.", "Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.", "Cover with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: banana-split-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 190 C / Gas 5.\n2. In a large bowl, combine flour, 175g margarine and chopped pecans.\n3. Press into the bottom of a 20x30cm tin.\n4. Bake in preheated oven for 20 minutes.\n5. Remove from oven and allow to cool.\n6. In a large bowl, combine remaining margarine, eggs and icing sugar.\n7. Beat with an electric mixer for 6 minutes or until fluffy.\n8. Spread over cooled base.\n9. Slice bananas and arrange on filling, then top with pineapple.\n10. Slice strawberries and layer over bananas.\n11. Cover with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves slicing strawberries and layering them over the bananas, which logically precedes covering the entire dessert with whipped cream in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the glasses which is necessary before pouring the mixed drink from Step 4 into them.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the glasses which must be done before pouring the mixed drink from Step 4 into them.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the ingredients in the shaker, which must occur before Step 3 where the mixture is shaken.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the glasses which must be done before pouring the mixed drink into them in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the drink ingredients, which must occur before Step 4 where the mixed drink is poured into the glasses.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 5, "title": "best-ever-margarita", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.", "Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.", "Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.", "Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: best-ever-margarita\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rim 2 margarita glasses with salt if desired and fill with ice.\n2. Pour the tequila, lime cordial, triple sec and lemon-lime soft drink into a cocktail shaker filled with ice.\n3. Hold your hand firmly over over the top of the shaker so the top doesn't pop off from the fizzy soft drink and shake vigorously.\n4. Pour into prepared margarita glasses and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves shaking the mixture in the cocktail shaker, which must occur before Step 4 where the mixture is poured into the glasses.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice mixture which must be done before it can be boiled in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining the ingredients which must occur before cooking them, which is detailed in Steps 2 through 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves bringing the mixture to a boil which must occur before reducing the heat in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice mixture which must occur before cooking it in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves bringing the rice mixture to a boil, which must occur before reducing the heat in Step 3 and cooking the rice until tender in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves reducing the heat to medium-low, which must occur before Step 4 where the rice is cooked at this reduced temperature.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice mixture which is essential before cooking and adding final ingredients like coconut cream and vanilla in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves bringing the rice mixture to a boil, which is necessary before reducing the heat and cooking the rice until tender (Steps 3 and 4), and this must occur before adding the coconut cream and vanilla extract in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves reducing the heat to medium-low to continue cooking the rice, which must occur before Step 5 where coconut cream and vanilla extract are added after the rice is cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the rice until it is tender and creamy, which is necessary before adding the coconut cream and vanilla extract in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice mixture which is essential to start the cooking process, thus it must occur before Step 6, where the pudding is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 6 as it involves boiling the rice mixture, which is essential before it can be served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3, which involves reducing the heat to medium-low, is part of the cooking process and must occur before Step 6, where the pudding is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the rice until it is tender and creamy, which is necessary before adding coconut cream and vanilla extract in Step 5, and serving in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 6, "title": "black-rice-pudding", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.", "Reduce heat to medium-low.", "Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.", "Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.", "Serve warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: black-rice-pudding\n\nProcedure:\n1. Rinse and drain glutinous black rice and glutinous white rice, then combine with sugar and water in a large saucepan.\n2. Bring to the boil over high heat, stirring frequently.\n3. Reduce heat to medium-low.\n4. Cover and cook until rice is tender and creamy, stirring occasionally, about 45 minutes.\n5. Stir in coconut cream and vanilla extract.\n6. Serve warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves stirring in coconut cream and vanilla extract, which must be done before serving the pudding in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming the butter and sugar together, which is typically done before adding flour (Step 3) to form the dough base.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which must occur before adding flour in Step 3 and mixing in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding flour which is necessary before mixing in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking in Step 10, and does not depend on flour sprinkling in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar which is essential to form the base of the dough before flour is added and kneaded in steps 3 through 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding the initial amount of flour to the butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before kneading and using additional flour in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the initial ingredients, which must occur before using the remaining flour to sprinkle the board in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing and kneading the dough to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the dough is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which is a foundational step in forming the dough and must occur before kneading the dough in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves initially adding flour to the butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before kneading and adding more flour in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the initial ingredients, which must occur before kneading the dough in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves sprinkling the board with flour to prepare for kneading the dough in Step 6, so it logically precedes Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 7, rolling the dough, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature when the shortbread is ready to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which is essential to form the base of the dough before it is rolled and shaped in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding flour to the butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before kneading and rolling the dough in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the initial ingredients which is necessary before kneading and rolling the dough in steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves sprinkling the board with flour to prevent sticking during kneading, which must occur before rolling the dough in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves kneading the dough to achieve the right consistency before it can be rolled out in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 8, cutting the dough into strips, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature when the shortbread is ready to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which is essential to form the base of the dough before shaping and cutting it in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding flour to the butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before kneading and shaping the dough in later steps, including Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the dough, which must occur before rolling and cutting the dough in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves sprinkling the board with flour to prepare for kneading and rolling the dough, which must occur before cutting the dough into strips in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves kneading the dough to achieve the right consistency before it can be rolled and cut into strips in Step 7 and Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rolling the dough to the required thickness, which must be done before cutting it into strips in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 9, placing the cookies on trays, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which is essential to form the base of the dough before shaping and baking in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding flour to the creamed butter and sugar mixture, which is essential to form the dough before it can be rolled, cut, and baked as described in steps 5 through 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the dough, which must occur before shaping and pricking the dough in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves preparing the board with flour for kneading the dough, which must occur before cutting and pricking the dough in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves kneading the dough to achieve the right consistency before it can be rolled and cut into strips in Steps 7 and 8, which must occur before placing on baking trays in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rolling the dough to the required thickness, which must occur before cutting into strips (Step 8) and pricking with a fork (Step 9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cutting the dough into strips, which must be done before Step 9 where the strips are pricked with a fork and placed on baking trays.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the shortbread in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming butter and sugar, which is essential to prepare the dough before baking, thus it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding flour to the butter and sugar mixture, which is essential for forming the dough before baking, thus it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the ingredients to form a dough, which must occur before baking the dough in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves preparing the dough by sprinkling flour on the board before kneading, which must occur before baking in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves kneading the dough to achieve the right consistency before baking, which must occur before Step 10 where the dough is actually baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rolling the dough to the required thickness, which must be done before cutting and baking (Steps 8 and 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cutting the dough into strips, which must be done before baking in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 7, "title": "brown sugar shortbread", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.", "Cream butter and brown sugar.", "Add 400g to 500g flour.", "Mix well.", "Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.", "Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.", "Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.", "Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.", "Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.", "Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: brown sugar shortbread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 160 C / Gas mark 3.\n2. Cream butter and brown sugar.\n3. Add 400g to 500g flour.\n4. Mix well.\n5. Sprinkle board with the remaining flour.\n6. Knead for 5 minutes, adding enough flour to make a soft dough.\n7. Roll to 1cm (1/2 in) thickness.\n8. Cut into 7x2cm (3x1 in) strips.\n9. Prick with fork and place on ungreased baking trays.\n10. Bake in preheated oven for 20 to 25 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves preparing the shortbread by pricking it and placing it on trays, which must be done before baking in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves putting all ingredients into the slow cooker and mixing them, which must occur before Step 2, where the slow cooker is set to cook the ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves putting all ingredients into the slow cooker and mixing them, which must occur before monitoring the mixture's moisture level in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is a conditional step that only applies if the mixture looks too dry during the cooking process, which occurs during Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves putting all ingredients into the slow cooker and must occur before cooking, which is addressed in Step 2, while Step 4 is a conditional step during cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a conditional step that can occur during Step 2 if the mixture looks too dry.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a closing parenthesis and does not contain any action or instruction, so Step 3 does not depend on it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves putting all ingredients into the slow cooker to start the cooking process, which must occur before dividing the cooked food into tubs in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the ingredients in the slow cooker, which must occur before dividing and storing the cooked mixture in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding water if the mixture looks too dry during the cooking process, which must occur before Step 5 where the food is already cooked and being stored.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a conditional step that should be applied during the cooking process in Step 2 if the mixture looks too dry, not after the cooking is completed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves putting all ingredients into the slow cooker to start the cooking process, which must occur before dividing and storing the meals as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the ingredients in the slow cooker, which must occur before dividing and storing the meals as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is related to adjusting the moisture level during the cooking process, which occurs before the food is divided and stored as described in Steps 5 and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a conditional step during the cooking process, which occurs before the food is divided and stored as described in Steps 5 and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dividing the cooked mixture into tubs, which logically precedes storing some in the fridge and freezing the rest as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing and mixing the ingredients, which logically precedes cooking and storage steps, including Step 7 which is about reheating the meal.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the ingredients in the slow cooker, which must occur before dividing and storing the meals as described in steps 5 through 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is a monitoring step during the cooking process, which occurs long before the food is stored and reheated as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a conditional step during the cooking process, which occurs long before the food is divided and stored as described in Steps 5 through 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dividing and storing the cooked mixture, which logically precedes reheating and eating the meal as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 8, "title": "busters-liver-dinner", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.", "Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.", "( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.", ")", "Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.", "This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.", "When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: busters-liver-dinner\n\nProcedure:\n1. Put all ingredients into a slow cooker, mix together.\n2. Put slow cooker on high for 4 to 5 hours or low all day.\n3. ( If mixture starts to look too dry just add a little hot water.\n4. )\n5. Once cooked, divide between several plastic microwaveable tubs with lids.\n6. This mixture usually makes 6 to 7 meals, I freeze 4 and put the rest in the fridge.\n7. When ready to eat microwave with lid half off for 2 to 3 minutes on medium high.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves freezing and refrigerating the meals, which must occur before reheating any meal as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 2 because the ingredients need to be placed in the food processor before they can be pulsed into a dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining initial ingredients to form a dough, which logically precedes the adjustment of its consistency by adding extra flour in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves forming the dough, which typically needs to be assessed for consistency before deciding in Step 3 whether extra flour is needed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining ingredients to form the dough, which is necessary before it can be divided in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 because the dough needs to be formed before it can be divided into two parts.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adjusting the dough's consistency before it is divided, which logically occurs before dividing the dough in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5 because the ingredients need to be combined and processed into dough before they can be used in a pie or pastie recipe.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 5 because the dough needs to be formed before it can be divided and used in a pie or pastie recipe.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 may need to occur before Step 4 to ensure the dough has the correct consistency for dividing and using in recipes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 9, "title": "butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.", "Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.", "You may need to add a little extra flour.", "Divide into two equal parts.", "Use in a pie or pastie recipe."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: butternut-squash-pastry-for-pies\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the flour, egg and squash into the container of a food processor.\n2. Pulse until mixed into a doughy ball.\n3. You may need to add a little extra flour.\n4. Divide into two equal parts.\n5. Use in a pie or pastie recipe.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 5 because the dough needs to be divided into two parts before it can be used in pie or pastie recipes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with preparing the filling in Step 2, as these tasks do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with boiling the chicken and vegetables in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining the chicken and vegetables in the saucepan, which must occur before Step 3 where the combined ingredients are boiled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with the initial cooking of the chicken and vegetables, and does not depend on the completion of Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must occur before they can be drained in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be completed before they can be drained in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur independently and prior to cooking the onion in butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which is independent of cooking the onion in butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which is independent of cooking the onion in butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which can be done independently of cooking the onion in butter as described in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which is independent of cooking the onion mixture in Step 6 and should be done early to ensure the oven is ready for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which is necessary before adding them to the pie, whereas Step 6 involves preparing the sauce, which are independent processes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables to cook them, which is independent of making the roux and sauce base in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before adding them to the pie dish in Step 11, independent of cooking the onion and making the sauce in Steps 5-9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking the onion in butter until soft, which needs to occur before adding flour and seasonings in Step 6 to create the roux for the pie's sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which is necessary to be ready for baking the pie in Step 15, and does not depend on the completion of Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which is necessary before combining them with the sauce made in steps 5-8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables to cook them, which is independent of making the sauce in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before combining them with the sauce created in steps 5-8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is necessary before adding flour and other ingredients in Step 6 to create the roux for the pie's sauce, which precedes adding liquids in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in flour and seasonings to cook with the onions and butter, which must occur before adding liquids in Step 7 to create a roux that thickens the mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which is necessary to be ready for baking the pie in Step 15, and does not depend on the completion of Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which is necessary before combining them with the sauce made in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables to cook them, which needs to occur before Step 8 where the sauce is thickened and later combined with the chicken mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before combining them with the sauce created in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is necessary before adding flour and other ingredients in Step 6 to create the sauce in Step 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in flour and seasonings which is necessary before adding liquids in Step 7 to create a thick sauce, hence it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves stirring in chicken stock and milk, which must occur before Step 8 where the mixture is simmered until thick.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be hot by the time the pie is ready to bake, and does not depend on the completion of Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which must be done before Step 9, where the sauce is prepared to pour over the chicken mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before creating the sauce in steps 5-9 and assembling the pie.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before combining them with the sauce created in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is necessary before adding flour and other ingredients in Steps 6 and 7 to create the sauce, which must be done before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding flour and seasonings to the onions cooked in butter, which is necessary before adding the chicken stock and milk in Step 7 to create the thick sauce, thus it must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves stirring in chicken stock and milk into the flour mixture to create a sauce, which must occur before Step 9 where the sauce is removed from heat after thickening.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce from heat after it has thickened, which does not affect the thickening process completed in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before preparing the pie components to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11, thus it cannot happen after Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are added to the pie dish in Step 11, not after lining the pie dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is part of preparing the sauce, and this needs to be done before the sauce is poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12, which occurs after the pie dish is prepared in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the roux and seasonings which is necessary to thicken the sauce before it is added to the pie in Step 12, thus it must occur before Step 10 where the pie dish is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves creating the sauce for the pie filling, which needs to be completed before the chicken mixture is placed into the pie dish in Step 11 and covered with this sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce mixture until thick, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, which occurs after Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves setting aside the sauce mixture, which can be done independently of preparing the pie dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before placing the pie in the oven (Step 15), which is well before Step 11 where the chicken mixture is placed in the pie dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are combined with the sauce in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is necessary before combining them with other ingredients in Step 6 to 8 to create the sauce, which is then poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the sauce by adding flour and seasonings to the onions, which must be done before combining it with the chicken mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves creating the sauce by adding and thickening the chicken stock and milk, which needs to be poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12, thus it must occur before placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce until thick, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce mixture from heat and setting it aside, which can be done before or simultaneously as the chicken mixture is placed in the pie dish in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves preparing the pie dish with pastry, which must be done before placing the chicken mixture into it as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before placing the pie in the oven (Step 15), not after assembling the pie (Step 12).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must occur before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11 and covered with the liquid mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11 and covered with the liquid mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are combined with the sauce in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter which is necessary before adding other ingredients to create the sauce in steps 6-8, which is then poured over the chicken mixture in step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the roux with flour and seasonings which is essential before adding liquids in Step 7 to create the thick sauce needed before assembling the pie in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves creating the sauce by adding chicken stock and milk to the roux, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 must occur before Step 12 to ensure the liquid mixture is thickened before being poured over the chicken mixture in the pie dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce mixture from heat after it thickens, which must occur before Step 12 where this hot liquid mixture is poured over the chicken in the pie dish.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves preparing the pie dish with pastry before adding the chicken and liquid mixtures, which are added in steps 11 and 12 respectively.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish, which logically precedes pouring the liquid mixture over it in Step 12 to ensure proper layering and distribution within the pie.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before placing the pie in the oven (Step 15), which is before sealing the pie with pastry (Step 13).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish in Step 11 and before being covered with pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish and baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are combined with the sauce in Step 12 and placed in the pie dish, well before sealing the pie with pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter, which is necessary before combining them with other ingredients in Step 6 to 8 to create the sauce for the pie filling, all of which must be completed before assembling the pie in Step 11 to 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the sauce by adding flour and seasonings, which must be done before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, thus it cannot occur after Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves creating the sauce by adding and simmering chicken stock and milk, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, which occurs before covering with pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce until thick, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, which occurs before covering with pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce mixture from heat and setting it aside, which can be completed before covering the pie with pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves lining the pie dish with pastry, which must occur before placing the chicken mixture and liquid mixture into the dish (Steps 11 and 12), and before covering with top pastry and sealing (Step 13).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish, which must occur before Step 13 where the pie is covered with top pastry and sealed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the liquid mixture over the chicken in the pie dish, which must be done before covering with the top pastry in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the pie in Step 15, not after Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must occur before they are placed in the pie dish and baked in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie dish and baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must occur before they are combined with the sauce and pastry in subsequent steps, well before the baking step (Step 14).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter, which is necessary before adding other ingredients to create the sauce in steps 6-8, all of which occur before assembling and baking the pie in steps 10-15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the sauce by adding flour and seasonings, which must occur before the sauce is poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12 and before the pie is baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves creating the sauce by adding chicken stock and milk to the cooked flour mixture, which needs to be done before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before sealing the pie with pastry in Step 13 and making slits in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce mixture until thick, which needs to be completed before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before the pastry is sealed and slit in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce from heat after thickening, which is necessary before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before covering with pastry and making slits in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves preparing the pie dish with pastry, which must occur before adding the fillings and covering with top pastry in Step 13, thus it cannot happen after Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish, which must occur before Step 14 where the pie is covered with top pastry and prepared for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the liquid mixture over the chicken in the pie dish, which must occur before covering with top pastry in Step 13 and making slits in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves covering the pie with pastry and sealing the edges, which must be completed before making slits in the top pastry as described in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the pie in Step 15 to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must occur before they are placed in the pie dish and baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are placed in the pie and baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which must be done before they are added to the pie dish in Step 11, well before the baking process in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter, which is necessary before adding other ingredients to create the sauce in steps 6-8, which is then poured over the chicken mixture in step 12 before baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the sauce by adding flour and seasonings, which must occur before the sauce is poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12 and baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves stirring in chicken stock and milk to create the sauce, which must be done before it is poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before the baking step (Step 15).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce until thick, which needs to occur before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before the baking process in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce from heat and setting it aside, which must occur before it is poured over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before the baking process in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves preparing the pie dish with pastry, which must be done before filling it with the chicken mixture and baking (Steps 11-15), not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish, which must occur before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the liquid mixture over the chicken in the pie dish, which must occur before baking the pie (Step 15) to ensure the filling is complete and ready for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 must occur before Step 15 as it involves sealing and preparing the pie before it is baked in the oven.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 must occur before Step 15 as it involves making slits in the pastry to allow steam to escape during baking, which must be done before the pie is placed in the oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 105, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the pie in Step 15, not after serving it in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 106, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining and boiling the chicken and vegetables, which is essential to prepare the filling before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 107, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves boiling the chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before assembling the pie in Step 11, thus it must occur before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 108, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the boiled chicken and vegetables, which is necessary before they are combined with the sauce and baked in the pie, all of which occur before Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 109, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooking onions in butter, which is necessary to prepare the sauce before assembling the pie, thus it must occur before the pie is baked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 110, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the sauce for the pie filling, which must be done before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 111, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves stirring in chicken stock and milk to make the sauce, which must be done before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 112, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves simmering the sauce until thick, which is necessary before pouring it over the chicken mixture in Step 12, well before the pie is baked and cooled in Steps 15 and 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 113, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves removing the sauce from heat and setting it aside before assembling the pie, which must occur before baking the pie in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 114, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves preparing the pie dish with pastry, which must occur before the baking process in Step 15, and thus cannot happen after the pie has been baked and cooled in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 115, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves placing the chicken mixture in the pie dish, which must occur before baking (Step 15) and cooling (Step 16); thus, it cannot happen after Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 116, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the hot liquid mixture over the chicken in the pie dish, which must occur before baking (Step 15), and cooling (Step 16) happens after the pie is baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 117, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves covering the pie with pastry and must occur before baking (Step 15), which is before cooling (Step 16).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 118, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14, making slits in the top pastry, must occur before baking (Step 15) to allow steam to escape during cooking, not after the pie has been baked and cooled (Step 16).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 10, "title": "chicken and vegetable pie", "question_idx": 119, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.", "In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.", "Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.", "Remove from heat, drain and set aside.", "In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.", "Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.", "Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.", "Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.", "Remove from heat and set aside.", "Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.", "Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.", "Pour hot liquid mixture over.", "Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.", "Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.", "Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.", "Cool for 10 minutes before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken and vegetable pie\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 220 C / Gas mark 7.\n2. In a saucepan, combine chicken, carrots, peas and celery.\n3. Add water to cover and boil for 15 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, drain and set aside.\n5. In the saucepan over medium heat, cook onion in butter until soft and translucent.\n6. Stir in flour, salt, pepper and celery seed.\n7. Slowly stir in chicken stock and milk.\n8. Simmer over medium-low heat until thick.\n9. Remove from heat and set aside.\n10. Prepare a 23cm (9 in) pie dish by lining with pastry, reserving pastry to cover.\n11. Place the chicken mixture in bottom of the prepared pie dish.\n12. Pour hot liquid mixture over.\n13. Cover with top pastry, seal edges, and cut away excess pastry.\n14. Make several small slits in the top to allow steam to escape.\n15. Bake in the preheated oven for 30 to 35 minutes, or until pastry is golden brown and filling is bubbly.\n16. Cool for 10 minutes before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves baking the pie which must occur before Step 16, where the pie is allowed to cool after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which needs to be ready before heating the oil in Step 2 for frying.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 3 because the prawns and chicken mixture needs to be prepared before it can be added to the hot oil in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 3 as the oil needs to be heated before adding the prawns and chicken mixture to cook.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which must be done before cooking them in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating the oil which is necessary before frying the prawns and chicken mixture in Step 3, and does not depend on the draining process described in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must happen before Step 4 as it involves adding the prawns and chicken mixture to the hot oil, which is then cooked and subsequently drained in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which is essential before cooking in Step 3 and adding to the soup in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which must be done before adding them to the soup in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which must be done before adding it to the soup ingredients in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture before it is added to the soup ingredients in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which must be cooked in Step 3, before adding to the soup base in Step 5, which occurs before bringing the mixture to a boil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which must be done before adding them to the soup base in Step 5, not after bringing the soup to a boil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the prawns and chicken mixture before it is added to the soup mixture in Step 5, which is before bringing it to a boil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture before it is added to the soup ingredients in Step 5, which precedes bringing the mixture to a boil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves combining ingredients in the pot which must occur before bringing them to a boil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which needs to be cooked in Step 3, well before adding seasonings in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which is essential before adding them to the soup in Step 5, and is unrelated to the addition of salt and sherry in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the prawns and chicken mixture, which needs to be done before adding it to the soup base in Step 5, which precedes Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture, which needs to occur before adding it to the soup in Step 5, well before seasoning with salt and sherry in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves combining the main ingredients in the pot and bringing them to a boil, which is necessary before seasoning with salt and sherry in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the soup to a boil before adding salt and sherry in Step 7, which is then followed by returning the mixture to a boil in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture, which must be cooked in Step 3, well before reaching Step 8 in the procedure.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which is independent of the boiling process described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding the prawns and chicken mixture to hot oil for cooking, which is necessary before adding them to the soup base in Step 5, well before the soup is brought back to a boil in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture, which must occur before adding it to the soup in Step 5, well before bringing the soup to a second boil in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding the fried mixture to the pot with other ingredients and must occur before boiling (Step 6) and re-boiling (Step 8).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the mixture to a boil initially, while Step 8 is about returning it to a boil after adding salt and sherry, indicating that Step 8 cannot occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding salt and sherry before returning the mixture to the boil in Step 8, indicating that Step 7 should occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture, which is essential to be done before cooking in Step 3 and adding to the soup in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which must occur before they are added to the soup in Step 5, not after Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the prawns and chicken mixture, which needs to be done before adding it to the soup base in Step 5, which precedes Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture, which must occur before adding them to the soup in Step 5, well before the simmering in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves combining the fried mixture with other ingredients and must occur before boiling and simmering in Steps 6 and 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the mixture to a boil initially, while Step 9 involves simmering the soup after it has returned to a boil in Step 8, indicating that Step 6 must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves adding salt and sherry, occurs before Step 9, where the heat is reduced to allow the soup to simmer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which is returning the soup to a boil, logically precedes Step 9, where the heat is reduced to allow the soup to simmer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which is needed in Step 3, well before the rice is browned in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, while Step 10 involves heating oil for browning the rice, and these processes are independent of each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the prawns and chicken mixture, which is essential before adding it to the soup base in Step 5, while Step 10 involves heating oil for browning the rice, which is added later in Step 12, indicating these steps are independent in sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture before adding it to the soup in Step 5, which must occur before browning the rice in Step 11 and adding it to the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding the fried prawns and chicken to the soup base and must occur before Step 10, which involves frying the rice to be added later to the already simmering soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the soup mixture to a boil, which is independent of Step 10 where additional oil is heated for browning the rice; these steps can occur simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves adding salt and sherry to the soup, which can be done independently of heating and browning the rice in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves returning the soup to a boil, is independent of Step 10, where additional oil is heated for browning the rice.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 (simmering the soup) and Step 10 (heating oil for the rice) can occur simultaneously as they involve different components and do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which is needed in Step 3, well before the rice is browned in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which is independent and occurs prior to the frying of rice in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the prawns and chicken mixture, which is independent of browning the rice in Step 11, and both steps contribute separately to the final soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture, which is independent of browning the rice in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves combining the cooked prawns and chicken with other ingredients to start the soup, which can proceed independently of the rice browning in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the soup mixture to a boil, which can occur independently of browning the rice in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves adding salt and sherry, is part of the soup's seasoning process and does not depend on the browning of the rice in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves returning the soup to a boil, is independent of Step 11, which involves browning the rice in oil; both steps can proceed simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the soup to develop flavors, which can occur independently and concurrently with frying the rice in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves heating oil which is a preparation step for Step 11 where rice is added and browned, so Step 10 must occur before Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the prawns and chicken mixture which is essential before cooking and adding to the soup in subsequent steps, making it necessary to occur before Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which is independent and occurs prior to the rice browning in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the prawns and chicken mixture, which must occur before adding it to the soup in Step 5, while Step 12 involves adding the browned rice to the already simmering soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture before adding it to the soup in Step 5, which must occur before adding the browned rice in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding the fried prawns and chicken mixture to the pot with other ingredients to start the soup, which must occur before adding the browned rice in Step 12 to complete the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves bringing the soup mixture to a boil, which is necessary before simmering in Step 9, and this must occur before the rice is added in Step 12 to ensure proper cooking and integration of flavors.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves adding salt and sherry, is part of the seasoning process and occurs before the rice is added in Step 12, as per the sequence in the procedure.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves returning the soup to a boil, is part of the soup preparation process and occurs before the rice is browned and added to the soup in Steps 10-12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the soup to develop flavors, which can occur concurrently with or before browning the rice in Step 11 and adding it in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which involves heating oil and browning the rice, must occur before Step 12, where the browned rice is added to the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves browning the rice in oil, which must occur before adding it to the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before cooking and adding the prawns and chicken to the soup, which happens before Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves heating oil for frying the prawns and chicken mixture, which must occur before they are added to the soup in subsequent steps, not after the soup is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 13 as it involves cooking the prawns and chicken which are essential components of the soup prepared in the subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 5 as it involves draining the cooked prawns and chicken mixture which is then used in the soup preparation in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves combining the cooked prawns and chicken with other ingredients to create the soup base, which must occur before adding the browned rice in Step 12, thus it cannot happen after Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves bringing the soup to a boil, must occur before Step 13, where the soup is served, to ensure all ingredients are properly cooked and integrated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves adding salt and sherry, occurs before the soup is served in Step 13, as part of the soup's flavoring process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves returning the soup to a boil, must occur before the soup simmers and other ingredients are added, as indicated in steps 9 through 12, all of which precede serving the soup in step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the soup to develop flavors, which must be completed before Step 13 where the soup is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 must occur before Step 12, as the rice needs to be heated and browned before it can be added to the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 must occur before Step 13 because the rice needs to be browned and added to the soup before it can be served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 11, "title": "chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.", "Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.", "When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.", "Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.", "Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.", "Bring to the boil.", "Add salt and sherry.", "Return to the boil.", "Reduce heat and allow to simmer.", "Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.", "Add rice and brown quickly.", "Drain and add to soup.", "Serve and enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicken-prawn-and-rice-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the prawns, chicken, egg and cornflour.\n2. Heat 750ml of the oil in wok or deep frying pan.\n3. When it is hot, add prawns and chicken mixture.\n4. Cook for 1/2 minute and drain.\n5. Place above mixture in pot with the stock, mushrooms, water chestnuts, bamboo shoots and green beans.\n6. Bring to the boil.\n7. Add salt and sherry.\n8. Return to the boil.\n9. Reduce heat and allow to simmer.\n10. Meanwhile, heat the remaining 250ml oil until it is hot.\n11. Add rice and brown quickly.\n12. Drain and add to soup.\n13. Serve and enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 must occur before Step 13 as the rice needs to be added to the soup before it is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 12, "title": "chicory-and-roquefort-salad", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.", "Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.", "Drizzle over salad."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicory-and-roquefort-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.\n2. Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.\n3. Drizzle over salad.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the main components of the salad, which should be done before adding the dressing made in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 12, "title": "chicory-and-roquefort-salad", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.", "Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.", "Drizzle over salad."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicory-and-roquefort-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.\n2. Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.\n3. Drizzle over salad.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves assembling the main ingredients of the salad, which must be done before the dressing is drizzled over it in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 12, "title": "chicory-and-roquefort-salad", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.", "Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.", "Drizzle over salad."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chicory-and-roquefort-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a bowl, toss chicory, Roquefort and pecan nuts together.\n2. Make the dressing by mixing together cream cheese, yoghurt and salt and pepper.\n3. Drizzle over salad.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves making the dressing which needs to be ready before it can be drizzled over the salad in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with melting the chocolate in the microwave as described in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with or before melting the chocolate in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves placing ingredients in a bowl to prepare for microwaving, which logically must occur before Step 3, where the ingredients are actually microwaved.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with the chocolate melting process in steps 2 to 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which must occur before Step 4 where the melted chocolate is whisked until smooth.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves microwaving the chocolate mixture until almost melted, which must occur before Step 4 where the mixture is whisked until smooth.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be hot by the time the cake mixture is ready to bake, and does not depend on the cooling of the chocolate mixture in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added to the mix in Step 10, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to be cooled before being added to the cake mix in Step 10, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture until smooth, must occur before Step 5, where the mixture is set aside to cool, to ensure it is smooth and homogeneous before cooling.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking the cake in Step 17, and is independent of beating butter and margarine in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate mixture which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, and does not depend on the creaming of butter and sugar done in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added to the batter in Step 10, independent of the creaming of butter and sugar in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture until smooth, must occur before it cools and is added to the batter in Step 10, and does not depend on the creaming of butter and margarine in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 (cooling the chocolate mixture) can occur simultaneously with Step 6 (beating butter and margarine), as these processes do not interfere with each other.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cake mixture is prepared.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, and does not depend on the creaming of butter and sugar done in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, and does not depend on the creaming of butter and sugar or the addition of egg yolks done in Steps 6, 7, and 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which needs to be done before it cools and is added to the batter in Step 10, independent of the creaming of butter and sugar in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before it is added to the batter in Step 10, independent of the creaming of butter and sugar in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine until creamy, which is a preparation step that does not depend on the addition of sugar in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking in Step 17, and is independent of beating in egg yolks in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, and does not depend on the completion of Step 8, which involves beating in egg yolks.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, whereas Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is independent of the chocolate melting process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which is independent of and precedes the creaming of butter, sugar, and egg yolks in steps 6-8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before it is added to the batter in Step 10, independent of the addition of egg yolks in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which can be done independently before adding sugar and egg yolks in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating butter and margarine until creamy, which can be done independently before gradually adding sugar as described in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking the cake in Step 17, but it does not depend on the completion of Step 9, which involves adding flour to the batter.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, thus it must occur before the flour is added in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, thus it must occur before adding the flour in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which needs to occur before it cools and is added to the batter in Step 10, independent of the flour addition in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be added in Step 10, before the flour is added in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine which is a separate process from adding flour in Step 9, and does not depend on the flour being added first.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which must occur before adding flour in Step 9 to ensure proper creaming and texture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the butter and sugar mixture, while Step 9 involves adding flour, both steps are independent in terms of their ingredients and can be performed in any order as long as they are done before combining with other mixtures.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, and is independent of adding the cooled chocolate in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added in Step 10, thus it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate which needs to be cooled before being added to the mix in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must happen before Step 10 because the chocolate mixture needs to be smooth and cooled before it can be added to the other ingredients.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 10 as the chocolate needs to be cooled before it is added to the mix.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves creaming the butter and margarine, which must be done before adding the chocolate mixture from Step 10 to ensure proper texture and mixing.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture to create a light and fluffy base, which must be completed before adding the cooled chocolate mixture in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which must be completed before adding the flour and chocolate mixture in Steps 9 and 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the butter, sugar, and egg yolk mixture, which must be done before adding the cooled chocolate mixture in Step 10 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking the cake in Step 17, and is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate which needs to cool before being added to the batter in Step 10, well before the egg whites are beaten in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate which needs to cool before being added to the batter in Step 10, while Step 11 involves beating the egg whites which are folded into the batter after the chocolate is added.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which needs to occur before it cools and is added to the batter in Step 10, well before beating the egg whites in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be added to the batter in Step 10, before the egg whites are beaten in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves creaming the butter and margarine, which is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 11 and can be completed before the egg whites are needed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which needs to be done before the egg whites are beaten and folded into the mixture in Steps 11 and 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate mixture to the batter, which can be done independently of beating the egg whites in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, and is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to cool before being added to the mix in Step 10, well before beating the egg whites in Step 11 and 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate which needs to be cooled and added to the batter before the egg whites are beaten in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture until smooth, must occur before adding it to the cake batter in Step 10, and is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before adding it to the batter in Step 10, independent of beating the egg whites in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves creaming butter and margarine, which can be done independently of beating the egg whites in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is independent of beating the egg whites in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, while Step 12 involves beating egg whites until stiff, and these processes are independent of each other.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which can be done before beating the egg whites in Step 12, as these processes are independent until they are combined in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate mixture to the batter, which can be done before beating the egg whites in Step 11 and 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites until foamy, which is a necessary initial stage before they can be beaten to stiff peaks in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, and is independent of folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to be cooled and added to the batter in Step 10, well before folding in the egg whites in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate which needs to be cooled and added to the mix in Step 10, before the egg whites are beaten and folded into the mixture in Steps 11-13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture until smooth, must occur before adding it to the cake batter in Step 10, and thus cannot happen after Step 13 where the egg whites are folded into the chocolate mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before it is added to the mix in Step 10, well before folding in the egg whites in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves creaming butter and margarine, which is necessary before adding other ingredients like sugar, egg yolks, and flour in subsequent steps, all of which need to be completed before folding in the egg whites prepared in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture to make it light and fluffy, which is necessary before adding other ingredients like egg yolks and flour, and must be completed before the chocolate and egg whites are incorporated in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which must be completed before the chocolate mixture is created and the egg whites are folded in at Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which needs to be done before folding in the beaten egg whites in Step 13 to ensure proper structure and mixing.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate mixture to the batter, which must occur before the egg whites are folded into the mixture in Step 13 to ensure proper incorporation and texture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites until foamy and then stiff, which must occur before they can be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the egg whites until stiff, which needs to be completed before they can be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 14, greasing and preparing the cake tin, to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cake mixture is prepared and poured.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is needed before it can be added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before greasing the tin in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to be cooled and added to the batter in Step 10, well before greasing the cake tin in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which needs to be done before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before greasing the tin in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before it is added to the cake mix in Step 10, well before greasing the cake tin in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is part of preparing the cake batter, while Step 14 is about preparing the cake tin, which can be done independently and at any time before pouring the batter.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is part of preparing the cake batter, while Step 14 involves preparing the cake tin, which can be done independently and at any time before pouring the batter.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which must be completed before adding the chocolate and flour mixtures in later steps, and is independent of preparing the cake tin as described in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which must be done before the batter is poured into the cake tin in Step 16, and thus before the tin is prepared in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the cake mix, which needs to be done before the mixture is poured into the cake tin in Step 16, and thus before greasing the tin in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites which needs to be done before they are folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, which occurs before greasing the tin in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the egg whites until stiff, which needs to be done before they are folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, which precedes greasing the cake tin in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which needs to be completed before the mixture is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before preparing the cake batter to ensure the oven is ready for baking when the cake mixture is prepared.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which needs to cool before being added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before greasing and preparing the tin in Step 14 and Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which needs to be cooled and added to the batter in Step 10, well before preparing the cake tin in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which needs to occur before it cools and is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before preparing the cake tin in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before it is added to the cake mix in Step 10, well before preparing the cake tin in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is part of preparing the cake batter, while Step 15 is about preparing the cake tin, which can be done independently and does not affect the batter preparation.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is part of preparing the cake batter, whereas Step 15 is about preparing the cake tin, which is done after the batter is ready.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is part of preparing the cake batter, whereas Step 15 is about preparing the cake tin, which can be done independently of the batter preparation.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which needs to be done before the batter is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate mixture to the cake batter, which needs to be done before the batter is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites which must be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, before the mixture is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the egg whites until stiff, which needs to be done before they are folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, which occurs before greasing and preparing the cake tin in Step 14 and Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which needs to be done before the mixture is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing the cake tin, which can be done independently and prior to wrapping the bottom of the tin with greaseproof paper or foil in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 105, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 16, pouring the mixture into the cake tin, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 106, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is essential before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, well before pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 107, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which must be cooled and added to the batter before it is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 108, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which must be done before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 109, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 10, where the cooled chocolate mixture is added to the cake batter, which is before pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 110, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 111, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is essential for creating the cake batter before it is poured into the tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 112, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which must be done before adding this mixture to the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 113, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 114, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the mix and beating again, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 115, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites until foamy and stiff, which must be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13 before the mixture is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 116, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the egg whites until stiff, which must be done before they are folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, prior to pouring the mixture into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 117, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture to complete the batter before it is poured into the cake tin in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 118, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 119, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15, which involves wrapping the bottom of the tin with greaseproof paper or foil, should occur before pouring the mixture into the tin in Step 16 to prevent leakage and ensure easy removal.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 120, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 121, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is essential before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, well before baking in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 122, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is necessary before it can be mixed with other ingredients in subsequent steps, well before baking in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 123, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which must occur before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before baking in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 124, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the melted chocolate mixture, which must be done before adding it to the cake batter in Step 10, well before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 125, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 126, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is necessary before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 127, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 128, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 129, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the mix and beating again, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 130, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites which must be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13 before baking in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 131, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the egg whites until stiff, which is necessary before folding them into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, prior to baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 132, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the beaten egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 133, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it in Step 16, and thus before baking in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 134, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the tin in Step 16 and subsequently baking in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 135, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before Step 17 where the cake is baked in the oven.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 136, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake (Step 17), not after.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 137, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 138, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is necessary before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, well before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 139, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which must occur before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the baking process in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 140, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the melted chocolate mixture, which must be done before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the baking process in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 141, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is part of the preparation of the cake batter, and must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 142, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is part of the cake batter preparation before baking, whereas Step 18 is checking if the cake is done after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 143, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is part of the cake batter preparation, and must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 144, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which is necessary before baking the cake in Step 17; it cannot occur after the cake is baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 145, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the mix and beating again, which is part of the cake batter preparation before baking, whereas Step 18 is checking if the cake is done after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 146, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating the egg whites which must be folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13 before baking, which occurs in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 147, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating egg whites until stiff, which is necessary before folding them into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, well before the baking process in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 148, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the beaten egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 149, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it and baking (Steps 16 and 17), not after the cake is baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 150, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must be done before pouring the mixture in and baking it as described in Steps 16 and 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 151, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before baking the cake as described in Step 17 and checking its readiness in Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 152, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves baking the cake, which must occur before checking its doneness with a skewer in Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 153, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, not after the cake has baked and potentially cracked as described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 154, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, thus it must occur long before Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 155, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is necessary before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, long before the baking and cooling process described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 156, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which is necessary before incorporating it into the cake batter in later steps, well before baking and cooling as described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 157, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the melted chocolate mixture, which must occur before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the baking process described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 158, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is necessary for preparing the cake batter before baking, while Step 19 occurs after the cake has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 159, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is part of the cake batter preparation, and must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 160, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 19 occurs after the cake has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 161, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which is part of the cake preparation process before baking, whereas Step 19 describes the cake's appearance after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 162, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the mix and beating again, which is part of the cake batter preparation before baking, whereas Step 19 occurs after the cake has been baked and is observing the physical characteristics of the cake.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 163, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating egg whites which are then folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, well before the baking process in Step 17 and the cracking mentioned in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 164, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating egg whites until stiff, which is necessary before folding them into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, well before the baking process described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 165, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17; Step 19 describes the cake's appearance after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 166, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it and baking (Steps 16 and 17), which occur before the cake cracks during baking as noted in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 167, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must be done before pouring the mixture in and baking as described in Steps 16 and 17, not after the cake has baked as described in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 168, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before baking (Step 17) and before the cake can crack during baking (Step 19).\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 169, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves baking the cake, which must occur before observing the top cracking as described in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 170, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18 involves checking if the cake is done, which must occur before or as the cake finishes baking, while Step 19 describes a potential outcome of the baking process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 171, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, not after cooling the cake as described in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 172, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture, which is essential before mixing and baking the cake, steps that occur long before Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 173, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is necessary before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, well before the cake is baked and cooled in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 174, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which is necessary before adding it to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the cake is baked and cooled in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 175, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the melted chocolate mixture, which must occur before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the cake is baked and cooled in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 176, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is part of the initial mixing process and must occur before the baking process in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 177, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is part of the cake batter preparation, and must occur before baking the cake in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 178, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 20 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 179, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17; Step 20 involves cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 180, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the mix and beating again, which is part of the cake batter preparation before baking, whereas Step 20 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 181, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating egg whites which are then folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, long before the cake is baked and cooled in Steps 17 and 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 182, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating egg whites until stiff, which is necessary before folding them into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, well before the cake is baked and cooled in Steps 17 and 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 183, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which must be done before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 20 involves cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 184, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it and baking (Steps 16 and 17), which occur before cooling in the tin (Step 20).\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 185, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must occur before Step 20, where the cake is allowed to cool in the tin after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 186, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before baking (Step 17) and cooling (Step 20).\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 187, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves baking the cake, which must occur before it can cool in the tin as described in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 188, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18 checks if the cake is done baking, which must occur before it cools in the tin as described in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 189, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 19 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 19 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 19 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 19 describes a potential occurrence during baking (Step 17), which naturally happens before cooling in Step 20.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 190, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, not after the cake has cooled as described in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 191, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture, which is essential before mixing and baking the cake, thus it must occur long before the cake is cooled and decorated in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 192, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is necessary before mixing it into the batter in Step 10, long before the cake is baked and cooled in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 193, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which is necessary before adding it to the cake batter in Step 10, long before the cake is baked and cooled as described in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 194, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the melted chocolate mixture, which is necessary before adding it to the batter in Step 10, long before the cake is baked and cooled in Step 21.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 195, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and baking, thus it must occur before the cake is baked and subsequently cooled as described in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 196, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 21 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 197, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 21 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 198, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 21 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 199, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the cake mix, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 21 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 200, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating egg whites which are then folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, well before the cake is baked and cooled in Steps 17 and 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 201, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating egg whites until stiff, which is necessary before folding them into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, long before the cake is baked and cooled as described in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 202, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 21 is about cooling the cake after it has been baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 203, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture into it and baking (Steps 16 and 17), not after the cake has cooled and been removed from the tin as described in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 204, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must occur before the cake is baked in Step 17 and subsequently cooled in Step 21.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 205, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before baking (Step 17) and cooling (Step 20 and 21), hence it cannot happen after Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 206, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves baking the cake, which must occur before Step 21 where the cake is removed from the tin after cooling.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 207, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18 must occur before Step 21 as it involves checking if the cake is properly baked before it cools and is removed from the tin.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 208, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 19 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 19 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 19 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 19, which notes that the cake may crack during baking, occurs during the baking process (Step 17), while Step 21 involves cooling the cake after it has been removed from the oven.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 209, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 20 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 20 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 20 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 20 involves cooling the cake in the tin to set it before removal, which logically precedes Step 21 where the cake is removed from the tin and allowed to cool completely.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 210, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, not after decorating it in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 211, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the chocolate mixture which is essential for making the cake batter in the subsequent steps, long before the decoration step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 212, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves melting the chocolate, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 22 is the final decoration step after the cake has been baked and cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 213, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves whisking the melted chocolate mixture to smoothness, which is essential before adding it to other ingredients in later steps, whereas Step 22 is the final decoration step after the cake has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 214, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling the chocolate mixture, which must occur before it is added to the cake batter in Step 10, well before the decoration step in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 215, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating butter and margarine, which is part of the cake batter preparation and must occur before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 22 is the final decoration step after the cake has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 216, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating sugar into the butter and margarine mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 22 is a final decorative step after the cake has been baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 217, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves beating egg yolks into the sugar and butter mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 22 is a final decorative step after the cake has been baked and cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 218, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding flour to the batter, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 22 is for decoration after the cake has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 219, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding the cooled chocolate to the cake mix, which is essential before baking the cake in Step 17, whereas Step 22 is the final decoration step after the cake has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 220, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves beating egg whites which are then folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, a necessary step before baking the cake in Step 17, which occurs long before decorating with icing sugar in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 221, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12, which involves beating egg whites until stiff, must occur before they are folded into the chocolate mixture in Step 13, which is well before the decoration step (Step 22).\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 222, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves folding the egg whites into the chocolate mixture, which is essential for preparing the cake batter before baking, whereas Step 22 is a final decorative step after the cake has cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 223, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves greasing and preparing the cake tin, which must be done before pouring the mixture and baking in Step 16 and 17, whereas Step 22 is for decoration after the cake has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 224, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves preparing the cake tin before baking, which must occur before Step 22 where the cake is decorated after it has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 225, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves pouring the mixture into the cake tin, which must occur before baking and cooling as described in steps 17 through 21, all of which precede the decoration step in 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 226, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves baking the cake, which must occur before cooling and decorating with icing sugar in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 227, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18, checking if the cake is done, must occur before Step 22, which involves decorating the completely cooled cake.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 228, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 19 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 19 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 19 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 19, which notes the potential for the cake's top to crack during baking, occurs naturally during the baking process in Step 17, well before the decoration step in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 229, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 20 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 20 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 20 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 20 involves cooling the cake in the tin to set before removing it, which must occur before Step 22 where the cake is decorated with icing sugar after it has completely cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 13, "title": "chocolate-chocolate-cake", "question_idx": 230, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.", "Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.", "Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.", "Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.", "Set aside to cool.", "Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.", "Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.", "Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.", "Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.", "Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.", "In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.", "Then increase speed and beat until stiff.", "Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.", "Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.", "Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.", "Pour the mixture into the cake tin.", "Bake for I hour.", "The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.", "Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.", "Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.", "Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.", "Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 21 happen after Step 22?", "why_question": "Why must Step 21 happen after Step 22?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-chocolate-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 degrees C / Gas Mark 4.\n2. Place the chocolate chips, coffee and water in a microwave safe bowl.\n3. Microwave until chocolate is almost melted.\n4. Remove and whisk until mixture is smooth.\n5. Set aside to cool.\n6. Using a hand held mixer, beat butter and margarine together in a large bowl until creamy.\n7. Gradually beat in sugar until light and fluffy.\n8. Gradually beat in egg yolks one at a time, beating well after each one.\n9. Slowly add the flour and beat at a low speed.\n10. Add the cooled chocolate to the mix and beat again.\n11. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites until foamy.\n12. Then increase speed and beat until stiff.\n13. Fold egg white mixture, one third at a time, into the chocolate mixture until blended thoroughly.\n14. Grease a 23cm springform tin or a cake tin with deep sides.\n15. Wrap the bottom of the tin securely with greaseproof paper or foil, so it comes up about 1 .5cm on the sides.\n16. Pour the mixture into the cake tin.\n17. Bake for I hour.\n18. The cake is ready when a skewer inserted about 1 .5cm from the side of the tin comes out clean.\n19. Note that the cake is very dense, so the top may crack when baking.\n20. Cool in the tin for 10 minutes to allow the cake to set.\n21. Then remove from the tin, and allow to cool completely, which may take several hours.\n22. Sift icing sugar lightly over the top for decoration.\n\n\n1. Must Step 21 happen after Step 22?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 21 involves removing the cake from the tin and allowing it to cool completely, which should be completed before sifting icing sugar on top in Step 22.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the dry mix before adding wet ingredients like eggs in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the dry mix before adding wet ingredients like eggs, milk, and butter in Steps 2 and 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding eggs to the dry ingredients to start forming the batter, which must occur before adding the liquid ingredients in Step 3 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the batter before it can rest in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves whisking eggs into the flour and cocoa mixture, which is essential before adding other liquid ingredients in Step 3 and must occur before the batter rests in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding and mixing the liquid ingredients into the dry ingredients to create the batter, which must be completed before Step 4, where the batter is allowed to rest.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the batter before cooking, thus it must occur before heating the pan in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding eggs to the sifted flour and cocoa powder, which is part of making the batter, and must occur before heating the pan in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the batter ingredients, which must be completed before heating the pan in Step 5 to cook the pancakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, can occur simultaneously with heating the pan in Step 5, as these actions do not interfere with each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the batter before cooking, while Step 6 is part of the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves incorporating eggs into the sifted flour and cocoa powder, which is part of making the batter, and must occur before heating the pan in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the batter ingredients, which needs to be completed before heating and greasing the pan in Step 6 for cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, is part of the batter preparation and does not depend on the heating or greasing of the pan described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the pan which should ideally be done before greasing it with oil in Step 6 to ensure the pan is hot when the batter is added.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is essential to prepare the batter before cooking, thus it must occur before Step 7 where the batter is poured into the pan.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding eggs to the flour and cocoa mixture to form the batter, which must be done before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the milk, melted butter, and sugar into the batter, which must be done before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, should occur before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 7 to allow the gluten in the batter to relax and the ingredients to meld, improving the texture of the pancakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, heating the pan, must occur before Step 7, pouring the batter, to ensure the pan is hot enough to cook the pancake properly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves greasing the pan before pouring the batter in Step 7, ensuring the batter does not stick; however, it can be done before heating the pan in Step 5 or after as long as the pan is greased before the batter is poured.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the batter before cooking, hence it must occur before Step 8 where the pancakes are cooked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding eggs to the flour and cocoa mixture to form the batter, which must be done before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the batter ingredients, which must be completed before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, should occur before cooking the pancakes (Step 8) to allow the gluten in the batter to relax and the ingredients to meld together.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the pan which must occur before Step 8 where the pancake is cooked in the heated pan.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves greasing the pan before cooking any pancakes, which is necessary to prevent sticking and must occur before Step 8 where the pancake is cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves pouring the batter into the pan, which must occur before Step 8 where the pancake is cooked and the edges start to crisp up.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to prepare the batter before cooking, thus it must occur before Step 9 where the pancakes are flipped during cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves incorporating eggs into the flour mixture to form the batter, which must be completed before cooking any pancakes as described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the initial ingredients to form the batter, which must be completed before cooking any pancakes as described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, must occur before cooking the pancakes (Steps 5-10), not after flipping them.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the pan which must occur before cooking the pancakes as described in Steps 7 to 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves greasing the pan before the initial cooking of the pancakes, not after flipping them as described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves pouring the batter into the pan to form a pancake, which must occur before Step 9, where the pancake is flipped to cook the other side.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooking the first side of the pancake, which must occur before flipping it in Step 9 to cook the other side.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to begin making the batter, and must occur before the batter can be cooked in steps 5-10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves whisking eggs into the flour and cocoa mixture, which is essential for creating the batter before any cooking begins, including the steps outlined in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding ingredients to create the batter, which must be completed before cooking the pancakes as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, must occur before cooking the pancakes (Steps 5-10) to ensure the batter develops the right texture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the pan which must occur before cooking the pancakes as described in steps 7 through 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves greasing the pan before the initial cooking of pancakes, and it is not dependent on the completion of Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves pouring batter into the pan to make a pancake, while Step 10 is about repeating the process with remaining batter, indicating that Step 7 must occur before Step 10 for each individual pancake.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooking the first side of a pancake, which must occur before flipping and cooking the other side (Step 9), and well before repeating the process with remaining batter as described in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves flipping a pancake to cook the other side, which must occur before removing the pancake from the pan and repeating the process with remaining batter as described in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the flour and cocoa powder, which is necessary to begin making the batter, and must occur before the batter can be cooked as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves whisking eggs into the flour mixture, which is essential for creating the batter before cooking, whereas Step 11 is about stacking the cooked pancakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves gradually whisking in milk, melted butter, and sugar into the batter, which must occur before cooking the pancakes as described in steps 5 through 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves letting the batter rest, must occur before cooking the pancakes (Steps 5-11), not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the pan which is necessary before cooking the pancakes (Steps 7-10), and must occur before Step 11 where the pancakes are stacked after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves greasing the pan before cooking each pancake, which must occur before Step 11 where pancakes are stacked after cooking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves pouring batter into the pan to make a pancake, which must occur before Step 11, where the pancakes are stacked after cooking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooking the pancake, which must occur before stacking the cooked pancakes in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves flipping the pancake to cook the other side, must occur before Step 11, where the cooked pancakes are stacked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 14, "title": "chocolate-pancake-batter", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.", "Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.", "Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.", "For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.", "Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.", "Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.", "Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.", "Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.", "Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.", "Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.", "Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: chocolate-pancake-batter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour and cocoa powder into a bowl.\n2. Make a well in the centre and whisk in the beaten eggs.\n3. Gradually whisk in milk, melted butter and sugar.\n4. For best results, set the pancake batter aside for 20 minutes to rest.\n5. Heat a heavy-based non-stick frying pan (about 20-22cm in diameter) over moderate heat.\n6. Use a piece of kitchen paper to grease the pan with a little sunflower oil.\n7. Use a soup ladle to pour some batter into the middle of the pan, just enough to create a slightly thicker pancake than a crepe.\n8. Cook for a minute or so until the pancake edges start to crisp up.\n9. Use a palette knife to flip the pancake and cook the other side, about 1 minute.\n10. Turn out of the pan and repeat with remaining batter, greasing the pan between pancakes if necessary.\n11. Stack the pancakes on top of each other to keep warm.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooking and turning out each pancake, which must occur before they can be stacked in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Preheating the oven can occur simultaneously with lining the baking tray, as these tasks do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which can be done independently and does not affect the mixing of ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which can be done independently and does not affect the mixing of ingredients in Steps 3 and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing cream cheese and egg yolks, which can be done independently of beating the egg whites in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the batter preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which needs to be ready before adding the batter in Step 7, and does not depend on the completion of Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the cream cheese and egg yolks, which needs to be completed before folding into the stiff egg whites created in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves placing ingredients in a bowl and must occur before Step 5, where these ingredients are beaten until stiff peaks form.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which needs to be ready before adding the batter in Step 7, not necessarily after folding the mixtures in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the cream cheese and egg yolks, which must be done before Step 6 where this mixture is folded into the egg whites.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 6 because the egg whites need to be beaten to stiff peaks before they can be folded into the cream cheese and egg yolk mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, beating the egg whites to stiff peaks, must occur before Step 6, where these beaten egg whites are folded into the cream cheese and egg yolk mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the cloud-bread in the oven (Step 8), not after preparing the batter (Step 7).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray before the batter is made and spooned onto it, which occurs in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the cream cheese and egg yolks, which must be done before they are folded into the egg whites in Step 6, prior to spooning onto the baking tray in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves beating the egg whites and baking powder until stiff peaks form, must occur before Step 6 where these beaten egg whites are folded into the cream cheese and egg yolk mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, beating the egg whites to stiff peaks, must occur before Step 6, where these beaten egg whites are folded into the cream cheese and egg yolk mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves combining the mixtures to create the batter, which must be done before spooning the batter onto the tray in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cloud-bread in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which must be done before placing the batter on it in Step 7 and baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the cream cheese and egg yolks, which is essential to prepare the batter before baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 8 because the egg whites need to be beaten to stiff peaks and combined with the other ingredients before the mixture can be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 8 because the egg whites need to be beaten to stiff peaks and combined with the other ingredients before the mixture can be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves folding the mixture into the egg whites to create the batter, which must be done before baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 15, "title": "cloud-bread", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.", "Line a baking tray with baking paper.", "Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.", "Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;", "beat together until stiff peaks form.", "Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.", "Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.", "Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cloud-bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas mark 2.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking paper.\n3. Mix cream cheese and egg yolks together until smooth.\n4. Place egg whites and baking powder in a glass, metal, or ceramic bowl;\n5. beat together until stiff peaks form.\n6. Fold cream cheese and egg yolk mixture gently into egg whites until just combined and light yellow in colour.\n7. Spoon the batter onto the prepared baking tray in mounds about 10cm in diameter, flattening peaks with the back of the spoon.\n8. Bake in the preheated oven until golden brown, 17 to 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves spooning and shaping the batter on the tray, which must be done before baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which can occur simultaneously with spreading the oats on the tray in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before Step 3, where the oats are toasted in the oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves spreading oats on a baking tray, which must occur before Step 3, where the oats are toasted in the oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before toasting the oats in Step 3, and is unrelated to the cooling process in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves spreading oats on a baking tray which must occur before toasting them in the oven (Step 3), and thus before they are set aside to cool (Step 4).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves setting aside the oats to cool after they have been toasted in Step 3, so Step 3 must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before toasting the oats in Step 3, while Step 5 involves cooling the oats after they have been toasted.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves spreading oats on a baking tray which must occur before they are toasted in Step 3 and subsequently cooled in Steps 4 and 5; thus, Step 2 does not depend on Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the oats from the tray to cool them faster after they have been toasted in Step 3, so Step 3 must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves setting the oats aside to cool, and Step 5 involves removing them from the tray to speed up cooling, which can be done simultaneously or in reverse order.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before toasting the oats in Step 3, and is unrelated to whipping the cream in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the oats which need to be cooled before being folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves toasting the oats which must be done before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling the toasted oats, which is independent of whipping the cream in Step 6 and can occur simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves removing the oats from the tray to cool, is independent of Step 6, where the cream is whipped, and can occur simultaneously or in any order relative to each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before toasting the oats in Step 3, which is necessary before they are folded into the cream in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves spreading oats to toast them, which must occur before Step 7 where the toasted oats are folded into the whipped cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 7 because the oats need to be toasted and cooled before they can be folded into the whipped cream mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling the toasted oats, must occur before Step 7 where the oats are folded into the whipped cream, to prevent the heat from affecting the cream's texture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 is related to cooling the oats and must occur before incorporating them into the cream mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves whipping the cream which must be done before folding in other ingredients in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before toasting the oats in Step 3, which occurs long before assembling the dessert in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the oats which are needed in Step 7, before the assembly of the dessert in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves toasting the oats which must be done before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, well before serving in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling the toasted oats, which must occur before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, well before serving in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves removing the oats from the tray to cool, logically occurs immediately after Step 4 and before incorporating the oats in Step 7, and is unrelated to the assembly and garnishing steps like Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves whipping the cream which needs to be done before folding in other ingredients in Step 7 and spooning into bowls in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves folding the toasted oats into the whipped cream mixture, which must be done before spooning the mixture into serving bowls in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before toasting the oats in Step 3, and is unrelated to the final garnishing steps including drizzling whisky.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the oats which are essential to be mixed with other ingredients in Step 7, long before the whisky drizzle in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves toasting the oats which is essential before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, well before whisky is drizzled in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling the toasted oats, which is necessary before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, well before whisky is drizzled in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves cooling the oats, must occur before Step 7 where the oats are folded into the cream, which is well before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Whipping the cream (Step 6) is essential before adding other ingredients and serving, while drizzling whisky (Step 9) is a final garnishing step that does not affect the preparation of the cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves folding the toasted oats into the whipped cream, which is essential before topping with berries and whisky in steps 8 and 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, drizzling whisky, can be done before or after topping with berries in Step 8, as it does not affect the placement or presentation of the berries.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before toasting the oats in Step 3, and must occur before Step 10 which involves garnishing the final dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves spreading oats to be toasted, which is essential before mixing them into the cream in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves toasting oats which is essential before they are mixed with other ingredients in Step 7, whereas Step 10 is the final garnishing step.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling the toasted oats, which is necessary before they are folded into the whipped cream in Step 7, well before garnishing with a mint leaf in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves removing the oats from the tray to cool, must occur before incorporating them into the cream mixture in Step 7, and long before garnishing in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves whipping the cream which is essential before folding in other ingredients and serving, whereas Step 10 is just garnishing, which is the final touch.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves folding ingredients into the whipped cream which is essential to form the base of the cranachan, whereas Step 10 is just garnishing, which is typically done after the dish is assembled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves spooning the mixture into serving bowls and topping with berries, which should be done before garnishing with a mint leaf in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 16, "title": "cranachan", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.", "Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.", "Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.", "Set aside to cool.", "Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.", "In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.", "Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.", "Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.", "For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.", "Garnish with a mint leaf."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: cranachan\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180 C / Gas mark 4.\n2. Spread oats out in a thin layer on a baking tray.\n3. Toast in the oven for about 10 minutes, or until lightly browned.\n4. Set aside to cool.\n5. Remove them from the tray for faster cooling.\n6. In a medium bowl, whip the cream to firm peaks.\n7. Gently fold in the icing sugar, vanilla and toasted oats.\n8. Spoon into 4 serving bowls, and top with fresh berries.\n9. For an extra touch, drizzle some whisky over each serving.\n10. Garnish with a mint leaf.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves drizzling whisky which can be done before garnishing with a mint leaf in Step 10, as these steps do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving stock in hot water, which can be done independently of melting butter in a saucepan as described in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving stock in hot water, which is independent of cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies in butter, and can be done beforehand.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter which is necessary before cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving the stock in hot water, which needs to be ready to add to the squash mixture in Step 5, thus it should occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing the onion, garlic, and chillies in Step 3, which precedes Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies until soft, which is necessary before adding the squash and other ingredients in Step 4 to ensure they are properly saut\u00e9ed in the flavored butter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5 because the dissolved stock is required in Step 5 to be added to the squash mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter to cook onions, garlic, and chillies, which must occur before adding the squash and stock in steps 4 and 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies in butter to soften the onion, which is essential before adding the squash and other ingredients in Step 4 and 5 for proper flavor development.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding and stirring the squash and seasonings before incorporating the stock in Step 5, so it does not need to happen after Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5, where the dissolved stock is added to the squash mixture, which is before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter to cook onions, garlic, and chillies, which must occur before adding the squash and stock in later steps, thus it cannot happen after Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies in butter, which is essential for flavor development before adding other ingredients like squash and stock in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding and stirring the squash and other ingredients before simmering, which is described in Step 7, following the covering in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves stirring in the stock and coriander, which must be done before covering and simmering the mixture in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5, where the dissolved stock is added to the squash mixture, which is before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter to cook onions, garlic, and chillies, which must occur before adding squash and stock in later steps, thus it cannot happen after Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves saut\u00e9ing the onion, garlic, and chillies, which must occur before simmering the mixture in Step 7 to develop the flavors.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding and stirring the squash and seasonings, which must occur before simmering the mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves stirring in the stock and coriander, which must occur before simmering the mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves covering the saucepan, must occur before Step 7, where the soup simmers, to ensure proper cooking and heat retention.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5, where the dissolved stock is added to the saucepan, which is well before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter in a saucepan which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing ingredients in subsequent steps, and cannot logically occur after the pureeing step (Step 8).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies in butter to soften the onion, which is essential before adding other ingredients and pureeing the mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding and stirring the squash with other ingredients, which is essential before pureeing the mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves stirring in the stock and coriander which is essential before simmering and pureeing the mixture in steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves covering the saucepan to simmer the soup, which must occur before pureeing the mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 must occur before Step 8 because the soup needs to be simmered to cook the squash thoroughly before it can be pureed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 5, where the dissolved stock is added to the soup, which is well before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting butter to cook ingredients, which is essential before blending and serving the soup in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chillies, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup before it is pureed in Step 8 and served in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding and cooking the squash and other ingredients, which is essential before pureeing the mixture in Step 8 and serving in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves stirring in the stock and coriander, which is essential before simmering and pureeing the soup, steps that occur before serving in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves covering the saucepan, must occur before Step 9 as it is part of the simmering process that softens the squash before it is pureed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 must occur before Step 9 because the soup needs to be simmered to cook the squash thoroughly before it is pureed in Step 8 and served in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 17, "title": "creamy-chayote-squash-soup", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Dissolve the stock in the hot water.", "Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.", "Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.", "Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.", "Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;", "cover.", "Simmer about 20 minutes.", "Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.", "Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: creamy-chayote-squash-soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Dissolve the stock in the hot water.\n2. Melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat.\n3. Cook and stir the onion, garlic and crushed chillies in the butter until the onion is soft.\n4. Add the squash, 2 tablespoons coriander, salt and pepper and stir continuously for 5 minutes.\n5. Stir in the stock and 1 tablespoon coriander;\n6. cover.\n7. Simmer about 20 minutes.\n8. Pour the mixture into a liquidiser and puree until smooth.\n9. Pour into bowls and garnish with a sprig of coriander to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 must occur before Step 9 because the soup needs to be pureed before it can be served in bowls.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue which can be done simultaneously as preparing the curry mixture in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue, which can be done independently and prior to arranging the foil sheets in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which can be done before arranging the foil and mussels in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue, which must occur before arranging and preparing the mussels in Step 4 to ensure the barbecue is ready for cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be ready before dotting it on the mussels in Step 5, which occurs after arranging the mussels on the foil in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil sheets which must be done before placing the mussels on them in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue, which must occur before placing the mussels on the barbecue in Step 9, but it does not depend on the preparation of the mussels in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be ready before dotting it on the mussels in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil before the mussels and curry mixture can be placed on them, which is necessary before proceeding to Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves placing the mussels on the foil before they can be dotted with the curry mixture in Step 5, so Step 4 must logically precede Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the barbecue, must occur before cooking the mussels (Step 9), but it does not depend on the arrangement or seasoning steps (such as Step 6).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be dotted onto the mussels before adding the red pepper and parsley in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil sheets which is necessary before placing and seasoning the mussels in Steps 4, 5, and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves placing the mussels on the foil, which must occur before adding toppings like the red pepper and parsley in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dotting the mussels with the curry mixture, which can be done before or after sprinkling red pepper and parsley as these steps do not interfere with each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue, which must occur before cooking the mussels in Step 9, and is independent of arranging the lime slices in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be applied to the mussels in Step 5, before topping them with other ingredients in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil before adding any ingredients, and it must occur before placing mussels and other components on the foil in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves placing the mussels on the foil before adding other ingredients and wrapping them, which can be done before topping them with lime slices in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dotting the mussels with the curry mixture, which should ideally be done before adding the red pepper, parsley, and lime slices in Steps 6 and 7 for better flavor infusion.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 and Step 7 involve adding different ingredients to the mussels and can be interchanged without affecting the cooking process or final outcome.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the barbecue, must occur before Step 8, wrapping the mussels in foil and cooking them, to ensure the barbecue is ready for cooking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be applied to the mussels before they are wrapped in foil in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil sheets which is necessary before placing and wrapping the mussels in Step 4 and Step 8, respectively.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves placing the mussels on the foil before they are wrapped in Step 8, so it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, dotting the mussels with the curry mixture, must occur before Step 8, wrapping the foil around the portions, to ensure the mussels are properly seasoned before cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sprinkling red pepper and parsley over the mussels, which should be done before wrapping them in foil in Step 8 to ensure the seasonings are enclosed with the mussels during cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing lime slices on top of the mussels before wrapping them in foil, which is Step 8, so Step 7 does not necessarily have to happen after Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 9 because the barbecue needs to be preheated before the mussels can be cooked on it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be applied to the mussels before they are cooked in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil sheets to hold the mussels, which must be done before the mussels are cooked in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves dividing and placing the mussels on foil before cooking, which must occur before Step 9 where the mussels are actually cooked on the barbecue.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dotting the mussels with the curry mixture before they are cooked on the barbecue in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sprinkling red pepper and parsley over the mussels before they are cooked in Step 9, as part of the preparation process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing lime slices on the mussels before they are cooked in Step 9, so it does not need to happen after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 must happen before Step 9 because the mussels need to be securely wrapped in foil before they can be cooked on the barbecue.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the barbecue, which must occur before cooking the mussels in Step 9, not after discarding unopened mussels in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which needs to be applied to the mussels before they are cooked in Step 9, hence it must occur before cooking, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil sheets to hold the mussels, which must occur before cooking them in steps 8 and 9, not after discarding unopened mussels in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves dividing and placing the mussels on foil, which must occur before they are cooked and checked for opening in Step 9 and Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dotting the mussels with the curry mixture before cooking, which must occur before Step 10 where any unopened mussels are discarded after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sprinkling red pepper and parsley over the mussels before they are cooked, whereas Step 10 is about discarding unopened mussels after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing lime slices on the mussels before they are cooked, which occurs before Step 10 where unopened mussels are discarded after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, wrapping the mussels in foil, must occur before cooking them on the barbecue in Step 9, which precedes checking for unopened mussels in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves cooking the mussels until they open, which must occur before Step 10 where any unopened mussels are discarded after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before cooking the mussels, which is essential for preparing the barbecue, and cannot logically happen after Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the curry mixture which is used to season the mussels before they are cooked in Step 9, thus it must occur before cooking, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the foil for the mussels, which is necessary before cooking them on the barbecue in Step 9, and thus must occur before the mussels are cooked and served in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves dividing and placing the mussels on foil, which is essential before cooking them on the barbecue in Step 9, and must occur before they are served in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves dotting the mussels with the curry mixture, which is essential before cooking them in Step 9, whereas Step 11 is about serving the cooked mussels.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sprinkling red pepper and parsley over the mussels before cooking, which must occur before Step 11 where the cooked mussels are served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves topping the mussels with lime slices before cooking, which must occur before they are cooked and served as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves wrapping the mussels in foil, must occur before cooking them on the barbecue in Step 9, and therefore before serving them in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves cooking the mussels which must occur before Step 11 where the cooked mussels are served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 18, "title": "curried bbq mussels", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.", "Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.", "Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.", "Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.", "Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.", "Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.", "Top each with lime slices.", "Wrap foil tightly around the portions.", "Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.", "Discard any mussels which do not open.", "Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: curried bbq mussels\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat barbecue for medium-high heat and lightly oil the cooking grate.\n2. Whisk together the butter, garlic, curry powder, cumin and salt in a small bowl.\n3. Arrange four large sheets of foil on a flat surface.\n4. Divide the mussels into four even portions and place one portion on each piece of foil.\n5. Dot the mussels with the curry mixture.\n6. Sprinkle the red pepper and parsley over the top of each portion.\n7. Top each with lime slices.\n8. Wrap foil tightly around the portions.\n9. Cook the packets on the preheated barbecue until the mussels have opened, 5 to 10 minutes.\n10. Discard any mussels which do not open.\n11. Transfer the mussels to small bowls and garnish each with a lime wedge to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 must occur before Step 11 because unopened mussels need to be discarded before serving the cooked mussels.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the mixture that needs to be boiled in Step 2, so it must occur before Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves mixing ingredients which must occur before boiling and cooling, as described in Steps 2 and 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must happen before Step 3 as boiling the mixture is required before it is removed from heat.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves creating the mixture that the strawberries are added to in Step 4, so it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the mixture to thicken it before adding the strawberries in Step 4, so it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves removing the mixture from heat before adding strawberries in Step 4 to prevent them from overcooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberry mixture which needs to be completed before it can be poured into the biscuit base in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the mixture to thicken it, which must occur before adding it to the biscuit base in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 5 as it involves removing the mixture from heat before adding strawberries and pouring into the base.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves stirring the strawberries into the mixture before it is poured into the base in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberry mixture, which must occur before it can be poured into the base and chilled as described in Steps 5 and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the mixture to thicken it, which must occur before adding the strawberries and chilling the tart as described in Steps 4 and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves removing the mixture from heat, which is necessary before adding strawberries and pouring into the base, both of which occur before chilling in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves stirring strawberries into the mixture before it sets in the base, which must occur before chilling in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pouring the strawberry mixture into the base, which must occur before chilling the tart in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberry mixture which must occur before it can be poured into the base and chilled as described in Steps 5 and 6, all of which precede serving in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 to ensure the mixture thickens properly before adding strawberries and proceeding with the rest of the recipe.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 4 to ensure the mixture is off the heat before adding strawberries, and it is not dependent on Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves stirring strawberries into the mixture which must occur before chilling and serving in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 7 because the strawberry mixture needs to be poured into the base and set before it can be served with whipped cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 19, "title": "easy strawberry tart", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.", "Boil for one minute.", "Remove from heat.", "Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.", "Pour into the digestive biscuit base.", "Chill until well set.", "Serve topped with whipped cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy strawberry tart\n\nProcedure:\n1. Mix together the sugar, water, jam and cornflour in a medium large saucepan.\n2. Boil for one minute.\n3. Remove from heat.\n4. Stir in the sliced strawberries, and toss until well coated.\n5. Pour into the digestive biscuit base.\n6. Chill until well set.\n7. Serve topped with whipped cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 must occur before Step 7 because the tart needs to be well set before it can be served with whipped cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining all ingredients which must occur before heating and cooking the mixture in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining ingredients which must occur before cooking the rice in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 3 as it involves bringing the mixture to a boil and then reducing the heat to a simmer, which is necessary before the rice can cook and absorb the liquid in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining ingredients which must occur before cooking and serving the rice, as described in Steps 2, 3, and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 as it involves cooking the rice, which needs to be done before it can be served with the cinnamon stick removed in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 20, "title": "easy-coconut-rice", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.", "Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.", "Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.", "Remove cinnamon stick to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: easy-coconut-rice\n\nProcedure:\n1. Combine rice with the coconut milk, water, salt, sugar and cinnamon stick in a large saucepan with a tight-fitting lid.\n2. Bring to the boil; reduce the heat to a simmer and cover.\n3. Cook until the liquid is absorbed and the rice is tender, about 25 minutes.\n4. Remove cinnamon stick to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 4 because the rice needs to be cooked and the liquid absorbed before the cinnamon stick can be removed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the grill, can occur simultaneously with Step 2, mixing the ingredients, to save time and ensure the grill is ready when needed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the grill, which can be done simultaneously while preparing the cheese mixture in steps 2 and 3, thus it does not need to happen after Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the ingredients which is necessary before Step 3, where the mixture is stirred until creamy and lump-free.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the grill, which should be done before Step 8 where the spinach rolls are grilled, and does not depend on the blanching of spinach in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the filling which can be done independently before blanching the spinach in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the filling ingredients to a creamy consistency, which can be done independently and prior to blanching the spinach in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the grill, must occur before Step 8, grilling the spinach rolls, to ensure the grill is ready for cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the filling which needs to be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves stirring the cheese mixture until creamy, which needs to be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, blanching the spinach leaves, must occur before Step 5, wrapping the cheese mix in the leaves, to ensure the leaves are pliable and easy to wrap.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the grill, must occur before Step 8, grilling the spinach rolls, and does not depend on the completion of Step 6, brushing with olive oil.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the filling ingredients which must be done before wrapping them in spinach leaves in Step 5, which precedes Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves stirring the cheese mixture to a creamy consistency, which needs to be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5, and thus before brushing with olive oil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Blanching the spinach leaves in Step 4 is necessary to soften them before wrapping the cheese mix in Step 5, which occurs before brushing with olive oil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves wrapping the cheese mix in spinach leaves, which should be done before brushing with olive oil in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the grill, must occur before Step 8, grilling the spinach rolls, and does not depend on the completion of Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the filling which needs to be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5, which precedes Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves stirring the cheese mixture until creamy, which needs to be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5, and thus before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves blanching the spinach leaves, which must be done before they can be used to wrap the cheese mix in Step 5, and thus must occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves wrapping the cheese mix in spinach leaves, which must be done before Step 7 where the rolls are either brushed with oil or rolled in almonds to prepare them for grilling.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, brushing with olive oil, can occur before or after sprinkling or rolling in almonds as described in Step 7, as both steps are independent in terms of their effect on the rolls.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 8 because the grill needs to be preheated before the spinach rolls can be grilled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the filling ingredients, which must be done before they are wrapped in spinach leaves in Step 5 and grilled in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves stirring the cheese mixture until creamy, which must be done before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5, and thus before grilling in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 5, as the spinach leaves need to be blanched before they can be used to wrap the cheese mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves wrapping the cheese mix in spinach leaves, which must occur before grilling the rolls in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, brushing with olive oil, should occur before Step 8, grilling, to ensure the rolls are properly oiled and do not stick to the grill or burn.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves sprinkling or rolling the almonds on the rolls, which should be done before grilling in Step 8 to allow the almonds to toast and adhere to the rolls during grilling.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the grill, must occur before Step 8, grilling the spinach rolls, and does not depend on the cooling process in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the filling ingredients, which must be done before they are wrapped in spinach leaves in Step 5 and subsequently grilled in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves stirring the cheese mixture to a creamy consistency, which is necessary before wrapping it in spinach leaves in Step 5, thus it must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 5 as the spinach leaves need to be blanched before they can be used to wrap the cheese mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves wrapping the cheese mix in spinach leaves, which must occur before grilling in Step 8 and cooling in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves brushing the spinach rolls with olive oil, which must be done before grilling in Step 8, not after cooling in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves sprinkling almonds on the rolls before grilling, which must occur before Step 8 (grilling) and therefore before Step 9 (cooling).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 21, "title": "feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat grill.", "Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.", "Stir until creamy, with no lumps.", "Blanch the spinach leaves.", "Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.", "Brush with olive oil.", "Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds", "Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.", "Let cool for 10 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: feta-and-sundried-tomato-spinach-rolls\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat grill.\n2. Mix together cream cheese, feta, sundried tomatoes, basil and garlic.\n3. Stir until creamy, with no lumps.\n4. Blanch the spinach leaves.\n5. Wrap a dollop of cheese mix in each spinach leaf.\n6. Brush with olive oil.\n7. Sprinkle almonds on the top or alternately roll them in the almonds\n8. Grill spinach rolls until slightly crispy on top.\n9. Let cool for 10 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 must occur before Step 9 as grilling the spinach rolls (Step 8) needs to be completed before they can cool (Step 9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 22, "title": "fiery-bean-and-avocado-dip", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a large bowl, mix blackeyed beans, tomatoes, red onion, Scotch bonnet chillies, Italian dressing and cayenne pepper.", "Stir in the avocados just before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fiery-bean-and-avocado-dip\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, mix blackeyed beans, tomatoes, red onion, Scotch bonnet chillies, Italian dressing and cayenne pepper.\n2. Stir in the avocados just before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves mixing most ingredients and must be completed before Step 2, where avocados are added just before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves cooking the onion and beef which must be done before they are added to the casserole dish in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves cooking the onion and beef which is necessary before combining them with other ingredients in Step 3 for further cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the additional ingredients with stock in the frying pan before combining them with the onion and beef mixture in the casserole dish in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves cooking the onion and beef which is necessary before combining with other ingredients in the casserole dish for oven cooking in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing and cooking initial ingredients which must occur before they are combined in the casserole dish and cooked in the oven in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 23, "title": "frugal-beef-stew", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.", "Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.", "Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.", "Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: frugal-beef-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the onion and beef to a frying pan with a little oil (if you feel it requires it, depends on how good your pan is) and cook until the onions are soft.\n2. Tip out the onion/beef into a casserole dish and add the rest of the ingredients to the frying pan with half the stock, cooking on a high heat for about 10 minutes.\n3. Pour the contents of the frying pan into the casserole dish along with the thyme and rest of the stock (and a little bit of pepper if you like) and put on the lid.\n4. Cook in the oven on a low heat (about 140 C) for around 3-4 hours, giving it a stir every hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves combining all ingredients in the casserole dish before it is cooked in the oven in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2, which precedes transferring some of the onion mixture in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic, which must occur before transferring some of this mixture to a bowl in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2, and thus must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 as Step 4 involves setting aside the onion mixture transferred in Step 3, which is derived from the saut\u00e9ed onions and garlic in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which is 'Set aside', is an action that applies to the onion mixture already transferred in Step 3, indicating that Step 4 follows Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which is necessary before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2, and well before processing the tomatoes in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is needed before Step 3, where part of this mixture is used in the meatballs, independent of the tomato processing in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in the meatball mixture, which is independent of the tomato processing in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, does not affect the processing of tomatoes in Step 5 and can occur independently.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before adding the processed tomatoes in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before Step 3, where part of this mixture is used to mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, independent of the tomato sauce preparation in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in the meatball mixture, which is independent of adding and processing the tomatoes in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is independent of adding the tomatoes to the saucepan in Step 6 and does not affect it.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes into a smooth consistency, which needs to be done before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before adding ingredients like tomatoes in Step 6 and bringing them to a boil in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before adding the tomatoes in Step 6, which precedes bringing the mixture to a boil in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making meatballs, which is independent of the tomato sauce preparation that begins in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is part of the preparation for making meatballs and does not depend on the boiling of the tomato sauce in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes which is necessary before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which precedes bringing the mixture to a boil in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, which must occur before Step 7 where the mixture is brought to a boil.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before adding ingredients and cooking them as described in steps following Step 1, including Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic, which is necessary before adding the tomatoes in Step 6 and must occur before the sauce is simmered in Step 9, not related to the heat adjustment in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for the meatballs, which is independent of the tomato sauce preparation steps that include Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is related to setting aside the onion mixture and does not depend on the heat adjustments made in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes which is necessary before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which occurs before reducing the heat in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, which must occur before Step 8 where the heat is reduced to simmer the sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves bringing the sauce to a boil, which must occur before reducing the heat in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2 and before adding the processed tomatoes in Step 6, all of which happen before Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onions and garlic which is necessary before creating the tomato sauce in steps 5-9, indicating it must occur before, not after Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making meatballs, which is independent of the simmering process of the tomato sauce described in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, directly follows Step 3 and is unrelated to the simmering process described in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes to add to the saucepan before it is brought to a boil in Step 7 and simmered in Step 9, indicating it should occur before Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, which must occur before Step 9's simmering of the sauce can begin.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the sauce to a boil, must occur before Step 9, where the sauce is simmered; thus, Step 7 cannot happen after Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which is reducing the heat to medium-low, must occur before Step 9, where the sauce is simmered, to ensure the sauce simmers at the correct temperature.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before saut\u00e9ing the onion and garlic in Step 2 and well before adding basil and oregano in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before adding them to the meatball mixture in Step 12, while Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce, which is a separate process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making meatballs, which is independent of adding basil and oregano to the sauce in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is independent of adding basil and oregano to the sauce in Step 10 and does not affect or depend on it.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes to create the sauce and must occur before Step 10, where basil and oregano are added to the simmering sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, which must occur before Step 10 where basil and oregano are added to the simmering sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which involves adding basil and oregano, occurs halfway through the 30-minute simmering process initiated in Step 9, which follows directly after bringing the mixture to a boil in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which is reducing the heat to medium-low, must occur before adding the basil and oregano in Step 10 to ensure the sauce simmers properly.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 specifies adding basil and oregano halfway through the 30-minute simmering period of Step 9, indicating that Step 9 must already be in progress before Step 10 can occur.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which is necessary before processing the bread into crumbs in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is needed before Step 12 to mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, while Step 11 involves processing bread into crumbs, which is unrelated to the saut\u00e9ing process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 12, as the onion mixture is needed to mix with other ingredients to form the meatballs.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is independent of Step 11, which involves processing the bread into crumbs.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes for the sauce, while Step 11 involves processing bread for the meatballs, and these processes are independent of each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan and does not depend on the breadcrumbs being prepared in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, is independent of Step 11, which involves processing bread into crumbs for the meatballs.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the tomato sauce, is independent of Step 11, which involves processing the bread into crumbs for the meatballs.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which is independent of processing the bread into crumbs in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the sauce, which is independent of processing the bread into crumbs in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which must occur before the onion mixture can be used in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is then used in Step 12 to mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, thus it must occur before Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 12 as it provides the onion mixture needed to mix with the other ingredients to form the meatballs.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, must occur before adding other ingredients to it in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes for the sauce, which is independent of making the meatball mixture in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which is independent of preparing the meatball mixture in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, which can occur independently and concurrently with preparing the meatball mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the tomato sauce, is independent of Step 12, which involves preparing the meatball mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which can occur concurrently with preparing the meatball mixture in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its simmering process, which is independent of preparing the meatball mixture in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which involves processing the bread into crumbs, can occur before or simultaneously with Step 12 as the crumbs are needed for the mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which must occur before forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onions and garlic which are later used in Step 12 to mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, independent of forming the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl to later mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, which must be done before forming the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, must occur before adding other ingredients to it in Step 12, not after forming meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, is part of preparing the tomato sauce and must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17, whereas Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs, which is a separate process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which needs to simmer while the meatballs are being prepared and cooked; these processes can occur concurrently.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, is part of preparing the sauce and does not depend on the completion of forming the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the sauce, is independent of forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 13 and can occur before the meatballs are prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which can occur concurrently with forming and cooking the meatballs in steps 11 to 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its simmering process, which is independent of forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is required before mixing with other ingredients in Step 12 to form the meatballs, thus it must occur before Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mixing ingredients to form the meatball mixture, which must be completed before shaping the meatballs in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which is necessary before making the sauce in steps 2-9, while Step 14 involves preparing a different pan for cooking the meatballs, and these steps are independent of each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before making the meatballs in Step 12, whereas Step 14 involves cooking the meatballs, which is a separate process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for the meatball mixture, which needs to be prepared before cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 refers to setting aside the onion mixture, which is used later in Step 12, and is unrelated to cooking the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes for the sauce and needs to be completed before adding to the saucepan in Step 6, which occurs long before cooking the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which is independent of cooking the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, which is independent of cooking the meatballs in Step 14 and can be done concurrently.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the sauce, is part of the sauce preparation and is independent of Step 14, which involves cooking the meatballs.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which can occur concurrently with frying the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its simmering process, which occurs before forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary for making the meatball mixture in Step 12, before cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must be done before cooking the meatballs in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meat mixture into meatballs, which must be done before they can be cooked in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs in subsequent steps, including Step 15 where the meatballs are cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onions and garlic which is necessary before making the tomato sauce and meatball mixture, both of which occur before cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making the meatballs, which must be prepared before cooking them in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is part of the preparation for making meatballs and must occur before forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves processing the tomatoes to create the sauce in which the meatballs are later cooked, and must occur before the meatballs are added in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which needs to simmer before the meatballs are added in Step 17, thus it does not depend on the completion of Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, which is part of preparing the sauce in which the meatballs will eventually be cooked, and this can occur independently and prior to browning the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the tomato sauce, is independent of Step 15, which involves cooking the meatballs in a separate pan.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves simmering the tomato sauce, can occur simultaneously with Step 15, where the meatballs are being browned, as these processes do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its simmering process, which occurs before the meatballs are cooked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is needed in Step 12 to mix with other ingredients to form the meatballs before they are cooked in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture which needs to be done before they can be cooked in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meat mixture into meatballs, which must be done before they can be cooked in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves setting up the frying pan and heating it, which must occur before cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 105, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs, and is unrelated to draining the cooked meatballs in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 106, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs, whereas Step 16 involves draining cooked meatballs, which occurs much later in the recipe.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 107, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl to later mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, which needs to occur before forming and cooking the meatballs in Step 13 and Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 108, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside part of the onion mixture, occurs early in the recipe and is unrelated to draining the meatballs on kitchen paper in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 109, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, needs to occur before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which is well before cooking and draining the meatballs in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 110, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which needs to occur before the meatballs are cooked and added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 111, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, which is part of preparing the sauce in which the meatballs will be cooked later in Step 18, and does not depend on the meatballs being browned first.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 112, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the sauce, is part of the sauce preparation and occurs long before Step 16, which involves draining the cooked meatballs.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 113, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves simmering the tomato sauce, can occur simultaneously with Step 16, where the meatballs are being drained after frying.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 114, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the sauce, which occurs during the 30-minute simmering of the sauce in Step 9, well before the meatballs are cooked and drained in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 115, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary for making the meatball mixture in Step 12, before cooking the meatballs in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 116, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must occur before cooking the meatballs in Step 15; Step 16 is the draining of the cooked meatballs.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 117, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meat mixture into meatballs, which must occur before they can be cooked in Step 15; Step 16 is the draining of the cooked meatballs.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 118, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves cooking the meatballs, which must occur before they can be drained on kitchen paper in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 119, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves cooking the meatballs, which must be completed before they can be drained on kitchen paper in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 120, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before adding ingredients in subsequent steps, including Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 121, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs, and must occur long before adding meatballs to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 122, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl to later mix with other ingredients for the meatballs, which must be formed and cooked before being added to the tomato sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 123, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, must occur before forming the meatballs in Step 12, not after adding the meatballs to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 124, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, must occur before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which is well before adding the meatballs to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 125, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which must occur before the meatballs are added in Step 17 to cook in the sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 126, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17 to ensure the sauce is properly cooked and flavored.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 127, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the tomato sauce, occurs long before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 128, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves simmering the tomato sauce, must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17 to ensure the sauce is properly cooked and flavored.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 129, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its simmering process, which occurs before the meatballs are added in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 130, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary to form the meatballs in Step 12, long before adding them to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 131, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must be done before cooking the meatballs in Step 15 and adding them to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 132, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs, which must be done before they are cooked in Step 15 and added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 133, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 must occur before Step 17 because the meatballs need to be cooked before they can be added to the tomato sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 134, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 must occur before Step 17 because the meatballs need to be browned before they can be added to the tomato sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 135, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves draining the cooked meatballs on kitchen paper to remove excess oil before they are added to the tomato sauce in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 136, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before adding ingredients and cooking them, as outlined in subsequent steps including Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 137, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic, which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs in subsequent steps, and must occur before Step 18 where the meatballs are cooked in the sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 138, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before making the meatballs in Step 12, which happens before they are added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 139, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is part of the preparation for making meatballs and must occur before forming and cooking the meatballs, which happens well before Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 140, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, must occur before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which is well before adding the meatballs to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 141, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which must occur before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 142, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17, which happens before Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 143, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the tomato sauce, must occur before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17, and thus well before Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 144, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17, which is before Step 18.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 145, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the tomato sauce during its initial cooking phase, which occurs before the meatballs are added in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 146, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary before forming the meatballs in Step 13, which occurs before they are cooked and added to the sauce in Step 17 and 18.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 147, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must be done before cooking the meatballs in Step 15 and adding them to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 148, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs, which must be done before they are cooked in Step 15 and added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 149, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 18 where the cooked meatballs are added to the tomato sauce for further cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 150, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 18 where the cooked meatballs are added to the tomato sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 151, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16 involves draining the cooked meatballs on kitchen paper, which must occur before adding them to the tomato sauce in Step 17, which precedes Step 18.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 152, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 18?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 18?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 18?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17 involves adding the meatballs to the tomato sauce, which must occur before Step 18 where the meatballs are cooked in the sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 153, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking the onion and garlic, which is essential to start the sauce and meatball preparation, and must occur before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 154, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic which is essential for preparing the sauce and meatballs mixture early in the recipe, whereas Step 19 involves cooking the pasta, which is done towards the end of the cooking process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 155, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making meatballs, which occurs before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 156, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is part of the preparation for making meatballs and must occur before adding other ingredients to the onion mixture in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 157, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes for the sauce, needs to occur before the sauce is cooked and the meatballs are added, which happens well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 158, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan to create the sauce, which needs to be prepared before the meatballs are added in Step 17, and this occurs well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 159, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, is part of preparing the sauce and must occur before the meatballs are added in Step 17, which happens well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 160, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the sauce, occurs much earlier in the cooking process and is unrelated to cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 161, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which needs to be ready before adding the meatballs in Step 17, and this can occur independently and prior to cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 162, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the sauce, which needs to occur during the 30-minute simmering period in Step 9, well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 163, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary for making the meatball mixture in Step 12, well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 164, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatballs which need to be cooked and added to the sauce before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 165, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs which need to be cooked and added to the sauce (steps 15-18) before the pasta is cooked in step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 166, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves cooking the meatballs, which must be done before they are added to the tomato sauce in Step 17, which occurs before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 167, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the tomato sauce, and this sequence is independent of Step 19, which involves cooking the pasta.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 168, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16, which involves draining the meatballs on kitchen paper, is part of the meatball preparation process and occurs before they are added to the sauce in Step 17, which is well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 169, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17, which involves adding the meatballs to the tomato sauce, is independent of Step 19, where the pasta is cooked; both steps can proceed simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 170, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 19?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 19?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 19?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18, which involves cooking the meatballs in the sauce, can occur simultaneously with Step 19, where the pasta is being cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 171, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which is necessary before any cooking begins, including saut\u00e9ing ingredients in subsequent steps, well before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 172, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic, which is essential for preparing the sauce and meatballs mixture early in the recipe, well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 173, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl for later use in making meatballs, which occurs before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 174, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, logically follows Step 3 and is necessary before proceeding to other steps that use the onion mixture, such as Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 175, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, needs to occur before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which is well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 176, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, is part of preparing the tomato sauce for the meatballs and must occur before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17, which is well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 177, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, must occur before adding the meatballs in Step 17, which happens well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 178, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for the sauce, occurs much earlier in the cooking process and is unrelated to the cooking of the pasta in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 179, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves simmering the tomato sauce, which needs to be completed before adding the meatballs in Step 17, which in turn must be done before Step 20 where the pasta is served.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 180, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the sauce during its initial cooking phase, which must occur before the sauce is used to toss with the pasta in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 181, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves processing the bread into crumbs, which is necessary for making the meatballs in Step 12, long before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 182, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must be done before cooking the meatballs in Step 15 and adding them to the sauce in Step 17, all of which occur before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 183, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs, which must be done before they are cooked in Step 15 and added to the sauce in Step 17, all of which occur before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 184, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves cooking the meatballs, which must be done before they are added to the tomato sauce in Step 17, which occurs before the pasta is cooked in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 185, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the tomato sauce, and this sequence is independent of cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 186, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16, which involves draining the meatballs on kitchen paper, must occur before adding the meatballs to the sauce in Step 17, which is well before cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 187, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17, which involves adding the meatballs to the tomato sauce, must occur before Step 20, where the pasta is cooked and served, to ensure the meatballs are properly cooked in the sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 188, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18 involves simmering the meatballs in the sauce, which can occur simultaneously with cooking the pasta in Step 19.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 189, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 19 happen after Step 20?", "why_question": "Why must Step 19 happen after Step 20?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 19 happen after Step 20?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 19 involves cooking the pasta, which needs to be done before it can be drained and tossed with the sauce in Step 20.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 190, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the saucepan for cooking, which must occur before any cooking can begin, including the steps that follow in the procedure.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 191, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves saut\u00e9ing onion and garlic, which is necessary before making the sauce and meatballs, both of which are completed before Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 192, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves transferring some of the saut\u00e9ed onion mixture to a bowl, which is necessary before forming the meatballs in Step 12, well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 193, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the onion mixture, is part of the preparation for making meatballs and must occur early in the procedure, well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 194, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves processing the tomatoes, must occur before adding them to the saucepan in Step 6, which is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 195, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves adding the processed tomatoes to the saucepan, must occur before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17, which is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 196, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves bringing the tomato sauce to a boil, must occur before Step 18 where the meatballs are cooked in the sauce, and this sequence is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 197, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves reducing the heat for simmering the sauce, occurs much earlier in the cooking process and is necessary before the meatballs are added to the sauce in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 198, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves simmering the tomato sauce, must occur before Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the sauce, and this sequence is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 199, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding herbs to the sauce during its cooking process, which must occur before the sauce is used to toss with pasta and top with meatballs in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 200, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which involves processing the bread into crumbs, must occur before Step 12 where these crumbs are mixed with other ingredients to form meatballs, which happens well before serving the pasta and sauce in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 201, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves preparing the meatball mixture, which must be done before cooking the meatballs in Step 15 and adding them to the sauce in Step 17, all of which occur before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 202, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves shaping the meatballs, which must be done before they are cooked in Step 15 and added to the sauce in Step 17, all of which occur before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 203, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the tomato sauce, which is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 204, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15, which involves cooking the meatballs, must occur before Step 17 where the meatballs are added to the tomato sauce, which is well before serving the dish in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 205, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16, which involves draining the meatballs on kitchen paper, must occur before adding them to the tomato sauce in Step 17, which is well before serving them with the pasta in Step 21.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 206, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 17 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 17 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 17 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 17, which involves adding the meatballs to the tomato sauce, must occur before Step 21 where the meatballs and sauce are served with the pasta.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 207, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 18 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 18 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 18 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 18, which involves cooking the meatballs in the sauce, must occur before Step 21 where the pasta is served with the meatballs and sauce.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 208, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 19 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 19 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 19 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 19 involves cooking the pasta, which needs to be done before Step 21 where the cooked pasta is tossed with the sauce and served with meatballs.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 24, "title": "fusilli-and-meatballs", "question_idx": 209, "steps": ["Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.", "Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.", "Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.", "Set aside.", "Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.", "Add to the saucepan.", "Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.", "Reduce the heat to medium-low.", "Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.", "Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.", "Process the bread until crumbs form.", "Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.", "Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.", "Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.", "Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.", "Drain on kitchen paper.", "Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.", "Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.", "Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.", "Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.", "Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 20 happen after Step 21?", "why_question": "Why must Step 20 happen after Step 21?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: fusilli-and-meatballs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Coat a large saucepan with cooking spray or a teaspoon of olive oil and set over a medium-high heat.\n2. Saut\u00e9 the onion and garlic for about 5 minutes or until soft.\n3. Transfer 2 tablespoons of the onion mixture to a large bowl.\n4. Set aside.\n5. Whiz the tomatoes, with their juice, in a food processor until fairly smooth.\n6. Add to the saucepan.\n7. Bring to the boil over medium-high heat.\n8. Reduce the heat to medium-low.\n9. Cover and simmer, stirring often, for 30 minutes.\n10. Add the basil and oregano halfway through this time.\n11. Process the bread until crumbs form.\n12. Add the crumbs, beef, egg, milk and pepper to the onion mixture in the bowl and mix just until blended.\n13. Shape into 20 meatballs about 2.5cm (1in) diameter.\n14. Coat a frying pan with cooking spray or olive oil and set over medium-high heat.\n15. Cook the meatballs, in batches, for about 8 minutes or until browned on all sides.\n16. Drain on kitchen paper.\n17. Add the meatballs to the tomato sauce.\n18. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally, for 20 minutes.\n19. Meanwhile, cook the pasta according to the instructions on the packet.\n20. Drain and toss with 3 ladlefuls of the sauce in a large heated serving bowl.\n21. Spoon the meatballs and remaining sauce over the top, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 20 happen after Step 21?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 20 involves tossing the cooked pasta with some of the sauce, which must be done before Step 21 where the meatballs and remaining sauce are added on top for serving.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing water and rice in the saucepan, which must occur before bringing it to a boil in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing water and rice in a saucepan, which must occur before it can be brought to a boil in Step 2 and then simmered in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves bringing the water to a boil, which must occur before Step 3 where the heat is reduced and the rice simmers.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice which must be done before it can be fluffed in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the water for the rice, which must occur before the rice can be simmered in Step 3 and subsequently cooled and fluffed in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice which must occur before removing it from heat and cooling as described in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves cooking rice which is independent of Step 5 where sesame oil is heated for frying tofu.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent of heating the sesame oil for tofu in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which is independent of heating the oil for tofu preparation in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling and fluffing the rice, which can be done independently of heating the oil for tofu in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which is independent of Step 6 where tofu is fried in oil, and both can be done simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent of frying the tofu in Step 6 and can be done simultaneously.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which can be done independently of frying the tofu in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling and fluffing the rice, which can be done independently of frying the tofu in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating the oil which must occur before adding and frying the tofu in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which is independent of frying the tofu in Step 7 and can be done simultaneously.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent of frying the tofu in Step 7 and can be completed earlier in the procedure.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which can occur simultaneously with Step 7 where the tofu is being fried.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling and fluffing the rice, is independent of Step 7, which involves frying the tofu, and can be completed earlier.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil in a separate pan, which can be done independently and does not need to follow the frying of tofu in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in the tofu, which must occur before Step 7 where the tofu is fried.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which is independent of seasoning the tofu in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent and unrelated to seasoning the tofu in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which is independent of seasoning the tofu in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling and fluffing the rice, is independent of Step 8, which involves seasoning the tofu, and can be completed separately.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil to cook tofu, which is independent of seasoning the tofu with salt in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in the tofu which needs to be done before it can be fried and seasoned with salt in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves frying the tofu until crisp and browned, which can be done before or after seasoning with salt in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice which is independent of Step 9, where the coconut milk is heated for the curry.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 and Step 9 involve different ingredients and processes, and neither step depends on the completion of the other.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which is independent of boiling the coconut milk in Step 9 for the curry sauce.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling and fluffing the rice, is independent of Step 9, which involves boiling coconut milk, and can be completed separately.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil and frying tofu, which can be done independently of boiling coconut milk in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves frying the tofu, which can be done independently of boiling the coconut milk in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves frying the tofu, which can be done independently of boiling the coconut milk in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves seasoning the tofu which is independent of boiling the coconut milk in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which is independent of and can be done concurrently with preparing the green curry sauce in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent of mixing the green curry paste with coconut milk in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which is independent of and can occur simultaneously with Step 10, which involves simmering the coconut milk and curry paste mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling and fluffing the rice, is independent of Step 10, which involves mixing green curry paste into coconut milk.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil and frying tofu, which can be done independently and concurrently with preparing the green curry sauce in steps 9-11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves frying the tofu, which can be done independently and prior to mixing the green curry paste with coconut milk in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves frying the tofu, which can be done independently and concurrently with preparing the green curry sauce in steps 9-11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves seasoning the tofu, which is independent of mixing the green curry paste with coconut milk in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves boiling the coconut milk, which needs to be done before mixing in the green curry paste in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which is independent of making the green curry sauce in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which is independent of and can occur concurrently with Step 11, which involves simmering the coconut milk and curry paste mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which is independent of simmering the coconut milk and curry paste mixture in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves cooling and fluffing the rice, is independent of Step 11, which involves simmering the green curry paste with coconut milk.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil and frying tofu, which can be done independently and concurrently with the preparation of the green curry sauce in steps 9 to 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves frying the tofu, which can be done independently and concurrently with preparing the green curry sauce in steps 9 to 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves frying the tofu until crisp and browned, which can be done independently of simmering the green curry mixture in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves seasoning the tofu which is independent of the coconut milk and curry paste mixture process described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves boiling the coconut milk, which needs to occur before Step 10 (mixing in the green curry paste) and Step 11 (simmering the mixture), but it does not need to happen after Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves mixing the green curry paste into the boiling coconut milk, which must occur before reducing the heat and simmering in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the rice, which needs to be cooked and ready before it can be served with the tofu and curry sauce in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling the rice, which needs to be cooked before it can be served with the tofu and curry sauce prepared in the later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the rice, which needs to be completed before Step 12 where the curry is served over the rice.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooling and fluffing the rice, which needs to be completed before Step 12 where the curry is served over the rice.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves heating oil to cook tofu, which needs to be done before Step 12 where the curry sauce is drizzled over the cooked tofu and rice.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves stirring in the tofu which needs to be done before it can be fried and seasoned in subsequent steps, prior to being combined with the sauce from Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves frying the tofu until crisp and browned, which needs to be completed before Step 12, where the curry sauce is drizzled over the cooked tofu and rice.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves seasoning the tofu with salt, which should be done after frying it in Step 7 and before combining it with the curry sauce in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves boiling the coconut milk, which needs to be mixed with green curry paste and simmered before being drizzled over the tofu and rice in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves mixing the green curry paste into the boiling coconut milk, which must occur before Step 12 where the mixture is drizzled over the tofu and rice.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 25, "title": "green-tofu-curry", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.", "Bring to the boil.", "Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.", "Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.", "Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.", "Stir in tofu.", "Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.", "Season with salt.", "In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.", "Mix in green curry paste.", "Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.", "Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: green-tofu-curry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place water in a medium saucepan, and stir in the rice.\n2. Bring to the boil.\n3. Cover, reduce heat, and simmer 20 minutes.\n4. Remove from heat, cool slightly, and fluff with a fork.\n5. Heat the sesame oil in a separate medium saucepan over medium heat.\n6. Stir in tofu.\n7. Stirring occasionally, fry about 20 minutes, until evenly crisp and lightly browned.\n8. Season with salt.\n9. In a small saucepan, bring the coconut milk to the boil.\n10. Mix in green curry paste.\n11. Reduce heat, and simmer 5 minutes.\n12. Drizzle generously over the tofu and rice to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves simmering the coconut milk and curry paste mixture, which needs to be completed before drizzling it over the tofu and rice in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the grill, which should be done before placing the ingredients under the grill as described in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the grill, which must occur before grilling the ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the ingredients which must be done before grilling them in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the grill, which must occur before grilling the ingredients in Step 3, thus it cannot happen after Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the ingredients which must be done before grilling and drizzling honey in Steps 3 and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 26, "title": "halloumi-and-figs", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat a grill for high heat.", "Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.", "Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.", "Drizzle with the honey."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: halloumi-and-figs\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat a grill for high heat.\n2. Break up the halloumi cheese, and toss with the fresh figs and walnuts in a small dish.\n3. Grill under the preheated grill until the halloumi is browned and the figs begin to caramelise, about 3 minutes.\n4. Drizzle with the honey.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves grilling the halloumi and figs, which must be done before drizzling honey on them in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves creaming the butter and adding sugar and eggs, which is necessary to create the base of the dough before adding flour in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the dough by beating butter, sugar, and eggs, which must be done before chilling the dough in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sieving and folding in the flour, which is necessary to form the dough before it can be chilled in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the biscuit dough, which must be done before forming balls from the dough in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sieving and folding in the flour, which is necessary to form the dough before shaping it into balls and rolling in hazelnuts in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3, chilling the dough, is necessary before forming the balls in Step 4 to ensure the dough is firm enough to handle and shape.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the biscuit dough, which must be done before forming the balls and making hollows in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sieving and folding in flour which is essential for forming the dough, which must occur before shaping the balls and creating hollows in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3, which involves chilling the dough, must occur before forming the balls in Step 4 and making the hollows in Step 5 to ensure the dough is firm enough to handle.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves forming the dough into balls and rolling them in hazelnuts, which must be done before making a hollow in each ball as described in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the biscuit dough, which must be done before baking the biscuits in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sieving and folding in the flour, which is essential for forming the biscuit dough before it can be shaped, filled with jam, and baked as described in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before forming the balls and baking (Steps 4, 5, and 6), as it is necessary to chill the dough to make it easier to handle and shape.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 6 because the biscuits need to be formed and prepared with jam before they can be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 27, "title": "jam-drop-biscuits", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.", "Sieve in flour and fold in.", "Chill for at least 30 minutes.", "Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.", "Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.", "Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: jam-drop-biscuits\n\nProcedure:\n1. Beat butter until fluffy and gradually add the sugar, vanilla sugar and eggs.\n2. Sieve in flour and fold in.\n3. Chill for at least 30 minutes.\n4. Form small balls from the biscuit dough and roll in ground hazelnuts.\n5. Make a hollow into each ball with the end of a wooden spoon and place onto a baking tray lined with baking parchment.\n6. Fill the holes with jam and bake in a preheated oven at 170 C / Gas 3 for 20 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves forming the biscuits and adding the jam, which must be done before baking them in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 and Step 2 are independent tasks focusing on different ingredients and can be performed in any order.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 and Step 3 are independent tasks focusing on preparing different ingredients and can be performed in any order.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 and Step 3 are independent tasks involving different ingredients and can be performed in any order.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the carrots which is necessary before they can be assembled onto the skewer in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cutting the red pepper into shapes, which needs to be done before they can be assembled onto the skewer in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 28, "title": "kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.", "Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.", "Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.", "Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: kid-s-cheese-and-veg-kebab\n\nProcedure:\n1. Shave the carrots into wide ribbons / waves using a potato peeler.\n2. Cut the red pepper into star shapes using a star cookie cutter.\n3. Cut the bread into flowers using a cookie cutter.\n4. Assemble all onto a skewer with bread flowers top and bottom and carrot curls, cheesy chunks and pepper stars seen as layers between.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cutting the bread into flowers, which must be done before assembling the skewer in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the paste which is needed in Step 3, and does not depend on the frying of the lamb and onion in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the paste which is needed in Step 3, hence it must occur before Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves frying the lamb and adding the onion, which must occur before Step 3 where the paste is added to the cooked lamb and onion.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the paste which is needed in Step 3, thus it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves frying the lamb and adding the onion, which is necessary before adding the paste in Step 3 and other ingredients in Step 4 for proper cooking sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding the paste to the lamb and onions and must occur before Step 4, where additional ingredients like water and tomatoes are added to simmer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the initial curry paste mixture which is required in Step 3, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves frying the lamb and adding onion, which is essential before adding the paste and other ingredients in subsequent steps for proper cooking sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the paste with the lamb and onions, which is necessary before adding other ingredients in Step 4 and 5 for proper flavor development.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 29, "title": "lamb-curry--serves-4-", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.", "Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.", "Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.", "Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.", "Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lamb-curry--serves-4-\n\nProcedure:\n1. Blend the garlic, ginger and one of the onions in a food processor then mix with the curry paste.\n2. Fry the lamb in a little oil, then add the remaining onion.\n3. Gently fry for a minute, then add the paste and cook for a couple of minutes.\n4. Add the water, tin of tomatoes, sugar, mushrooms and potatoes, and gently simmer covered for a few hours, until everything is tender.\n5. Add the two fresh tomatoes and the spinach and cook for a couple of minutes, then serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering the main ingredients until tender, which is essential before adding the fresh tomatoes and spinach in Step 5 for final cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries and sugar to refrigerate, which can be done independently of mixing the dry ingredients for the shortcakes in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries and can be done independently of making the shortcake dough in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients which is necessary before Step 3, where butter is rubbed into the flour mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries and can be done independently and prior to making the dough in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be completed before adding the wet ingredients in Step 4 to form the dough.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create coarse crumbs, which must be done before adding the wet ingredients in Step 4 to form the dough.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to kneading the dough in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients which is essential before adding wet ingredients and butter in Steps 3 and 4 to form the dough.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which must occur before forming the dough in Step 4 and subsequently kneading it in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough, which must be done before kneading it in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries and can be done independently and prior to making the dough in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the dough, which must occur before the dough can be divided in half in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which is essential before forming the dough in Step 4 and subsequently dividing it in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough which must be done before it can be divided in half in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which must be done before the dough is divided in half in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to preparing and baking the shortcake dough in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must occur before the dough can be formed and rolled out in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which is essential before forming the dough in Step 4 and subsequently shaping it in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough which must be done before it can be divided and shaped in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which must be done before the dough can be divided and shaped as described in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough in half, which can be done before or after rolling each half into a circle as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to baking the shortcakes in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be completed before forming and baking the dough in steps 3 through 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which is essential before forming the dough in Step 4, and must occur before shaping and baking the dough in Steps 6, 7, and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough which must be done before it can be shaped and baked in Steps 6, 7, and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which must occur before shaping and baking the dough as described in Steps 6, 7, and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough in half, which must occur before Step 8 where the dough halves are placed on the baking tray.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough which must be completed before placing them on the baking tray in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to baking the shortcakes in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be done before the dough is baked in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which is essential before forming the dough in Step 4 and baking in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough which must be baked in Step 9, thus it must occur before baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which must occur before baking the shortcakes in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough in half, which must occur before baking the shortcakes in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough, which must be done before baking in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on the baking tray, which must occur before Step 9's baking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to baking the shortcakes in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcakes, which must be done before baking them in Step 9, well before cooling them in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create crumbs, which is essential before forming the dough and baking, thus it must occur before baking (Step 9), not after cooling (Step 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough which is essential before baking the shortcakes in Step 9, whereas Step 10 involves cooling the baked shortcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough which must occur before baking (Step 9), whereas Step 10 is cooling the baked shortcakes.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough, which must occur before baking (Step 9), and thus before cooling (Step 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough which must occur before baking in Step 9, whereas Step 10 involves cooling the baked shortcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on the baking tray to bake, which must occur before Step 10 where the baked shortcakes are cooled on a wire rack.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which must be completed before they can be cooled on a wire rack in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries with sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to making the lemon butter in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be prepared before the lemon butter in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour for the shortcake dough, which is independent and can be completed before creating the lemon butter mixture in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves making the dough for the shortcakes, which needs to be done before baking in Step 9, while Step 11 is preparing lemon butter for assembly, which is used later in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough which is essential before baking in Step 9, while Step 11, preparing lemon butter, can be done independently and is used later in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough, which is necessary before baking in Step 9, while Step 11 is preparing the lemon butter for assembly, which is used later in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves shaping the dough, must occur before baking in Step 9, whereas Step 11, preparing lemon butter, can be done independently while the shortcakes cool.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on the baking tray to bake, which is independent of making the lemon butter in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which is independent of preparing the lemon butter in Step 11; both steps can proceed simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes, while Step 11 is preparing the lemon butter, which can be done simultaneously as they do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which can be done independently and prior to beating the cream in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be prepared before baking in Step 9, whereas Step 12 involves beating cream for the topping, which is used after the shortcakes are baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the shortcake dough, which must be baked and cooled before the whipped cream is made in Step 12 for assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves making the dough for the shortcakes, which needs to be baked and cooled before assembling with whipped cream in Step 15, while Step 12 involves beating the cream which is used later in the assembly process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough for the shortcakes, which must be done before baking in Step 9, while Step 12 involves beating cream for the topping, which is independent of the dough preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough, which is necessary before baking in Step 9, while Step 12 involves beating cream, which is independent of the dough preparation and used later in assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves shaping the dough, must occur before baking in Step 9, while Step 12 involves beating cream which is independent of the dough preparation and baking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on a baking tray and precedes baking, which needs to be completed before the whipped cream is prepared in Step 12 for assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes which must be cooled before assembly in Step 14, while Step 12 involves beating the cream which can be done concurrently or after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes, which can occur independently of beating the cream in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which involves combining butter and lemon zest, can be prepared independently of Step 12, where cream is beaten until it thickens.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves refrigerating the strawberries and sugar to allow them to macerate, which can be done independently and prior to whipping the cream in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be prepared before the whipped cream in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour to make the dough for the shortcakes, which must be completed before baking in Step 9, whereas Step 13 involves beating cream for the topping, which is independent of the dough preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves making the dough for the shortcakes, which needs to be baked and cooled before assembling with whipped cream made in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough for the shortcakes, which must be done before baking in Step 9, while Step 13 involves beating the cream for topping, which is independent of the dough preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves dividing the dough, must occur before baking in Step 9, and is independent of Step 13, where cream is beaten to form stiff peaks.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough for the shortcakes, which must be done before baking in Step 9, while Step 13 involves beating the cream for topping, which can be prepared independently and does not affect the preparation of the dough.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on a baking tray to bake, which is independent of Step 13 where cream is beaten until stiff peaks form; these steps do not depend on each other and can be performed simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which must be cooled before assembly in Step 14, while Step 13 involves preparing the whipped cream which can be done concurrently or after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes, which can occur simultaneously with beating the cream in Step 13, as these processes do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 can be completed independently of Step 13 as it involves preparing a different component of the dessert.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the cream until it begins to thicken, which is a necessary precursor to adding sugar and beating until stiff peaks form in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries with sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which needs to be done before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be done before the dough is formed and baked in steps 3 to 9, all of which occur before assembling the shortcakes in step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour to make the dough, which must be done before baking the shortcakes in Step 9, well before splitting them in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves making the dough for the shortcakes, which must be completed and baked (steps 5-10) before assembling the shortcakes with fillings in step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough which is essential to form the shortcakes before baking, while Step 14 is about assembling the baked shortcakes, thus kneading must occur before baking and assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough, which is necessary before baking in Step 9, while Step 14 involves splitting the baked shortcakes for assembly, which occurs after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough into circles before baking, which must occur before the shortcakes are baked and subsequently split in half in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on a baking tray to bake, which must occur before the shortcakes can be split and assembled in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which must be completed and cooled before they can be split and assembled in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes and must occur before Step 14, which involves assembling the shortcakes with fillings.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which involves combining butter and lemon zest, can be completed independently of the whipping of the cream in Step 14 and does not rely on the sequence of whipping the cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12, which involves beating the cream until it thickens and forms stiff peaks, can be completed before splitting the shortcakes in Step 14, as the whipped cream needs to be ready for assembling the shortcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves beating the cream until stiff peaks form, which can be done independently and prior to splitting and assembling the shortcakes in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves combining strawberries and sugar and refrigerating them until serving, which needs to be done before they are used in Step 15 for assembly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be completed before the dough can be made and baked in subsequent steps, long before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour to create the dough for the shortcakes, which must be completed long before assembling the shortcakes with toppings in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves making the dough for the shortcakes, which must be completed and baked (steps 5-10) before assembling the shortcakes with toppings in step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which is necessary before baking the shortcakes in Step 9, while Step 15 is part of the assembly of the finished shortcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves dividing the dough, which is necessary before baking the shortcakes in Step 9, while Step 15 is part of the assembly of the finished shortcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough into circles before baking, which must occur before the shortcakes are baked, cooled, and assembled in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on a baking tray to bake, which must occur before assembling the shortcakes with fillings and toppings in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which must be completed and cooled before they can be split and assembled with toppings in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes and must occur before assembling them in Step 15, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 can be completed earlier as it only involves preparing the lemon butter, which does not depend on the assembly of the shortcakes in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12, which involves beating the cream until it thickens and forms stiff peaks, can be completed before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15, as the whipped cream needs to be ready for topping.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13, which involves beating the cream until stiff peaks form, can be completed before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15, as the whipped cream needs to be ready for topping.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves splitting the shortcakes in half, which is necessary before you can apply the lemon butter, strawberries, and whipped cream as described in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 105, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the strawberries with sugar and needs to be done before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15 and 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 106, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves combining dry ingredients for the shortcake dough, which must be done before baking the shortcakes in Step 9, well before assembling the final dessert in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 107, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture, which is essential for making the dough for the shortcakes, and must occur before baking and assembling the shortcakes in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 108, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough for the shortcakes, which must be completed and baked (steps 5-10) before assembling the shortcakes with toppings in step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 109, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough, which is essential to form the shortcakes before they are baked in Step 9 and assembled in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 110, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves dividing the dough in half, must occur before baking and assembling the shortcakes, which are completed in steps 9 and 16 respectively.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 111, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves shaping the dough, which must occur before baking and assembling the shortcakes in steps 9 and 15 respectively.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 112, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves placing the dough on a baking tray to bake, which must occur before assembling the shortcakes in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 113, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves baking the shortcakes, which must be completed before they can be assembled with toppings in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 114, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooling the shortcakes, which must be done before they can be split and assembled with fillings in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 115, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which involves combining butter and lemon zest, must be completed before Step 15 where the lemon butter is used to spread on the cake bottoms.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 116, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves beating the cream which is used in Step 15, before the final assembly in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 117, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves beating the cream to form stiff peaks, which needs to be done before assembling the shortcakes in Step 15 and 16 where the whipped cream is used.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 118, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves splitting the shortcakes in half, which is necessary before they can be assembled with fillings in Step 15 and finally covered in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 30, "title": "lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes", "question_idx": 119, "steps": ["In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.", "In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.", "Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.", "Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).", "Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.", "Divide dough in half.", "Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.", "Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.", "Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.", "Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.", "Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.", "In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.", "Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.", "To assemble, split shortcakes in half.", "Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.", "Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lemon-zested-strawberry-shortcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a small bowl, combine strawberries and sugar; cover and refrigerate until serving.\n2. In a bowl, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.\n3. Rub the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.\n4. Combine the milk, egg yolk and lemon zest; stir into crumb mixture until a soft dough forms (dough will be sticky).\n5. Turn onto a lightly floured surface; knead 10 times.\n6. Divide dough in half.\n7. Gently pat or roll each half into a 1 .75cm thick circle.\n8. Place 5cm apart on an ungreased baking tray.\n9. Bake at 200 C / Gas 6 for 8-10 minutes or until golden brown.\n10. Remove to a wire rack; cool for 15 minutes.\n11. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, combine butter and lemon zest; set aside.\n12. In a small mixing bowl, beat cream until it begins to thicken.\n13. Add sugar; beat until stiff peaks form.\n14. To assemble, split shortcakes in half.\n15. Place cake bottoms on dessert plates; spread with lemon butter, then top each with a 1/4 of the strawberries and whipped cream.\n16. Cover with shortcake top and remaining berries and cream.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves assembling the base of the shortcakes with lemon butter, strawberries, and whipped cream, which logically precedes adding the shortcake top and additional berries and cream in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil which must occur before adding the onion in Step 2 to ensure proper cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil which is necessary before adding the onion in Step 2, which precedes Step 3 where celery and carrot are added.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion to soften it before adding the celery and carrot in Step 3, but these steps can be interchanged or done simultaneously as long as all ingredients are properly softened before proceeding.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil which is necessary before adding ingredients like onion in Step 2, which precedes Step 4 where garlic and spices are added.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion which is foundational for flavor development before adding spices in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, while Step 4 involves adding spices; these steps can be interchanged without affecting the overall cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil which is necessary before adding ingredients like onions in Step 2, which precedes adding lentils and other ingredients in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion which is foundational for flavor development before adding other ingredients like lentils and tomatoes in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which needs to be done before adding the lentils and other ingredients in Step 5 to ensure they are properly softened and integrated into the flavor base.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices to release their flavors before adding the lentils and liquids in Step 5, which is essential for flavor development in the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil, which is necessary to cook the onion in Step 2, well before the simmering process in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion, which is necessary before adding other ingredients like lentils and tomatoes in Step 5, which precede Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which must be done before adding the lentils and other ingredients in Step 5 and before simmering in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and garlic before adding lentils and liquids in Step 5, which is necessary for flavor development and must occur before the simmering in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the pan which must occur before Step 6's simmering process to cook those ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil in a saucepan which is essential to start cooking the main ingredients, while Step 7 is preparing a garnish that is used at the end, thus these steps do not need to be sequential.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion which is essential for the base flavor of the soup, while Step 7 is preparing the garnish which can be done at any time before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which is part of the initial soup preparation, while Step 7 is about preparing the garnish, which can be done independently of the soup's main cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices which is essential for developing the soup's flavor early in the cooking process, while Step 7 is about preparing the garnish which can be done at any time before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding main ingredients for the soup to cook, while Step 7 is preparing the garnish, which can be done independently of the soup's initial cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to soften the lentils and vegetables, while Step 7 is preparing the garnish, which can be done independently at any time during or after the simmering process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil, which is necessary to begin cooking the onions in Step 2, long before the bay leaf is removed in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion, which is necessary before adding other ingredients like lentils and tomatoes in later steps, and must occur before Step 8, which involves removing the bay leaf after the soup has been cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which is necessary before blending the soup in Step 9, whereas Step 8 is about removing the bay leaf after the soup has been cooked and before it is blended.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and garlic which is essential for flavor development early in the cooking process, while Step 8 is about removing the bay leaf after the soup has simmered.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to create the base of the soup, which needs to occur before Step 8 where the bay leaf is removed after the soup has simmered.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to soften the lentils and vegetables, which must occur before Step 8 where the bay leaf is removed, typically after the cooking process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves stirring coriander into the yoghurt for garnish, can be completed independently of the soup's cooking process and does not need to follow the removal of the bay leaf in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil in a saucepan, which is necessary to begin cooking the ingredients, and must occur before any ingredients are added or cooked, including those actions described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion, which is essential for developing the base flavor of the soup and must occur before the blending process in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which must be done before blending the soup in Step 9 to ensure they are properly softened and integrated into the soup's texture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and garlic to release their flavors, which is essential before blending the soup in Step 9 to ensure the flavors are well incorporated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the soup and must occur before Step 9, where the soup is blended after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to soften the lentils and vegetables, which must occur before blending the soup in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves stirring coriander into the yoghurt for garnish, can be completed at any time before serving and does not depend on the blending of the soup in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, removing the bay leaf, can occur before blending in Step 9 to ensure it is not blended into the soup, but it is not strictly required to follow this sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil in a saucepan, which is necessary to start the cooking process, and must occur before any ingredients are added or cooked, including those actions described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions which is essential for the base flavor of the soup and must occur before the other ingredients are added and the soup is cooked, blended, and seasoned in subsequent steps.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup before blending and seasoning in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and garlic which is essential for flavor development early in the cooking process, while Step 10 is about adjusting the soup's consistency after it has been blended.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to create the base of the soup, which must occur before blending and adjusting the consistency in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to cook the lentils and vegetables, which must occur before blending and adjusting the consistency in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves stirring coriander into the yoghurt for garnish, can be completed at any time before serving and does not depend on the consistency of the soup adjusted in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, removing the bay leaf, should occur before blending the soup in Step 9 to avoid blending the bay leaf into the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves blending the soup to achieve smoothness, which can be done before adjusting the consistency in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil, which is necessary to start the cooking process, and must occur before any ingredients are cooked, including those in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion, which is essential for developing the base flavor of the soup and must occur before the other ingredients are added and the soup is cooked and blended, as described in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup before blending and seasoning in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and garlic to release their flavors early in the cooking process, which is essential before the main ingredients like lentils and tomatoes are added in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to create the base of the soup, which must occur before seasoning and reheating in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to cook the lentils and vegetables, which must occur before blending and reheating in steps 9 and 11; thus, it does not depend on the reheating step.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves preparing the garnish which can be done at any time before serving and does not depend on the completion of Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, removing the bay leaf, should occur before blending the soup in Step 9 to avoid blending the bay leaf into the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves blending the soup to achieve smoothness, which should occur before reheating and seasoning in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adjusting the soup's consistency before seasoning and reheating in Step 11, but these steps can be interchanged based on personal preference for consistency and taste.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the oil, which is necessary to start the cooking process, and must occur before any ingredients are cooked, including those in the subsequent steps leading up to Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup and must occur before the soup is cooked and served in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the celery and carrot, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup and must occur before the soup is blended and served in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking spices and must occur before the soup is blended and served, which are described in steps 9 and 12 respectively.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to cook, which is essential before blending and serving the soup in later steps, including Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves simmering the soup to cook the lentils and vegetables, which must occur before blending and serving the soup in steps 9 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves preparing the coriander yoghurt garnish, which is used in Step 12, hence it can be completed at any time before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, removing the bay leaf, must occur before blending the soup in Step 9 to ensure no large pieces remain, which is well before serving the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves blending the soup to achieve smoothness, which must be completed before Step 12 where the soup is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adjusting the soup's consistency before reheating and serving in Steps 11 and 12, so it must occur before Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 31, "title": "lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Heat the oil in a saucepan.", "Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.", "Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.", "Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.", "Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.", "Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.", "Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.", "Remove the bay leaf from the soup.", "Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.", "Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.", "Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.", "Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: lightly spiced tomato and red lentil soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the oil in a saucepan.\n2. Add the onion and cook over a low heat for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until beginning to soften.\n3. Stir in the celery and carrot and cook for 3 minutes, stirring frequently.\n4. Add the garlic, cumin and coriander and cook for a further minute, stirring constantly.\n5. Add the lentils, stock, tomatoes with their juice, tomato pur\u00c3\u00a9e and bay leaf.\n6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat, then half-cover the pan with a lid and simmer for 25-30 minutes until the lentils and vegetables are very soft.\n7. Meanwhile, stir the coriander into the yoghurt for the garnish.\n8. Remove the bay leaf from the soup.\n9. Blend the soup in the pan using a hand-held blender, or tip into a blender or food processor, process until smooth, then return the soup to the pan.\n10. Check the consistency; it will be fairly thick, so if you prefer it thinner, dilute with a little more stock.\n11. Season to taste, then reheat until just bubbling.\n12. Serve drizzled with some of the coriander yoghurt and sprinkled with freshly ground black pepper.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves reheating the soup until just bubbling, which should be completed before serving the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which can be done independently and concurrently with preparing the baking tray in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which can be done independently and does not affect the mixing of ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which is necessary before placing the dough on it in Step 6, and does not depend on the mixing process completed in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing flour, Splenda, and butter which is necessary to create the crumble before adding other ingredients in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients or forming dough to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray, which needs to be ready before placing the dough balls on it in Step 6, thus it does not need to occur after Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the dry ingredients which must occur before adding the wet ingredients like egg in Step 5 to form a dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating a crumbly mixture of flour, Splenda, and butter, which is necessary before adding the egg and currants in Step 5 to form a dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 6, placing dough balls on the tray, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray before any dough is placed on it, which logically occurs before forming and placing the dough balls in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the initial ingredients which is necessary before forming the dough balls in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the crumble mixture which is essential before forming the dough balls in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves mixing the egg and currants into the dough, which must be done before forming and placing the dough balls on the baking tray in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the dough on the tray (Step 7) to ensure the oven is ready for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray before any dough is placed on it, which must occur before Step 6 where the dough is actually placed on the tray.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the initial ingredients which is essential before forming and baking the dough balls in Step 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves creating the dough mixture, which must be done before shaping and baking the dough as described in Steps 6 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves mixing the dough which needs to be done before shaping and placing the dough balls on the tray in Step 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the dough balls on the tray, which logically must occur before spacing them out as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 8 as the oven needs to be preheated before the cakes can be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray before baking, which must occur before Step 8 where the cakes are actually baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing ingredients which is essential to form the dough before baking, hence it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing ingredients to form a crumble, which is essential before forming dough and baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves mixing the egg and currants into the dough, which is essential before baking the dough in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the dough on the baking tray, which must occur before baking in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves spacing the dough balls on the tray, which must occur before baking them in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cakes in Step 8, not after they are removed and cooled in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking tray before baking, which must occur before Step 8 where the cakes are baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing ingredients which is essential to form the dough before baking, thus it must occur before Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing ingredients to form a crumble, which is essential before baking the cakes in Step 8; it cannot occur after the cakes are baked and cooled in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding the egg and currants to form the dough, which is essential before baking the cakes in Step 8; Step 9 is about cooling the cakes after they are baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the dough on the baking tray, which must occur before baking (Step 8) and cooling (Step 9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves spacing the dough balls on the baking tray before baking, which must occur before Step 8 (baking) and therefore before Step 9 (cooling).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 32, "title": "no-sugar-rock-cakes", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.", "Line a baking tray with baking parchment.", "Mix flour, Splenda&reg;", "and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.", "Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.", "Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;", "remember to space them out.", "Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.", "Remove and place on cooling tray."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: no-sugar-rock-cakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 200 C / Gas 6.\n2. Line a baking tray with baking parchment.\n3. Mix flour, Splenda&reg;\n4. and butter in a bowl until a fine crumble is achieved.\n5. Add the egg and currants, and mix into a dough.\n6. Place balls of dough (slightly bigger than a golf ball) onto the baking tray;\n7. remember to space them out.\n8. Bake for 20 minutes, or till a nice golden brown.\n9. Remove and place on cooling tray.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves baking the cakes until golden brown, which must occur before Step 9, where the cakes are removed and placed on a cooling tray.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing and combining the ingredients which must occur before they can be melted and combined in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the cheese mixture which must be done before it can be spooned onto toast and grilled in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the cheese mixture which needs to be completed before spooning onto toast in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the cheese mixture which must be done before it can be applied to the toast and grilled in Step 3 and Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves melting the cheese mixture, which must occur before it can be spooned onto toast and grilled in Step 3, and well before serving in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 33, "title": "old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.", "Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.", "Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.", "Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: old-fashioned-welsh-rarebit\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grate 250g well-flavoured mature Cheddar cheese (you can also use a good Double Gloucester or Shropshire) and put into a heavy-based medium-sized pan (preferably nonstick) with 10g butter, 1 tsp mustard (English, wholegrain or Dijon), plenty of ground black pepper and 4 tbsp ale or semi-skimmed milk.\n2. Set over a low heat and melt gently, stirring, until smooth and thick.\n3. Spoon onto 4 thick slices of toast and grill until browned and bubbling.\n4. Serve with grilled mushrooms and a leaf salad for a light lunch or snack.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves spooning the cheese mixture onto toast and grilling it, which must be completed before serving with side dishes as described in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and covering it with water, which is necessary to start the cooking process before boiling and skimming fat in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and starting the cooking process, which must occur before adding other ingredients in subsequent steps like Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves simmering the lamb and skimming off fat, which is necessary before adding vegetables in Step 3 to ensure the base broth is prepared.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and starting the cooking process, which must occur before adding vegetables in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves simmering the lamb and skimming off fat, which is essential before adding vegetables in later steps for proper cooking and flavor development.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and breaking up the first batch of potatoes to thicken the stew before adding the remaining potatoes and carrots in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and must occur before cooking and adding other ingredients, including those in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves simmering the lamb and skimming off fat, which is essential before adding vegetables in later steps to ensure the lamb is tender and the broth is clear.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and breaking up the first batch of potatoes to thicken the stew, which must occur before adding the remaining potatoes and carrots in Step 4, which is followed by Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding the remaining potatoes and carrots, which must occur before they can be cooked as described in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and starting the cooking process, which is essential to occur before seasoning and final additions in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling and skimming fat from the lamb, which is essential for preparing the base of the stew before other ingredients like potatoes and carrots are added, as outlined in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and breaking up the initial batch of potatoes to thicken the stew, which must occur before the final seasoning and garnishing in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding remaining potatoes and carrots which need to cook before seasoning and garnishing in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves simmering the stew until the potatoes are cooked, which is necessary before seasoning in Step 6 to ensure proper taste and texture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the lamb in the pot and must occur before cooking and adding other ingredients, which precedes Step 7 where parsley or leeks are added just before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling and skimming fat from the lamb, which is essential for preparing the base of the stew before adding other ingredients like in steps 3-7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and breaking up the initial batch of potatoes to thicken the stew, which must occur before adding the remaining ingredients in subsequent steps, including Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding remaining potatoes and carrots which need to be cooked before seasoning and adding garnishes in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves simmering the remaining potatoes and carrots until cooked, which must occur before Step 7 where fresh parsley or chopped leeks are added for flavor, indicating that Step 5 does not depend on Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Seasoning with salt and pepper in Step 6 can be done either before or after adding parsley or leeks in Step 7, as these steps are independent in terms of flavor adjustment.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves starting the cooking process by boiling the lamb, which logically precedes all other steps including serving the stew in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling and skimming fat from the lamb, which is essential for preparing the base of the stew before other ingredients are added and before it is served in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking some of the potatoes to thicken the stew, which is essential before adding the remaining ingredients and serving, as described in steps 4 through 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding remaining potatoes and carrots, which is essential for completing the cooking process before serving in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 8 because the potatoes need to be cooked before the stew is ready to serve.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves seasoning the stew, which must be done before Step 8 where the stew is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 34, "title": "one-pot irish stew", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.", "Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.", "Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.", "Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.", "Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.", "Season well with salt and pepper to taste.", "Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.", "Serve piping hot."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: one-pot irish stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the lamb in a large pot, cover with water and add a pinch of salt.\n2. Bring to the boil; skim off any white fat that comes to the surface, then simmer on low heat for another 30 minutes.\n3. Add the onion and half of the potatoes and cook for 30 minutes until the potatoes are soft; break them up and stir - this will thicken the stew.\n4. Add the remaining potatoes and carrots.\n5. Simmer for another 20-30 minutes until potatoes are cooked.\n6. Season well with salt and pepper to taste.\n7. Stir in fresh parsley or chopped leeks.\n8. Serve piping hot.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves stirring in fresh parsley or chopped leeks, which should be done before serving (Step 8) to ensure they are mixed throughout the stew.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion which must occur before Step 2, where the onion is cooked until softened.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion which is essential to start the cooking process before adding mushrooms in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onion until softened, which is necessary before adding the mushrooms in Step 3 to ensure proper layering of flavors.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion which is essential to start the cooking process before adding mushrooms in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions until softened, which is necessary before adding the mushrooms in Step 3 and 4, thus it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms which must occur before they can release their juices as described in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion which is essential to prepare the base for the dish before adding other ingredients like mushrooms and seasonings in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions until softened, which is necessary before adding mushrooms in Step 3; it is unrelated to the addition of mustard, lemon zest, garlic, and sherry in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms which need to be cooked before adding the ingredients in Step 5, which are used to create a sauce for the cooked mushrooms.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the mushrooms until they release their juices, which is necessary before adding other ingredients in Step 5 to ensure proper flavor and texture development.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion, which is necessary to start the cooking process before adding other ingredients like mushrooms in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions until softened, which is necessary before adding mushrooms in Step 3, and does not depend on the actions taken in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms which need to be cooked before being mixed with other ingredients in Step 6, thus it does not need to happen after Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the mushrooms until they release their juices, which is necessary before adding other ingredients in Step 5 and 6 for proper flavor integration and sauce formation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the mushrooms, which must occur before Step 6 where the mushrooms are cooked with these new ingredients until evenly coated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and cooking onions which is essential to prepare the base for the mushroom mixture, independent of the preparation of peppers in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions which is essential before adding mushrooms in Step 3, while Step 7 involves preparing the peppers to be added later, and these tasks do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms to cook, which is independent of draining and slicing peppers in Step 7; these steps can occur simultaneously or in any order.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking mushrooms until they release their juices, which is independent of draining and slicing peppers as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the mushrooms to create a sauce, which can be done independently of draining and slicing the peppers in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the mushrooms until they are evenly coated with sauce, which can be completed independently before mixing in the peppers in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion, which is essential to start the cooking process and must occur before adding other ingredients like mushrooms and peppers in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions which is essential before adding mushrooms in Step 3, and this sequence must occur before mixing in the peppers in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms which need to be cooked before mixing with the peppers in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the mushrooms until they release their juices, which is necessary before adding other ingredients like mustard and sherry in Step 5, and must occur before mixing in the peppers in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the mushrooms to create a sauce, which needs to occur before mixing in the peppers in Step 8 to ensure proper flavor integration and coating.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the mushrooms with added ingredients to create a sauce, which should be completed before adding the peppers in Step 8 to ensure proper flavor integration and coating.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves preparing the peppers which are then mixed into the mushrooms in Step 8, so Step 7 must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onion, which is essential to start the cooking process and must occur before adding other ingredients like mushrooms, peppers, and tuna.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions which is essential to prepare the base for adding mushrooms and other ingredients; it does not depend on the addition of tuna and parsley which happens in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms which need to be cooked before combining with other ingredients like peppers and tuna in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking mushrooms until they release their juices, which is essential before adding other ingredients like mustard and sherry in Step 5; it does not depend on the addition of tuna in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the mushrooms to create a sauce, which is necessary before mixing in the peppers and tuna in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the mushrooms with added ingredients to create a sauce, which is necessary before adding the peppers and tuna in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves preparing the peppers which are then mixed with the mushrooms in Step 8, before adding the tuna in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the peppers into the mushrooms to heat them, which logically precedes adding the tuna in Step 9 to ensure all ingredients are heated through before serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding onions, which is necessary to start the cooking process, and must occur before the final serving step (Step 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the onions which is essential to prepare the base for the mushroom and pepper mixture, and must occur before adding other ingredients like mushrooms, peppers, and tuna.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding mushrooms early in the cooking process, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and completing the dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before adding other ingredients like mustard, lemon zest, and sherry in Step 5, which are essential for the final dish preparation before serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the mushrooms which is essential before mixing with peppers and tuna in later steps, and cannot logically occur after the dish is served in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the mushrooms with added ingredients to create a sauce, which must occur before mixing in the peppers and tuna in subsequent steps, not after serving the dish as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves preparing the peppers which are then mixed with the mushrooms in Step 8, before the tuna is added in Step 9, all of which occur before serving the dish in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the peppers into the mushrooms and heating them, which must occur before adding the tuna and parsley in Step 9, and serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 35, "title": "peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.", "Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.", "Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.", "Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.", "Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.", "Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.", "Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.", "Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.", "Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.", "Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: peppers-with-tuna-and-mushrooms\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a frying pan and add 1 chopped onion.\n2. Cook for 5 minutes or until softened.\n3. Add 250g halved or quartered chestnut mushrooms.\n4. Season and cook, stirring occasionally, until the mushrooms give up their juices.\n5. Add 1 tbsp wholegrain mustard, the grated zest of 1 lemon, 1 crushed garlic clove and 4 tbsp dry sherry.\n6. Cook, stirring until the mushrooms are evenly coated with a little sauce.\n7. Meanwhile, drain and slice a 280g jar of roasted red peppers.\n8. Mix the peppers into the mushrooms and heat gently for 1 minute.\n9. Finally, stir in a 185g can tuna, drained, and 25g chopped fresh parsley.\n10. Serve immediately, with crisp salad leaves and plenty of hot crusty bread or boiled rice.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding tuna and parsley to the dish, which must be done before serving the dish as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves crushing the garlic which is then used in Step 2, hence it must occur before Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves crushing garlic which is a foundational ingredient that needs to be prepared before mixing with other ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves transferring the crushed garlic to a mixing bowl, which is necessary before adding and mixing other ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves crushing garlic which is foundational for the subsequent steps, including mixing with other ingredients in Step 3 and Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves transferring the crushed garlic to a mixing bowl, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and making the mayonnaise in Step 3 and 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 36, "title": "rouille", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.", "Transfer to a mixing bowl.", "Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.", "When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: rouille\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a mortar, crush the garlic to a fine mash.\n2. Transfer to a mixing bowl.\n3. Add the egg yolks, and beat into a mayonnaise while adding the olive oil.\n4. When the sauce is thick and smooth, stir in the cayenne pepper and saffron.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves creating the mayonnaise base which is essential before adding the spices in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 37, "title": "sardine spread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.", "Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: sardine spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.\n2. Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.\n3. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 2 because the sardines need to be mashed before the other ingredients can be added and mixed together.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 37, "title": "sardine spread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.", "Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: sardine spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.\n2. Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.\n3. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 3 because the sardines need to be prepared before they can be enjoyed as a spread.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 37, "title": "sardine spread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.", "Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: sardine spread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the sardines in a bowl and roughly mash with a fork.\n2. Add in all of the remaining ingredients and stir well.\n3. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding and mixing all ingredients which is essential before Step 3, where the spread is enjoyed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the dry ingredients which must be done before adding the butter in Step 2 to ensure even distribution and proper texture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the dry ingredients which must be done before adding the wet ingredient (milk) in Step 3 to form the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves incorporating butter into the flour mixture to create a crumb-like texture, which is necessary before adding the liquid (milk) in Step 3 to form the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the dry ingredients which is essential to prepare the mixture before adding wet ingredients in Step 3 and mixing in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves incorporating butter into the flour before adding milk in Step 3, which is essential for creating the right texture before forming the dough in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 4 as it involves adding milk to the dry ingredients, which is necessary before mixing to form the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves sifting the dry ingredients which is essential to prepare the mixture before adding other ingredients and forming the dough in the subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves incorporating butter into the flour mixture to create a crumb-like texture, which is essential before forming and kneading the dough in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding milk to form the dough, which is necessary before kneading and rolling out the dough in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 38, "title": "scone-pastry", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.", "Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.", "Make a well in the centre and add the milk.", "Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.", "Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: scone-pastry\n\nProcedure:\n1. Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a bowl.\n2. Add the butter and rub in until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.\n3. Make a well in the centre and add the milk.\n4. Mix with a wooden spoon or your fingers to make a fairly soft but not sticky dough, adding a little more milk if necessary.\n5. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and knead briefly, then roll out and use as required.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the ingredients to form the dough, which must occur before kneading and rolling the dough in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding potatoes, carrots, and onion to the pan before boiling, which is necessary to occur before Step 2, where the contents are brought to a boil.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling vegetables which must be done before adding the corned beef in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 3 to ensure the vegetables are partially cooked before adding the corned beef.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the base ingredients which must be cooked before adding the corned beef and gravy granules in Steps 3 and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling and simmering the vegetables before adding the corned beef in Step 3 and the gravy granules in Step 4, so it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding corned beef which needs to be cooked before thickening the stew with gravy granules in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the base ingredients which must occur before thickening the stew in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves boiling and simmering the vegetables, which is necessary before adding the corned beef and gravy granules in subsequent steps to complete the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 5 as the corned beef needs to be added and simmered before the gravy granules are added and the stew thickens in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding gravy granules to thicken the stew, which logically precedes Step 5 where the stew thickens as a result of adding the granules.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the initial ingredients which must occur before the subsequent cooking and thickening steps, including Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 6 as it involves boiling the vegetables which is essential before adding other ingredients and serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 6 as it involves adding corned beef to the stew, which is essential before the final thickening and serving steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves adding gravy granules to thicken the stew, must occur before Step 6, as the stew needs to thicken before it is ready to serve.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 39, "title": "shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.", "Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.", "Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.", "Add gravy granules and stir.", "The stew will now thicken up.", "It is now ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: shellabina-s-corned-beef-hash\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add potatoes, carrots and onion to a large pan and add water to cover.\n2. Bring to boil and simmer for 20 minutes.\n3. Add corned beef and simmer for another 5 minutes.\n4. Add gravy granules and stir.\n5. The stew will now thicken up.\n6. It is now ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, where the stew thickens, naturally occurs before Step 6, which is serving the dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking when the batter is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before adding ingredients like in Step 3 to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the batter preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming the butter and sugar which must be done before adding eggs in Step 3 to ensure proper mixing and texture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the batter preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is essential to form the base of the batter before adding eggs in Step 3 and potentially adding milk in Step 4 if the batter is too thick.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is necessary before thinning the mixture with milk in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 7 to ensure the oven is adequately preheated for baking, not necessarily after Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves creaming the butter and sugar which is essential to form the base of the batter before adding flour in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the butter and sugar mixture, which is necessary before adding flour in Step 5 to ensure proper mixing and consistency of the batter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adjusting the batter's consistency before adding flour in Step 5, so it should occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 6, spooning the batter into the muffin tin, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is essential for creating the cupcake batter, and must occur before adding this batter to the muffin tin in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding and beating eggs into the mixture, which must occur before spooning the batter into the muffin tin in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adjusting the batter's consistency before it is spooned into the muffin tin in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves mixing the flour into the batter, which must be done before Step 6 where the batter is spooned into the muffin tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 7, baking the cupcakes, to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is essential for preparing the batter before baking, hence it must occur before Step 7 where the cupcakes are baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is essential before baking the cupcakes in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adjusting the batter's consistency before baking, which must be done before Step 7 where the cupcakes are actually baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding flour to the batter, which must be done before baking the cupcakes in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spooning the batter into the muffin tin, which must be done before baking in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before baking the cupcakes in Step 7, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is a foundational step in making the batter, and must occur before baking the cupcakes in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the batter, which must occur before baking the cupcakes in Step 7; Step 8 is a test for doneness after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adjusting the batter's consistency before baking, which must occur before Step 7 where the batter is baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding flour to the batter, which must be done before baking the cupcakes in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spooning the batter into the muffin tin, which must occur before baking in Step 7, and therefore before checking if they are done in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves baking the cupcakes, which must occur before Step 8, where the doneness of the cupcakes is checked with a skewer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cupcakes in Step 7, not after they are cooled in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is an initial step in making the batter, and must occur before baking and cooling steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is essential before baking the cupcakes in Step 7, whereas Step 9 is about cooling the cupcakes after they are baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves adjusting the batter consistency, occurs during the batter preparation phase before baking, whereas Step 9 is part of the cooling process after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding flour to the batter, which is part of the preparation before baking, whereas Step 9 is about cooling the cupcakes after they have been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spooning the batter into the muffin tin, which must occur before baking (Step 7) and cooling (Step 9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves baking the cupcakes, which must occur before they can rest and cool as described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, checking if the cake is done, must occur before Step 9, which involves resting and cooling the cupcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cupcakes in Step 7, not after decorating them in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating butter and sugar which is an initial step in making the batter, whereas Step 10 is about decorating the already baked cupcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves adding eggs to the batter, which is essential for making the cupcakes and must occur before baking them in Step 7, not after decorating in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adjusting the batter's consistency before baking, which must occur before Step 7 where the cupcakes are baked, not after the decoration step (Step 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding flour to the batter, which is essential for forming the cupcake mixture before baking in Step 7, whereas Step 10 is about decorating the already baked and cooled cupcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spooning the batter into the muffin tin, which must occur before baking (Step 7) and cooling (Step 9), and well before decorating (Step 10).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves baking the cupcakes, which must occur before they can be cooled and decorated in steps 9 and 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, testing if the cake is done, must occur before Step 10, which involves decorating the fully cooled cupcakes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 40, "title": "simple-basic-cupcakes", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.", "Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.", "If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.", "Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.", "Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.", "Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.", "The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.", "Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.", "Decorate, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: simple-basic-cupcakes\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy.\n3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition.\n4. If the batter is too thick, stir in some milk.\n5. Gradually add the flour, mixing well each time until evenly mixed.\n6. Spoon tablespoons of batter into a greased muffin tin.\n7. Bake in preheated oven for 15-20 minutes.\n8. The cake is done when a skewer inserted to the cake comes out clean.\n9. Let rest for fives minutes, then allow to cool fully on a wire rack.\n10. Decorate, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves letting the cupcakes rest and then cooling them on a wire rack, which must occur before decorating them in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the butter and oil to prepare for cooking, which must occur before adding the chicken, onion, and garlic in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the butter and oil, which must occur before adding the chicken, onion, and garlic in Step 2 and before cooking them in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves stirring in the chicken, onion, and garlic, which must occur before they can be cooked and softened in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating the butter and oil, which is necessary before adding ingredients like chicken, onion, and garlic in Step 2, which precedes Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding chicken, onion, and garlic to the pan for cooking, which must occur before Step 4 where spices and tomato puree are added to the cooked ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the chicken, onion, and garlic until the onion is soft, which is necessary before adding the spices in Step 4 to ensure they are mixed into a well-cooked base.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating butter and oil in a pan, which is necessary before adding ingredients like chicken, onion, and garlic in Step 2, all of which precede transferring the mixture to the slow cooker in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding and cooking the chicken, onion, and garlic, which must occur before they are placed into the slow cooker in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the chicken, onion, and garlic until the onion is soft, which is necessary before adding the spices in Step 4 and then transferring the mixture to the slow cooker in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing spices and tomato puree with the chicken in the frying pan, which must be done before transferring the contents to the slow cooker in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating butter and oil to prepare for cooking chicken and onions, which must occur before adding ingredients to the slow cooker in Step 5 and seasoning in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding and cooking the chicken, onion, and garlic, which is essential before adding other ingredients in later steps and before slow cooking, making it independent and necessary prior to Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chicken until the onion is translucent, which is necessary before adding spices and other ingredients in later steps, and does not depend on the seasoning step (Step 6).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing spices and tomato puree with the chicken, which is essential before slow cooking (Step 5), whereas Step 6 involves seasoning, which is unrelated to the mixing of spices.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the slow cooker and mixing them, which can be done before seasoning with salt in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating butter and oil to prepare for cooking chicken and onions, which must occur before the mixture is placed in the slow cooker in Step 5 and cooked as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding and cooking the chicken, onion, and garlic, which is essential before placing the mixture into the slow cooker in Step 5, thus it must occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion until soft and must occur before adding the mixture to the slow cooker in Step 5, which precedes the slow cooking process in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing spices and tomato puree with the chicken and must occur before Step 5, where the mixture is transferred to the slow cooker, which is well before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the slow cooker before cooking, which must occur before Step 7 where the dish is actually cooked in the slow cooker.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves seasoning the dish, which can be adjusted before or even during the cooking process in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating butter and oil to prepare for cooking, which logically occurs before the cooking and slow cooking processes described in subsequent steps, including Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves adding chicken, onion, and garlic to the pan for cooking, which is essential before the mixture is transferred to the slow cooker in Step 5; it cannot logically occur after the final serving step (Step 8).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the onion, garlic, and chicken to soften the onion before adding spices, which is necessary before the mixture is placed in the slow cooker in Step 5 and long before the cardamom pods are removed in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing spices and tomato puree into the chicken mixture, which must occur before the mixture is cooked in the slow cooker (Step 5-7), and before the cardamom pods are removed in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients to the slow cooker which must occur before the cooking process in Step 7, and well before removing the cardamom pods in Step 8 after cooking is complete.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves seasoning the dish, which must be done before the cooking process in Step 7, not after the cardamom pods are discarded in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 41, "title": "slow cooker butter chicken", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.", "Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.", "Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.", "Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.", "Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.", "Season to taste with salt.", "Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.", "Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: slow cooker butter chicken\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat the butter and vegetable oil in a large frying pan over medium heat.\n2. Stir in the chicken, onion and garlic.\n3. Cook and stir until the onion has softened and turned translucent, about 10 minutes.\n4. Stir in the curry powder, curry paste, tandoori masala, garam masala and tomato puree until no lumps of tomato puree remain.\n5. Pour into a slow cooker, and stir in the cardamom pods, coconut milk and yoghurt.\n6. Season to taste with salt.\n7. Cook on High 4 to 6 hours, or on Low 6 to 8 hours until the chicken is tender and the sauce has reduced to your desired consistency.\n8. Remove and discard the cardamom pods before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves cooking the chicken in the slow cooker, which must be completed before Step 8, where the cardamom pods are removed prior to serving.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves topping and tailing the grapefruits, which is necessary to prepare them for the skin removal in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves topping and tailing the grapefruits, which is necessary to prepare them for peeling in Step 2, before any juices are caught in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl to catch the juices, which logically precedes Step 3, where the purpose of using the bowl is explained.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves topping and tailing the grapefruits, which is necessary to prepare them for peeling and segmenting in the subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing the skin off the grapefruit, which is necessary before segmenting the grapefruit in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is a continuation of Step 2, explaining the purpose of slicing the grapefruit over a bowl, and does not depend on the completion of Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the grapefruits, which is necessary before they can be segmented and used in the salad in Steps 4 and 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the grapefruit, which needs to be done before arranging the salad components in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is directly related to Step 2 and involves catching the juices while peeling the grapefruit, which is necessary before segmenting the grapefruits in Step 4 and long before arranging the salad in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves segmenting the grapefruits, which needs to be done before arranging them with the smoked salmon in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the grapefruits, which must be done before they are segmented and added to the salad in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the grapefruit, which needs to be done before arranging them with the smoked salmon in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is directly related to Step 2 and involves catching the juices while slicing the grapefruit, which is necessary before segmenting the grapefruits in Step 4 and using the juice in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves segmenting the grapefruits, which needs to be done before arranging them with the smoked salmon in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves arranging the lettuce which serves as the base for the salad, and it does not necessarily have to be completed after topping it with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the grapefruits, which is necessary before segmenting them in Step 4 and using their juice in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing the skin off the grapefruit to catch the juices, which is necessary before Step 7 where the juice is used for the dressing.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is designed to catch the juices while preparing the grapefruit, which is necessary before mixing the dressing in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves segmenting the grapefruits, which needs to be done before Step 6 where these segments are used in the salad, and before Step 7 where the juice is used for the dressing.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves arranging the base of the salad, which needs to be done before adding toppings and dressing in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the main components of the salad, while Step 7 is about preparing the dressing, which does not depend on the arrangement of the salad components.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the grapefruits, which is necessary before they can be segmented and used in the salad in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 8 because the grapefruit juice collected in Step 2 is needed to make the dressing in Step 7, which is then poured over the salad in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 is directly related to Step 2 and occurs immediately after it to catch the juices while slicing the grapefruit, which is necessary before segmenting and using the juice in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves segmenting the grapefruits, which is necessary to prepare the grapefruit segments used in Step 6, before the dressing is made and poured over the salad in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves arranging the base of the salad, which must be done before topping it with ingredients and dressing in Steps 6 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves arranging the main components of the salad, which must be done before dressing the salad with the mixture prepared in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 42, "title": "smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Top and tail the grapefruits.", "Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.", "This is to catch any juices.", "Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.", "Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.", "Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.", "Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.", "Pour over the salad and serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: smoked-salmon-and-grapefruit-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Top and tail the grapefruits.\n2. Slice the skin off the grapefruit over a bowl.\n3. This is to catch any juices.\n4. Using a small knife, segment the grapefruits over the juice bowl.\n5. Arrange the lamb's lettuce onto each serving plate or a large salad bowl.\n6. Top with grapefruit segments and smoked salmon.\n7. Mix together 1 pinch of cracked peppercorns and 1 tablespoon grapefruit juice from the bowl.\n8. Pour over the salad and serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the dressing which needs to be done before Step 8 where the dressing is poured over the salad.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 is incorrectly formatted and appears before Step 2, indicating it should occur first in the sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which logically precedes mixing them as described in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 is a continuation of Step 1 and should occur before Step 3, which involves mixing the ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before adding liquids in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2, which involves mixing the ingredients, logically occurs before adding liquids in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which can be done before adding the liquids in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before adjusting the liquid amounts in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2, which involves mixing the ingredients, logically occurs before adding liquids in Step 4 and adjusting their amounts in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients which should logically occur before adding liquids in Step 4 and adjusting their amounts in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the slow cooker, while Step 5 adjusts the liquid quantities to ensure proper coverage and ratio, thus they can be interchanged or adjusted simultaneously.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before Step 6, where the positioning of tarragon and bay leaf is adjusted within the already added ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2, which involves mixing the ingredients, logically occurs before adding liquids and seasonings in steps 4 and 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which can be done before adding the liquids and seasonings described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the ingredients in the slow cooker, which is necessary before Step 6, where the positioning of herbs like tarragon and bay leaf is adjusted within the liquid mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves adjusting the liquid levels in the cooker, can be completed before ensuring the herbs are submerged as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before Step 7 where the slow cooker is turned on to simmer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 is a continuation of Step 1 and involves mixing the ingredients, which should occur before cooking starts in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which should be done before Step 7 where the slow cooker is turned on to simmer.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the ingredients in the slow cooker, which must be done before turning on the cooker in Step 7 to allow the ingredients to cook properly in the mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adjusting the liquid levels before cooking, which should be done before Step 7 where the cooking process begins.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 should occur before Step 7 to ensure the tarragon and bay leaf are properly submerged for optimal flavor release during the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing and adding ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before cooking them in Step 7, well before the aroma mentioned in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 is part of the initial setup of ingredients in the slow cooker, which must occur before the cooking process described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which should be done before cooking starts in Step 7, not after the cooking process as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the slow cooker, which is necessary before the cooking process in Step 7, whereas Step 8 refers to the reaction to the aroma after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adjusting the liquid levels in the slow cooker before cooking begins, while Step 8 refers to the end of the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves ensuring the tarragon and bay leaf are submerged, must occur before the cooking process in Step 7 to ensure they release flavor during cooking, not after the cooking process as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves cooking the stew in the slow cooker, which must be completed before the aroma described in Step 8 can fill the room.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves adding all ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before cooking and seasoning (Step 9) to ensure proper cooking and flavor integration.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which should occur before cooking (Step 7), while Step 9 involves seasoning after cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which occurs before the cooking process (Step 7) and seasoning (Step 9).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the slow cooker which is essential for cooking the stew, whereas Step 9 is seasoning the stew after it has cooked, indicating that Step 4 must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adjusting the liquid levels before cooking, while Step 9 is about seasoning the dish after it has been cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves ensuring the tarragon and bay leaf are submerged, should occur before the slow cooking process in Step 7 to allow flavors to infuse during cooking, not after seasoning adjustments in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves simmering the stew in the slow cooker, which must be completed before seasoning with salt and pepper in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 is a humorous remark about the aroma and does not affect the sequence of cooking or seasoning steps, which are completed independently.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing and adding ingredients to the slow cooker, which must occur before the cooking process in Step 7, whereas Step 10 involves cooking pasta to serve with the already prepared stew.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which is part of the initial preparation, whereas Step 10 involves cooking pasta to serve with the stew, which is done towards the end of the cooking process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which occurs before the cooking process, while Step 10 involves cooking pasta to serve with the stew, which is a final step.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the stew for cooking, which must occur before the stew simmers for 5 hours in Step 7, whereas Step 10 involves cooking pasta to serve with the already prepared stew.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adjusting the liquid levels in the slow cooker during the initial cooking process, while Step 10 is about cooking pasta to serve with the stew, which happens after the stew has been cooked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves ensuring the tarragon and bay leaf are submerged, must occur during the preparation of the stew in the slow cooker, well before Step 10, which involves cooking pasta to serve with the stew.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves simmering the stew in the slow cooker, which must be completed before Step 10, where the pasta is cooked to be served with the already prepared stew.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 is a humorous remark about the aroma during cooking, while Step 10 involves serving the dish; these steps are independent in terms of sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves seasoning the stew, which should be done before serving with pasta in Step 10 to ensure the stew is flavorful when combined with the pasta.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing and adding ingredients to the slow cooker, which logically precedes cooking and serving with pasta in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 is part of the initial preparation of the stew and must occur before cooking, while Step 11 is the final step of serving the dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the ingredients in the slow cooker, which occurs before cooking, while Step 11 is about serving the dish, which happens after the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding liquids to the stew for cooking, which must occur before the stew simmers and is served with pasta in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adjusting the liquid levels in the slow cooker during the initial cooking setup, which must occur before the stew cooks for 5 hours as described in Step 7, and long before serving with pasta in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves ensuring the tarragon and bay leaf are submerged, must occur during the preparation and cooking process, well before serving the dish with pasta in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves simmering the stew in the slow cooker, which must be completed before serving with pasta as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 is a humorous remark about the aroma during cooking, while Step 11 is the final step of serving the dish; they are not sequentially dependent.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves seasoning the stew with salt and pepper, which should be done before serving with pasta in Step 10, not after.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 43, "title": "spanish-rabbit-stew", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?", ").", "I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.", "Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.", "You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.", "Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.", "Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.", "If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!", "Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.", "Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.", "Most importantly, enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spanish-rabbit-stew\n\nProcedure:\n1. After slicing all of your ingredients, throw them all into your slow cooker (everything in at once, couldn\u2019t be easier right?\n2. ).\n3. I like to mix mine up, so I can take a big scoop and get a lovely mix of goodness.\n4. Pour in half pint of white wine and half pint of water.\n5. You might want to add a little more of each to cover your ingredients but the key rule is to keep the mixture 50/50.\n6. Make sure your tarragon and bay leaf aren\u2019t floating on the top or it won't let off any real flavour.\n7. Turn your slow cooker on to low power, let it simmer for about 5 hours.\n8. If your aren\u2019t hungry once that wonderful smell fills the room, I\u2019ll refund the cost of the ingredients!\n9. Flavour with salt and pepper to taste.\n10. Cook the pasta according to the packet instructions, and serve with pasta.\n11. Most importantly, enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11, which is to enjoy the meal, logically follows after serving the stew with pasta in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can be done independently and does not rely on the preparation of the baking dish in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the squash in the oven as described in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish with water before placing the squash in it, which can be done either before or after cutting the squash as described in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish with water before placing the squash in it, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the baking dish to prepare it for baking, which logically must occur before Step 4, where the squash is actually baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, which is prior to peeling the squash in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be done before baking the squash in Step 4, and is unrelated to the cooling and peeling of the squash in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before Step 5, where the peel is removed after the squash has cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash until soft, which must occur before the peel can be removed in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, and is unrelated to setting aside the peeled squash in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be done before baking the squash in Step 4, and therefore cannot occur after Step 6 where the squash is set aside after baking and peeling.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before Step 6 where the baked squash is set aside after peeling.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which must occur before it can be cooled and peeled in Step 5 and set aside in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves cooling and peeling the squash which logically precedes setting it aside in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before baking the squash in Step 4, and this must occur before Step 7 where the butter is melted for saut\u00e9ing.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must occur before it is cooked and mashed with other ingredients in steps following Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is cooked and mashed with other ingredients in Step 12, independent of melting butter and sauteing other ingredients in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which needs to be done before it can be added to the pot in Step 12, and is independent of melting butter in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves cooling and peeling the squash, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added to the pot and mashed, which is before Step 7 where butter is melted in the pot.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, does not depend on the melting of butter in Step 7 and can be performed independently.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before baking the squash in Step 4, and is unrelated to sauteing ingredients in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is cooked in the oven in Step 4, and is unrelated to sauteing the onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is added to the soup in Step 12, and is independent of saut\u00e9ing the onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which is necessary before it can be added to the soup in Step 12, independent of saut\u00e9ing the onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves cooling and peeling the squash, must occur before the squash is added in Step 12, and does not depend on the sauteing of onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the cooked squash, does not depend on the sauteing of onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8 and can be completed independently.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter in a pot which is necessary before sauteing the onion, leek, and garlic in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, which is necessary before adding the squash to the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is cooked and added to the soup in later steps, not after adding the chicken stock in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is cooked and mashed with the potatoes in Step 12, and thus does not depend on the addition of chicken stock in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves baking the squash until soft, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added to the pot and mashed with potatoes, which is before adding the chicken stock in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the baked squash, which must be done before adding the squash to the soup in Step 12, independent of adding chicken stock in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, does not depend on the addition of chicken stock in Step 9 and can be completed independently.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute onions, leek, and garlic, which must be done before adding the chicken stock in Step 9 to combine all ingredients properly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves saut\u00e9ing onions, leek, and garlic, which must be done before adding the chicken stock in Step 9 to develop the flavors.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, well before adding ingredients to the pot in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be baked before it is added to the soup in Step 12, thus it does not depend on the completion of Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must be done before it is added to the soup in Step 12, and is unrelated to adding potatoes in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which needs to be done before it can be added to the soup in Step 12, independent of the potato cooking in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled, which is independent of cooking the potatoes in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, does not depend on the completion of Step 10, as the squash is used later in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute onions, leek, and garlic, which can be done independently and prior to adding the chicken stock and potatoes in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves saut\u00e9ing onions, leek, and garlic, which must be done before adding the chicken stock in Step 9 and the potatoes in Step 10, as these ingredients form the base flavor of the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring chicken stock into the pot, which can be done before or after adding the potatoes in Step 10, as both steps are part of preparing the base for the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary before baking the squash in Step 4, well before cooking the potatoes in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking and must occur before baking in Step 4, which is well before cooking the potatoes in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must occur before it is cooked and mashed with potatoes in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves baking the squash until soft, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added to the pot and mashed with potatoes, which follows after Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled slightly, which is independent of cooking the potatoes in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, does not depend on the completion of Step 11, which involves cooking potatoes; these steps occur independently in the recipe.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter and saut\u00e9ing onions, leeks, and garlic, which can be done independently and prior to the boiling and cooking of potatoes in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves sauteing onions, leek, and garlic, which can be done independently of cooking the potatoes in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding chicken stock to the pot which is necessary before boiling the potatoes in Step 10 and 11, thus it does not need to occur after Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding potatoes and bringing the mixture to a boil, which must occur before Step 11 where the potatoes are cooked until soft.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, which involves preheating the oven, must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, and therefore must happen before Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be baked before it can be added to the soup in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before it can be added to the soup in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves baking the squash until it is soft, must occur before Step 12 where the cooked squash is mashed with potatoes, as the squash needs to be soft to be properly mashed and integrated into the soup.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled, which must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added to the pot and mashed with potatoes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added to the pot and mashed with potatoes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter and sauteing onions, leeks, and garlic, which must be done before adding the squash and other ingredients in later steps, including Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves sauteing onions, leek, and garlic, which must be done before adding the squash in Step 12 for flavor development.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding chicken stock to the pot which is necessary before adding and cooking the potatoes in Step 10, which precedes the addition of squash in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooking the potatoes in chicken stock until soft, which needs to occur before Step 12 where the cooked squash is added and mashed with the already softened potatoes.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which is necessary before they can be mashed with the squash in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, well before pureeing the soup in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking, which must occur before it is cooked and pureed in later steps, including Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before it can be mashed and pureed in steps 12 and 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves baking the squash until soft, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added and mashed with potatoes, which is prior to Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled slightly, which must occur before mashing and pureeing with the potatoes in Step 12 and Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before Step 12 where the squash is added and mashed with the potatoes, which is prior to Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter and saut\u00e9ing vegetables which is necessary before adding the squash and other ingredients to the pot, which must occur before blending in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves saut\u00e9ing onions, leek, and garlic which must occur before adding the squash and other ingredients for blending in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding chicken stock to the pot, which is necessary before step 13 where the soup is pureed; the liquid from the stock is needed to blend the ingredients smoothly.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooking the potatoes, which need to be soft before they can be mashed with the squash in Step 12 and pureed in Step 13, thus it must occur before Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which needs to be completed before they are mashed with the squash in Step 12, which precedes the pureeing in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mashing the squash with the potatoes, which can be done before or after pureeing in Step 13, as both steps aim to break down the soup's solid components into a smoother consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, well before the soup is seasoned and blended in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for roasting the squash, which must occur before baking in Step 4, long before the soup is seasoned and heated in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before it can be added to the soup in Step 12, well before pureeing and seasoning in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which is necessary before it can be mashed and pureed with potatoes in steps 12 and 13, which occur before step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled, which must occur before it is added to the soup in Step 12, well before pureeing in Step 13 and seasoning in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before it is added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, not after the soup is pureed in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute onions, leeks, and garlic, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and pureeing the soup, thus it must occur before Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves sauteing onions, leek, and garlic which is essential for flavor development before adding other ingredients and blending, which occurs in steps 9-14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring chicken stock into the pot, which is necessary before blending the ingredients in Step 13, and does not depend on the actions of Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding and cooking potatoes in the stock, which must occur before blending the soup in Step 13; Step 14 is simply returning the pureed soup to the pot.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which needs to occur before Step 12 where the squash is added and mashed with the potatoes, and this sequence precedes the pureeing of the soup in Step 13 and returning it to the pot in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mashing the squash with the potatoes, which must occur before pureeing the mixture in Step 13 and returning it to the pot in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves pureeing the soup to smoothness before it is returned to the pot in Step 14, so it must occur before Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, well before seasoning and final heating in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be baked early in the process to be ready for later steps, and is unrelated to the final seasoning and heating steps in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which must occur before it can be added to the soup in Step 12, well before seasoning and final adjustments in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which must be done before it can be added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, well before seasoning and final heating in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled slightly, which is necessary before the squash can be added and mashed with the potatoes in Step 12, well before seasoning and final adjustments in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before it is added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, not after the seasoning and heating in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute onions, leek, and garlic, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and seasonings in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves saut\u00e9ing the base vegetables which is essential before adding liquids and other ingredients for proper flavor development, whereas Step 15 is for final seasoning and should be done after the soup is blended.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves adding chicken stock which is essential for cooking the potatoes and squash, while Step 15 involves seasoning and final adjustments, which are done after the main ingredients are cooked and pureed.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves cooking the potatoes, which need to be soft before they can be mashed with the squash in Step 12, prior to seasoning and final heating in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which needs to occur before they are mashed with the squash in Step 12 and pureed in Step 13, all of which precede the seasoning and additional ingredients added in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mashing the squash with the potatoes, which is necessary before pureeing the mixture in Step 13, and this must occur before seasoning and final heating in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves pureeing the soup to achieve a smooth texture, which should be done before adding seasonings and other ingredients in Step 15 to ensure even distribution and integration of flavors.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14, which involves returning the pureed soup to the pot, must occur before Step 15, where seasonings and other ingredients are added to the soup for final flavoring.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 105, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, long before the final heating of the soup in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 106, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the squash for baking, which is essential before it is cooked and used in the soup, making it necessary to occur long before Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 107, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves placing the squash in the oven to bake, which is essential for softening the squash before it is added to the soup in Step 12, well before the final heating in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 108, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves baking the squash which is essential before it can be added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, long before the final heating in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 109, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves removing the peel from the squash after it has been baked and cooled slightly, which is necessary before the squash can be added to the soup in Step 12, well before seasoning and final heating in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 110, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before it is added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, and long before the final heating in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 111, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute onions, leeks, and garlic, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and must occur before Step 16 where the soup is heated through after all ingredients are combined and seasoned.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 112, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves saut\u00e9ing onions, leek, and garlic which is essential for building the flavor base of the soup and must occur before adding other ingredients like squash and stock, which happens well before Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 113, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring chicken stock into the pot which is essential for cooking the potatoes and squash, whereas Step 16 is about reheating the soup after all ingredients including seasonings and dairy are added.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 114, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding potatoes and boiling them until soft, which is essential for the texture of the soup and must occur before pureeing the ingredients together in Step 13, not after heating the soup in Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 115, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which is necessary before they are mashed with the squash in Step 12 and pureed in Step 13, all of which occur before the final heating in Step 16.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 116, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mashing and combining the squash with the potatoes, which is essential before pureeing and seasoning the soup in subsequent steps, including Step 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 117, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves pureeing the soup to achieve a smooth texture, which must be done before seasoning and final heating in steps 15 and 16.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 118, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves returning the pureed soup to the pot, which must occur before Step 16 where the soup is heated through after seasoning.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 119, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 16?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 16?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves seasoning and adding final ingredients to the soup, which should be done before heating through in Step 16 to ensure flavors meld properly.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 120, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the squash in Step 4, well before the final step of serving the soup in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 121, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the baking dish for the squash, which must be done before baking the squash in Step 4, and long before the final steps of seasoning and serving the soup.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 122, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the squash for baking, which is essential before it can be used in the soup, thus it must occur long before Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 123, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves baking the squash until it is soft, must occur before it can be peeled, mashed, and added to the soup, all of which are steps that precede Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 124, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves cooling and peeling the squash, must occur before the squash can be added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, and thus cannot happen after Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 125, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves setting aside the peeled squash, must occur before it is added and mashed with potatoes in Step 12, and thus cannot happen after Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 126, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves melting butter to saute vegetables, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup before adding other ingredients and must occur before the final heating and serving steps.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 127, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves sauteing onions, leek, and garlic, which is essential for preparing the base of the soup before other ingredients are added and before the final steps of seasoning and serving as described in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 128, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring chicken stock into the pot, which is essential for cooking the potatoes and squash, and must occur before the soup is seasoned and served in Step 17.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 129, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves adding potatoes and boiling them, which is essential for the soup's base and must occur before blending and seasoning in subsequent steps, well before serving in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 130, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves cooking the potatoes until soft, which is necessary before pureeing with the squash in Step 13, and must occur before the final heating and serving in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 131, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves mashing and combining the squash with potatoes, which is essential before pureeing and seasoning the soup in subsequent steps, all of which must occur before serving the soup in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 132, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves pureeing the soup to achieve the desired texture before seasoning and serving, which must be completed before Step 17 where the soup is served.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 133, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 involves returning the pureed soup to the pot for further seasoning and heating, which must occur before serving the soup in Step 17.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 134, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 15 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 15 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 15 involves seasoning and adding final ingredients to the soup, which must be done before serving (Step 17) to ensure the flavors are well incorporated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 44, "title": "spiced butternut squash soup", "question_idx": 135, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.", "Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.", "Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.", "Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.", "Cool slightly, then remove the peel.", "Set aside.", "Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.", "Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.", "Pour the chicken stock into the pot.", "Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.", "Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.", "Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.", "Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.", "Return to the pot.", "Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.", "Heat through, but do not boil.", "Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "why_question": "Why must Step 16 happen after Step 17?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced butternut squash soup\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 190 C / Gas mark 6.\n2. Pour a small layer of water in a baking dish, or a swiss roll tin.\n3. Place the squash halves cut side down on the dish.\n4. Bake for about 40 minutes, or until a fork can easily pierce the flesh.\n5. Cool slightly, then remove the peel.\n6. Set aside.\n7. Melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat.\n8. Add the onion, leek and garlic, and saute for a few minutes, until tender.\n9. Pour the chicken stock into the pot.\n10. Add the potatoes, and bring to the boil.\n11. Cook for about 20 minutes, or until soft.\n12. Add the squash, and mash with the potatoes until chunks are small.\n13. Use an immersion hand blender to puree the soup, or transfer to a blender or food processor in batches, and puree until smooth.\n14. Return to the pot.\n15. Season the soup with cayenne pepper, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, salt and pepper, then stir in the sherry, cream and milk.\n16. Heat through, but do not boil.\n17. Ladle into bowls, and top with a dollop of soured cream if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 16 happen after Step 17?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 16, which involves heating the soup through without boiling, must occur before serving (Step 17) to ensure the soup is hot when served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with greasing and flouring the tin as described in Step 2.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can occur simultaneously with other steps such as mixing ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the tin, which can be done independently of sieving the dry ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking when the batter is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which is necessary before adding the batter in Step 8, and is independent of mixing the guava pulp and juice in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving dry ingredients which can be done independently and does not rely on the mixing of guava pulp and juice in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking when the batter is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which needs to be done before adding the batter in Step 8, and is independent of creaming butter and sugar in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving dry ingredients which can be prepared independently before creaming butter and sugar in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 and Step 5 involve preparing separate components of the batter and can be done independently of each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking when the batter is prepared.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which needs to be done before adding the batter in Step 8, and is independent of adding eggs in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving dry ingredients, which can be prepared before creaming butter and sugar and adding eggs in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the guava mixture and can be done independently before creaming the butter and sugar in Step 5 and adding eggs in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves creaming together butter and sugar, which needs to be done before adding eggs one at a time in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature when the batter is ready to be baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which must be done before adding the batter in Step 8, not necessarily after mixing the ingredients in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving the dry ingredients which must be done before they are added to the creamed mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the guava mixture which needs to be ready before it can be alternately added with the flour mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves creaming together butter and sugar, must occur before Step 7 where the creamed mixture is combined with other ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 must occur before Step 7 because the eggs need to be added to the creamed butter and sugar mixture before alternating with the flour and guava mixtures.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before pouring the batter into the tin (Step 8) to ensure the oven is at the correct temperature for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 8 because the tin needs to be prepared before the batter can be poured into it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving the dry ingredients which must be done before they are added to the wet ingredients in Step 7, prior to pouring the batter into the tin in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing guava pulp and juice, which needs to be done before Step 7 where it is added to the creamed mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves creaming together butter and sugar, must occur before Step 8 because the creamed mixture is needed to combine with other ingredients to form the batter that is poured into the tin in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 must occur before Step 8 because the eggs need to be added to the creamed mixture before the batter is poured into the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves combining the ingredients to form the batter, which must occur before Step 8 where the batter is poured into the tin for baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 9 because the oven needs to be preheated before the cake batter is baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 9 because the tin needs to be prepared before the batter can be poured into it and baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sieving the dry ingredients which is necessary before they are added to the wet ingredients in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing guava pulp and juice, which is required before Step 7 where it is added to the creamed mixture, well before baking in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 must occur before Step 9 because the creamed butter and sugar mixture is needed to combine with other ingredients to form the batter before baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 must occur before Step 9 because the eggs need to be added to the creamed mixture before the batter is poured into the tin and baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves combining the ingredients to form the batter, which must occur before Step 9 where the batter is baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 45, "title": "spiced-guava-cake", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.", "Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.", "Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.", "In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.", "In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.", "Add eggs, one at a time.", "Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.", "Pour batter into prepared tin.", "Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-guava-cake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 180 C / Gas 4.\n2. Grease and flour one 23x13cm loaf tin.\n3. Sieve together flour, cornflour, nutmeg, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon and cloves.\n4. In another bowl, mix together guava pulp and juice.\n5. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.\n6. Add eggs, one at a time.\n7. Add flour mixture and guava mixture alternately to creamed mixture.\n8. Pour batter into prepared tin.\n9. Bake at 180 C / Gas 4 for 30-35 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves pouring the batter into the tin, which must occur before baking the cake in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can be done independently and concurrently with lining the loaf tin in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before cooking the pumpkin in Step 3 to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparing the mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin before adding any ingredients, which can be done independently and prior to cooking the pumpkin in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before baking in Step 11, and does not depend on the completion of Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin before adding any ingredients, while Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin, which is unrelated to the preparation of the tin.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin until tender, which is necessary before it can be mashed in Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which needs to be ready before adding the mixture in Step 9, and is not dependent on the addition of honey and sultanas in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which needs to be mashed and mixed with honey and sultanas in Step 5, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which needs to be done before adding honey and sultanas in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which is necessary before adding the mixture in Step 9, and is independent of sifting flours and allspice in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which needs to be mashed and added to the flour mixture in Step 8, independent of the flour sifting in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which needs to be done before adding it to the flour mixture in Step 8, which follows the sifting of flours in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which can be done independently of sifting the flours and allspice in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which needs to be done before mixing ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin, which needs to be ready before adding the mixture in Step 9, and does not depend on the mixing process completed in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which needs to be mashed and added to the flour mixture in Step 8, while Step 7 involves preparing the flour mixture to which the pumpkin is added.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which needs to be done before adding it to the flour mixture in Step 8, which follows the rubbing in of butter in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which can be done independently of rubbing butter into the flour mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which can be done independently before rubbing in the butter in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before mixing ingredients (Step 8) to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after preparation.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin, which must be done before adding the mixture in Step 9, not necessarily after mixing the ingredients in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and mashing the pumpkin, which needs to be done before it can be added to the flour mixture in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 8 because the pumpkin needs to be mashed and prepared before it can be added to the flour mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is necessary before mixing it with the flour mixture in Step 8.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which must be done before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create a breadcrumb-like texture, which should be done before adding the wet pumpkin mixture in Step 8 to ensure proper mixing and texture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before adding the mixture to the tin in Step 9 to ensure the oven is ready for baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin with parchment, which must be done before adding the mixture in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking and mashing the pumpkin, which must be done before it is added to the flour mixture in Step 8, prior to being placed in the tin in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin, which needs to be done before adding it to the flour mixture in Step 8, prior to placing in the tin in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which must be done before Step 8 where this pumpkin mixture is added to the flour mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which is necessary before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8, thus it must occur before Step 9 where the mixture is placed in the tin.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create breadcrumbs, which must be done before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8, which precedes placing the mixture into the tin in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the ingredients to create the batter, which must be done before Step 9 where the batter is placed into the baking tin.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11, thus it should happen before Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin, which must be done before adding the mixture in Step 9, well before sprinkling pumpkin seeds in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which is essential before mixing it with other ingredients in Step 8, well before sprinkling pumpkin seeds in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin, which is necessary before combining it with other ingredients in Step 8, well before sprinkling pumpkin seeds in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is essential before mixing with the dry ingredients in Step 8, well before sprinkling pumpkin seeds in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which is necessary before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8, well before sprinkling pumpkin seeds in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create a breadcrumb-like texture, which is essential before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8 and prior to placing it in the tin in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the pumpkin mixture into the dry ingredients, which must occur before Step 10 where the mixture is already in the tin and being topped with pumpkin seeds.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves placing the mixture into the tin and smoothing the surface, which must occur before sprinkling pumpkin seeds on top in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin with parchment, which must be done before adding the mixture in Step 9, well before baking in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which is necessary before it can be mashed, mixed with other ingredients, and baked in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin, which is necessary before mixing it with other ingredients in Step 8, well before baking in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is necessary before baking the mixture in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which is necessary before mixing with the pumpkin to form the batter in Step 8, well before baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create a breadcrumb-like texture, which is necessary before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8 and baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the pumpkin mixture into the dry ingredients, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves placing the mixture into the tin which must occur before baking in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves sprinkling pumpkin seeds on the mixture before baking, which must be done before Step 11 where the loaf is actually baked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11, not after cooling the loaf in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin with baking parchment, which is necessary before adding the mixture in Step 9, well before the loaf is cooled in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which is essential to prepare the pumpkin mixture used in Step 8, long before the cooling process in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which is necessary before combining it with other ingredients in Step 8, well before the loaf is baked and cooled as described in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is necessary before baking the loaf in Step 11, and cannot be done after the loaf has been baked and cooled as described in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice for the bread mixture, which must be done before combining with other ingredients and baking, hence well before cooling the loaf as described in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing butter into the flour mixture to create a breadcrumb-like texture, which is essential before adding the pumpkin mixture and baking, and must occur before Step 12, which involves cooling the baked loaf.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves adding the pumpkin mixture to the flour mixture and beating it, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11, and thus well before cooling the loaf in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves placing the mixture into the tin to bake, which must occur before baking and cooling as described in Step 11 and Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves sprinkling pumpkin seeds on the mixture before it is baked, which must occur before the baking and cooling steps outlined in Steps 11 and 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves baking the loaf until it is well risen and golden brown, which must occur before Step 12 where the loaf is allowed to cool in the tin.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the loaf in Step 11, and thus long before brushing with honey in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves lining the loaf tin, which is necessary before adding the mixture in Step 9, long before the cooling and brushing with honey in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which is essential for preparing the mixture used in the earlier stages of the recipe, well before the final touches like brushing with honey in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which is essential before mixing it with other ingredients in Step 8, whereas Step 13 involves brushing the baked loaf with honey, which occurs after the baking process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is essential for the batter preparation before baking, whereas Step 13 involves brushing the baked loaf with honey, which is a finishing touch.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and adding allspice, which is necessary before combining with the pumpkin mixture in Step 8, well before the final brushing with honey in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing in the butter to make the breadcrumb-like mixture, which is essential before adding the pumpkin mixture in Step 8 and baking in Step 11, all of which occur before the loaf is brushed with honey in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the ingredients to form the teabread batter, which must be done before baking in Step 11, whereas Step 13 is a finishing touch applied after baking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves placing the mixture into the baking tin to cook, which must occur before baking and cooling, which are prerequisites for the brushing with honey in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves sprinkling pumpkin seeds on the mixture before baking, which must occur before Step 13 where the loaf is brushed with honey after baking.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves baking the loaf, which must occur before it can be cooled and brushed with honey in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves cooling the loaf and removing it from the tin, which can be done before or independently of brushing it with honey in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the teabread in Step 11, not after completing the entire process.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the loaf tin before baking, which must occur before the baking in Step 11 and long before the final steps including Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooking the pumpkin which is essential to prepare the mixture for baking, and must occur before the baking in Step 11, not after the teabread is completed in Step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mashing the cooked pumpkin which is essential before mixing with other ingredients and baking, while Step 14 is about serving the bread; these steps are unrelated in sequence but necessary at different stages of the recipe.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey and sultanas to the mashed pumpkin, which is essential for preparing the batter before baking, whereas Step 14 is about serving the teabread after it has been baked and cooled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves sifting flours and allspice which is essential for preparing the batter before baking, and must occur before the baking step (Step 11), not after the teabread is completed and served (Step 14).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves rubbing in the butter to make the breadcrumb-like mixture, which is essential before baking in Step 11, whereas Step 14 is about serving the teabread after it has been baked and cooled.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the ingredients to form the teabread batter, which must occur before baking and cooling as described in steps 11 and 12, well before step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves placing the mixture into the tin to bake, which must occur before baking and cooling as described in steps 11 and 12, all of which precede step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves sprinkling pumpkin seeds on the mixture before baking, which must occur before Step 14 where the teabread is already baked and being served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves baking the loaf, which must occur before it can be cooled, turned out, and brushed with honey as described in steps 12 and 13, which precede step 14.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves cooling and removing the loaf from the tin, which must occur before Step 14 where the loaf is brushed with honey while still warm.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 46, "title": "spiced-pumpkin-teabread", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).", "Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.", "Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.", "Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.", "Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.", "Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.", "Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.", "Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.", "Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.", "Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.", "Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.", "Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.", "Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.", "This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spiced-pumpkin-teabread\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 180\u5c0aC (350\u5c0aF, gas mark 4).\n2. Line a 900 g (2 lb) loaf tin with baking parchment.\n3. Steam the pumpkin flesh, or cook it in just a little boiling water, for 10 minutes or until tender.\n4. Drain thoroughly, then mash with a potato masher until smooth.\n5. Add the honey and sultanas, and beat well.\n6. Sift the wholemeal and white flours and the allspice into a bowl, tipping in any bran left in the sieve.\n7. Rub in the butter with your fingertips until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.\n8. Add the pumpkin mixture and beat well with a wooden spoon until evenly mixed.\n9. Tip the mixture into the prepared tin and smooth the surface.\n10. Sprinkle with the pumpkin seeds.\n11. Bake for 50 minutes or until the loaf is well risen, golden brown and firm to the touch.\n12. Allow the loaf to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a wire rack.\n13. Gently brush with the 2 tsp honey while still warm.\n14. This teabread is best served slightly warm, or within a day of making.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves brushing the teabread with honey while it is still warm, which should occur before it cools down completely, whereas Step 14 suggests when the teabread is best served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding ingredients to the pan, which must occur before Step 2, where these ingredients are cooked until lightly browned.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms, which must occur before adding anchovies and water in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms until lightly browned, which is necessary before adding the anchovies and water in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding initial ingredients, which must occur before adding other ingredients in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms until lightly browned, which is necessary before adding other ingredients in Step 3 and 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering anchovies and water, which is necessary before adding other vegetables in Step 4 to ensure proper integration and flavor development.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the anchovy mixture, which must be ready to toss with the pasta cooked in Step 6; therefore, it does not depend on the boiling of water in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms in the pan, which is independent of boiling the pasta in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the anchovies and water, which can occur independently of boiling the pasta in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering the vegetables in the anchovy mixture, which can occur simultaneously with Step 5 where the pasta is being cooked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the anchovy mixture, which needs to be ready to toss with the pasta cooked in Step 6; therefore, Step 1 does not need to happen after Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms, which is independent of cooking the linguine in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the anchovies and water, which can be done simultaneously as the pasta cooks in Step 6.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering vegetables while Step 6 involves cooking pasta; both steps can occur simultaneously as they use different pots and do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves bringing water to a boil for the pasta, which can be done simultaneously with the earlier steps of cooking the anchovy mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the anchovy mixture which needs to be ready to toss with the pasta cooked in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms, which is part of preparing the anchovy mixture, and must be completed before the pasta (cooked in steps 5-7) is tossed with this mixture in step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering the anchovies and water, which is part of preparing the sauce that will be mixed with the pasta cooked in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering the vegetables and needs to occur before Step 7 where the pasta is drained and ready to be tossed with the anchovy mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling water for the pasta, which needs to be ready to cook the linguine before it can be drained in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the linguine until al dente, which must be completed before Step 7, where the pasta is drained.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the base of the anchovy mixture, which must be done before it can be tossed with the pasta in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms until lightly browned, which is necessary before adding other ingredients in subsequent steps, and is unrelated to tossing the pasta with the anchovy mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering anchovies with vegetables, which must occur before Step 8 where the cooked pasta is tossed with the anchovy mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering the vegetables which is necessary before combining them with the pasta in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling the pasta, which needs to be cooked and ready to toss with the anchovy mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the linguine, which needs to be done before it can be tossed with the anchovy mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves draining the cooked linguine, must occur before Step 8 where the pasta is tossed with the anchovy mixture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves heating oil and adding initial ingredients, which is essential to start the cooking process and must occur before combining with the pasta in later steps.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms, which is necessary before adding other ingredients and must occur early in the process, whereas Step 9 is a final seasoning step after the dish is assembled.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering anchovies and water, which is essential for preparing the anchovy mixture before it is tossed with the pasta in Step 8, and thus must occur before Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering vegetables which is essential before mixing with the pasta in Step 8, whereas Step 9 is seasoning which can be done after the pasta is served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling the pasta, which needs to be cooked and ready before it can be tossed with the anchovy mixture in Step 8, which precedes seasoning and serving in Steps 9 and 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the pasta which needs to be done before it can be tossed with the anchovy mixture in Step 8, which precedes seasoning with black pepper in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves draining the cooked linguine, must occur before Step 8 where the pasta is tossed with the anchovy mixture, and this sequence precedes Step 9 where optional seasoning with black pepper is done.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves tossing the pasta with the anchovy mixture and chili flakes, which is essential before seasoning with black pepper in Step 9, but these steps can be interchanged without affecting the final dish.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the anchovy mixture which must be done before it can be tossed with the pasta in Step 8 and served in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the garlic, broccoli, and mushrooms, which must occur before they are combined with other ingredients and the pasta, as outlined in later steps.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves simmering anchovies and water, which is essential to prepare the anchovy mixture before it is tossed with the pasta in Step 8, well before serving in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves simmering vegetables and must occur before Step 8 where the pasta is tossed with the anchovy mixture, which includes the cooked vegetables from Step 4.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling the pasta, which must be cooked and drained before it can be tossed with the anchovy mixture in Step 8, prior to serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves cooking the pasta which must be done before it can be tossed with the anchovy mixture in Step 8 and served in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves draining the cooked linguine, must occur before Step 8 where the pasta is tossed with the anchovy mixture, and this happens before serving in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 must occur before Step 10 because the pasta needs to be tossed with the anchovy mixture before it can be served.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 47, "title": "spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;", "cook until lightly browned.", "Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.", "Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.", "While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.", "Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;", "drain.", "Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.", "If desired, season with black pepper.", "Serve immediately."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: spicy-tomato-anchovy-pasta\n\nProcedure:\n1. Heat 6 tablespoons olive oil in a large frying pan over medium heat, then stir in garlic, broccoli and mushrooms;\n2. cook until lightly browned.\n3. Add anchovies and water, cover and simmer for 4 to 5 minutes.\n4. Stir in spring onions, tomatoes and parsley and cover again, simmering until vegetables are soft, about 3 to 4 minutes.\n5. While the vegetables are cooking, bring a large pot of water and one teaspoon of olive oil to the boil.\n6. Add linguine and cook until al dente, about 7 to 8 minutes;\n7. drain.\n8. Toss with anchovy mixture and chilli flakes.\n9. If desired, season with black pepper.\n10. Serve immediately.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves seasoning which can be done before serving (Step 10), as it adjusts the final flavor to taste.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 2 because the strawberries need to be in the bowl before they can be sprinkled with sugar.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the strawberries in a bowl, which is necessary before they can be coated with sugar and allowed to stand, as described in Steps 2 and 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sprinkling sugar on the strawberries to coat them, which must occur before Step 3 where the strawberries are left to stand and stirred occasionally.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the strawberries in a bowl, which is necessary before adding Pimm's in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sprinkling sugar on the strawberries to coat them before adding Pimm's in Step 4, which is essential for the sugar to dissolve and macerate the fruit.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves letting the sugared strawberries stand before adding Pimm's in Step 4, so it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the strawberries in a bowl, which is necessary before adding sugar, Pimm's, or any other ingredients, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sprinkling sugar on the strawberries to coat them before adding Pimm's in Step 4, which is necessary before letting them stand for additional time in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur before Step 4 and Step 5, as it involves allowing the strawberries to macerate with sugar before adding the Pimm's.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves adding Pimm's before letting the mixture stand for another 30 minutes as described in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves placing the strawberries in a bowl, which is necessary to begin the preparation before any other steps, including garnishing with mint leaves in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves sprinkling sugar on the strawberries to coat them, which is necessary before adding Pimm's in Step 4 and before the garnishing in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves letting the strawberries and sugar mixture stand, which is necessary before adding Pimm's in Step 4 and further standing in Step 5; Step 6 is a final garnishing step.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 must occur before Step 6 as the Pimm's needs to be added to the strawberries before the final garnishing with mint leaves.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 48, "title": "strawberries-in-pimm-s", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Place the strawberries in a large bowl.", "Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.", "Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.", "Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.", "Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.", "Garnish with mint leaves, if desired."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberries-in-pimm-s\n\nProcedure:\n1. Place the strawberries in a large bowl.\n2. Sprinkle the sugar evenly over the strawberries, and stir to evenly coat all of the fruit.\n3. Let stand at room temperature for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.\n4. Add the Pimm's, and stir once more.\n5. Let stand for another 30 minutes at room temperature.\n6. Garnish with mint leaves, if desired.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves letting the strawberries stand with Pimm's for 30 minutes, which must occur before garnishing with mint leaves in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing strawberries for garnish and does not depend on the cream cheese mixture prepared in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing strawberries for garnish and does not depend on the mixing of ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves beating the cream cheese and adding coffee, which needs to be done before Step 3 where this mixture is combined with custard and whipped cream.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing strawberries for the layers and garnish, which is independent of soaking the sponge fingers in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture, which is independent of soaking the sponge fingers with coffee in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture which is needed before applying it in Step 7, while Step 4 involves preparing the sponge fingers which are used in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves setting aside and slicing strawberries for use in later steps, which does not depend on the placement of sponge fingers in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture which is needed in Step 7, and does not depend on the placement of sponge fingers done in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture which needs to be ready before layering in Step 7, thus it does not have to follow Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which needs to be done before they are layered in the bowl in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves setting aside and slicing strawberries for use in later steps, including Step 6, so it must occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture, which needs to be ready before layering it in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture before it is layered onto the sponge fingers and strawberries in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which needs to be done before they are layered in the bowl in Step 5, and thus before adding strawberries in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves lining the bowl with sponge fingers, which must occur before adding strawberries in Step 6 to create the layered structure of the trifle.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves setting aside strawberries for garnish and slicing the rest, which needs to be done before they are used in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture which is needed in Step 7 to complete the first layer of the trifle.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture which is used in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which must be done before they are layered in the bowl in Step 5, and thus before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves lining the bowl with sponge fingers, which must occur before adding strawberries and custard mixture in Steps 6 and 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spreading strawberries over the sponge fingers, which should occur before sprinkling chocolate and adding custard mixture as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves setting aside strawberries for garnish and slicing the rest, which needs to be done before they are used in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the custard mixture which is needed in Step 7, before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture which is used in Step 7 and again in Step 8, thus it must occur before these steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which must occur before they are layered in the trifle in Steps 5 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves lining the bowl with the first layer of sponge fingers, which must occur before Step 8, where the layers are repeated, including adding another layer of sponge fingers.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spreading half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers, and Step 8 is a repetition of the layers including another layer of strawberries, so Step 6 does not need to happen after Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 must occur before Step 8 as it involves layering the first set of ingredients which is necessary before repeating the layers in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 9 as it involves setting aside strawberries for garnish which are used in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture which is needed in Step 7, long before the garnishing step in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the custard mixture which is needed in Step 7, well before the garnishing step in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which must occur before they are layered in the trifle (Step 5), whereas Step 9 involves garnishing the completed trifle, which is a final step.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves lining the bowl with sponge fingers, which is necessary to form the base layers of the trifle before adding toppings and custard layers, whereas Step 9 is about garnishing the completed trifle.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spreading strawberries over the sponge fingers, which is part of the layering process that must be completed before garnishing with strawberries in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves layering ingredients inside the trifle, which must be completed before the garnishing step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves repeating the layering of ingredients inside the trifle, which must be completed before garnishing with strawberries in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves setting aside strawberries for garnish and must occur before they are used in Step 9, not after the trifle has been refrigerated in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the cream cheese mixture which is needed in Step 7, before the trifle is refrigerated in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing ingredients to create the custard mixture, which is needed in Steps 7 and 8, before the trifle is refrigerated in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves brushing the sponge fingers with coffee, which must be done before they are layered in the trifle in Step 5, well before the trifle is refrigerated in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves lining the bowl with sponge fingers, which is part of the layering process that must be completed before refrigerating the trifle as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves spreading strawberries over the sponge fingers, which is part of the layering process that must be completed before refrigerating the trifle as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves layering ingredients inside the trifle, which must be completed before chilling the trifle as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves repeating the layering of the trifle components, which must be completed before chilling the trifle in the fridge as described in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 49, "title": "strawberry-tiramisu-trifle", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.", "In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.", "Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.", "Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.", "Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.", "Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.", "Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.", "Repeat the layers in order again.", "Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.", "Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: strawberry-tiramisu-trifle\n\nProcedure:\n1. Set 3 strawberries for the garnish aside, and cut the rest into slices.\n2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese with a hand whisk until creamy, gradually adding 2 tablespoons of the coffee.\n3. Then stir in the custard and finally fold in the whipped cream.\n4. Brush the sponge fingers with the remaining coffee.\n5. Line a glass bowl with one layer of the soaked sponge fingers.\n6. Spread half of the strawberries over the sponge fingers.\n7. Sprinkle half of the grated chocolate over that and then half of the custard mixture.\n8. Repeat the layers in order again.\n9. Cut the remaining 3 strawberries in half and lay them on top of the trifle.\n10. Cover and leave in the fridge for at least 4 hours, best overnight.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves garnishing the trifle with strawberries, which should be done before Step 10 where the trifle is refrigerated to set.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which can be done simultaneously or before preparing the ingredients in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which is independent of and can occur before preparing the ingredients in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing tomatoes while Step 3 involves preparing onions, and these tasks can be performed independently of each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before preparing the ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for cooking when needed.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the tomatoes by loosening their skins with boiling water, which must occur before Step 4 where the skins are removed and the tomatoes are chopped.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves draining and chopping onions, which is independent of the tomato preparation described in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before preparing the ingredients to ensure the oven is ready for cooking when needed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the tomatoes which are then used in Step 5, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the onions, which are then used in Step 5, indicating that Step 3 must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the tomatoes which are then used in Step 5, so it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which should be done before preparing the ingredients in steps 2-7 to ensure the oven is ready for cooking.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing the tomatoes which are needed in Step 5, before the gammon steaks are assembled in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the onions which are then used in Step 5, before the gammon steaks are prepared and assembled in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the tomatoes which are needed in Step 5 to mix with onions and apples before being used in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves placing the onions, tomatoes, and apples into the casserole dish, which needs to be done before wrapping the gammon steaks with the mixture in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before placing the gammon steaks in the oven to cook, as indicated in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing tomatoes, which are needed in Step 5 before the gammon steaks are prepared and placed in the dish in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the onions which are then used in Step 5, before the gammon steaks are prepared and placed in the dish in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the tomatoes which are needed in Step 5 to mix with onions and apples before stuffing the gammon steaks in Step 6, thus it must occur before Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves placing onions, tomatoes, and apples into the casserole dish, which is necessary before wrapping the gammon steaks with the mixture in Step 6 and placing them in the dish in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing each gammon steak individually by stuffing and securing it, which must be completed before repeating the process with other steaks in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the gammon steaks in the oven to cook as described in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing tomatoes which are needed in Step 5, well before the cider is poured over the gammon steaks in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the onions which are needed in Step 5, before the gammon steaks are prepared and cooked in Steps 6 to 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the tomatoes which are then used in Step 6 to fill the gammon steaks before they are cooked in Step 9, thus it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves placing the onions, tomatoes, and apples into the casserole dish before the gammon steaks are added and cider is poured in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing the gammon steaks by stuffing and wrapping them, which must be done before Step 8 where the cider is poured over the prepared steaks in the dish.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing each prepared gammon steak into the dish, which must be done before Step 8 where cider is poured over the steaks.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before cooking the gammon in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves preparing tomatoes, which is necessary before assembling the gammon steaks in Step 6, well before the cooking process in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the onions which are needed in Step 5, well before the cooking process in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the tomatoes which are needed in Step 5 to be mixed with onions and apples before the gammon steaks are assembled and cooked in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves placing the onions, tomatoes, and apples into the casserole dish, which must occur before the gammon steaks are added and cooked in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves preparing and assembling the gammon steaks before they are cooked, which must be completed before Step 9, where the dish is actually cooked in the oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves placing the prepared gammon steaks in the dish, which must occur before Step 9 where the dish is cooked in the oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 50, "title": "tangy-gammon-in-cider", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.", "Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.", "Drain the onions and chop each one in half.", "Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.", "Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.", "Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.", "Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.", "Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.", "Cook for 1 hour."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tangy-gammon-in-cider\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat the oven to 200 degrees /gas mark 6.\n2. Start by piercing each tomato once and covering with boiling water to loosen the skins.\n3. Drain the onions and chop each one in half.\n4. Once the tomatoes have been in the water for 5 minutes, drain, then remove the skins and coarsely chop into largish pieces.\n5. Put the onions, tomatoes and apples into a casserole dish.\n6. Take a gammon steak, lay flat, and spoon some of the mixture into the middle, then wrap the sides of the steak over the top and secure with a small skewer or piece of raw spaghetti.\n7. Place in the dish and repeat with the other gammon steaks.\n8. Pour cider over the steaks, cover the top with a lid or tin foil.\n9. Cook for 1 hour.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves pouring cider over the steaks and covering them, which must be done before Step 9, where the dish is cooked in the oven.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the serving plate which logically precedes arranging the tomatoes on it in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the serving plate which is necessary before arranging the tomatoes and basil in Step 2 and Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing and placing the tomatoes on the plate, which must be done before adding basil leaves in Step 3 to ensure proper layering and distribution of flavors.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the serving plate which is necessary before arranging and seasoning the ingredients in Steps 2, 3, and 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing and placing the tomatoes on the plate, which must occur before adding vinegar and oil in Step 4 to ensure proper seasoning and dressing of the tomatoes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sprinkling salt and scattering basil, which should be done before adding vinegar and oil in Step 4 to allow the flavors to meld.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the serving plate which is necessary before arranging the ingredients in Steps 2 to 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves slicing and placing the tomatoes on the plate, which must occur before covering with cling film in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves sprinkling salt and scattering basil leaves, which should be done before covering with cling film in Step 5 to allow the flavors to meld.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 51, "title": "tomato and basil salad", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.", "Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.", "Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.", "Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.", "Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tomato and basil salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Grab an attractive serving plate; flat glass or black works nicely.\n2. Slice the tomatoes thinly and scatter onto plate.\n3. Sprinkle with salt, then scatter all over the basil leaves.\n4. Drizzle over the vinegar and oil.\n5. Cover with cling film and leave at room temperature until ready to serve.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves drizzling vinegar and oil over the salad, which should be done before covering with cling film in Step 5 to allow the flavors to meld.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 2 because you need boiling water to cook the tortellini as described in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water to cook the tortellini, which must be done before frying them in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini which must be done before frying them in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water which is necessary before frying the tortellini in Step 3, hence it must occur before Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini which must be done before frying them in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is an explanation of the benefit of slightly undercooking the tortellini before frying, as mentioned in Step 2, and does not dictate the sequence of frying in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water to cook the tortellini, which must be done before frying and adding almond butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"yes\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini which must be done before frying and adding almond butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the tortellini which needs to be done before adding ingredients like almond butter in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a precautionary note about the cooking process and does not involve a sequential action that affects or is affected by the addition of ingredients in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water to cook the tortellini, which must occur before frying them in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini which must be done before frying them in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the tortellini which must occur before Step 6, where the tortellini is continued to be fried until golden brown.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a precautionary note about the cooking process that should be considered before frying the tortellini in Step 3, not after Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding honey, salt, and almond butter to the pan, which is necessary to flavor and coat the tortellini before frying them until golden brown in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water to cook the tortellini, which must occur before frying and serving them in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini, which must be done before frying and serving them in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the tortellini, which is essential before serving in Step 7, thus it must occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is a precautionary note about the cooking process that logically follows Step 2 and precedes Step 3, and does not depend on the serving instructions in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients that are essential for cooking the tortellini in the pan, which must be completed before serving as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves frying the tortellini until golden brown, which must be completed before serving and garnishing in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water which is necessary to cook the tortellini before frying, thus it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the tortellini, which is essential before frying and serving them as described in later steps, including Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves frying the tortellini, which is essential before serving and enjoying it as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 is part of the cooking process and must occur before the tortellini is served in Step 7 and enjoyed in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves adding ingredients essential for cooking the dish, which must occur before the final serving and enjoyment steps (Step 7 and Step 8).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves frying the tortellini until golden brown, which must be completed before serving and enjoying the dish as described in Steps 7 and 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 52, "title": "tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.", "Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.", "In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.", "If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.", "Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.", "Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.", "Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.", "Enjoy!"], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: tortellini-fritto-with-almond-butter\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a saucepan of water to the boil.\n2. Add the tortellini and cook according to the instructions on the packet, however I recommend you slightly under cook it and drain.\n3. In a non-stick shallow pan, heat some olive oil and gently fry the tortellini.\n4. If you slightly undercooked your tortellini then it's less likely to stick to the pan.\n5. Add some honey, salt to taste and around 2 tablespoons of the almond butter to the pan.\n6. Continue to gently fry and stir the tortellini until golden brown.\n7. Serve the tortellini with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly grated Parmesan cheese and green leaf salad of your choice.\n8. Enjoy!\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves serving the tortellini, which logically precedes enjoying the meal as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin in cold water, which can be done independently and prior to cooking the vegetables in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin in cold water, which needs to be ready to add to the cream mixture in Step 6, before the vegetables are arranged in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables in stock, which must occur before Step 3, where the vegetables are run under cold water to stop the cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin in cold water, which needs to be ready to add to the cream mixture in Step 6, independent of cooking the sorrel in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables in stock, which can be done independently of cooking the sorrel in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, while Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel, which can be done independently of the vegetables' cooling.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin in cold water, which needs to be ready to add to the hot cream and yogurt mixture in Step 6, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables in stock, which must be done before adding them to the terrine in Step 11, independent of heating the cream and yogurt in Step 5.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which is necessary before adding them to the terrine in later steps, independent of the cream and yogurt boiling in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is added in Step 6, and does not depend on the cream and yogurt mixture prepared in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 6 because the gelatin needs to be softened in cold water before it can be added to the sorrel and cream mixture in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be done before adding them to the terrine in Step 11, whereas Step 6 involves adding ingredients to the cream mixture, which is independent of the vegetable cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which needs to occur before mixing them into the terrine in later steps, independent of adding sorrel and gelatin in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is then used in Step 6, so it must occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves bringing cream and yogurt to a boil, which must occur before adding the sorrel and gelatin in Step 6 to ensure they mix properly into a smooth mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 7 because the gelatin needs to be softened in cold water before it can be added to the sorrel and cream mixture in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables in stock, which must be done before adding them to the terrine in Step 11, whereas Step 7 involves adding ingredients to the cream mixture, which is independent of the vegetable cooking process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which needs to occur before mixing them into the terrine in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the sorrel, which is then added in Step 6, before the cooling process in Step 8, indicating that it can occur before Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves bringing cream and yogurt to a boil, which must occur before Step 6 where the chopped sorrel and gelatin are added, indicating that Step 5 should precede Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding ingredients to the mixture which must be done before removing it from heat in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 6, where the softened gelatin is added to the sorrel and cream mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables in stock, which must be done before adding them to the terrine in Step 11, and is independent of cooling the cream mixture in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 must occur immediately after cooking the vegetables in Step 2 to stop the cooking process and prevent them from becoming overcooked.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves cooking the sorrel, which is added to the cream mixture in Step 6, before it cools down in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves bringing cream and yogurt to a boil, must occur before Step 8, as the cream mixture needs to be prepared and cooled before it can be used in subsequent steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which must occur before cooling the mixture in Step 8 to ensure proper mixing and setting.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture and removing it from heat, which can be followed directly by Step 8 where the mixture is set aside to cool; the order of these steps is inherently sequential and does not necessitate a reversal.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 6, where the softened gelatin is added to the sorrel and cream mixture, which is well before Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be arranged in the mould in Step 11, before the cream mixture is added in Step 12, which follows after Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which must occur before they are arranged in the mould in Step 11, well before the cream mixture is added in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is added to the cream mixture in Step 6, well before the cream mixture is poured into the mould in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5, which involves bringing cream and yogurt to a boil, must occur before Step 9 where part of this cream mixture is poured into a mould, indicating that Step 5 precedes Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which needs to be done before pouring any of the mixture into the mould in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture, which needs to be done before pouring any of the mixture into the mould in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture slightly before using it, which can be done concurrently with refrigerating the initial layer of the cream mixture in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin which is necessary before it is added in Step 6, well before arranging the mould in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be done before they are arranged in the mould in Step 11, thus it does not depend on the type of mould used in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which is necessary before arranging them in the mould in Step 11, and thus must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is needed in Step 6, well before arranging the mould in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling cream and yogurt, which is necessary to mix with gelatin and sorrel in subsequent steps before assembling the terrine, independent of the type of mould used in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which needs to occur before pouring the cream mixture into the mould in Step 9, thus it must happen before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture, which needs to be done before pouring it into the mould in Step 9, thus it cannot occur after Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture briefly before layering, which is necessary before pouring the first layer into the mould in Step 9, and does not depend on the type of mould used mentioned in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 can be performed before or after Step 10 as it involves pouring the cream mixture into a mould, which does not depend on the type of mould being used.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 6, where the softened gelatin is added to the sorrel and cream mixture, which is well before arranging the vegetables in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be done before they are arranged in the mould in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves running the cooked vegetables under cold water to stop them from cooking further, which must occur immediately after cooking them in Step 2 and before arranging them in the mould in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is added to the cream mixture in Step 6, long before arranging the vegetables in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling cream and yogurt, which must be mixed with gelatin and sorrel in subsequent steps to create the cream mixture before layering in the mould with vegetables in Step 9 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which needs to be done before pouring it into the mould in Steps 9 and 12, not after arranging the vegetables in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture, which needs to be done before pouring it into the mould and layering with vegetables in Steps 9 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture slightly before layering, which needs to occur before Step 11 where the vegetables are arranged in the mould.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring a base layer of the cream mixture into the mould before arranging the vegetables in Step 11, which helps in setting the initial layer that supports the structured layering of the vegetables.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which recommends using a silicone mould for easier removal, can be decided upon before arranging the vegetables in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 6, where the softened gelatin is added to the sorrel and cream mixture, which is well before Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be arranged in the mould in Step 11 before the remaining cream mixture is poured over them in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which must occur before they are arranged in the mould in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is added to the cream mixture in Step 6, well before arranging the vegetables and adding the remaining cream mixture in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling the cream and yogurt, which is necessary to dissolve the gelatin added in Step 6, before the cream mixture is first used in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which needs to occur before pouring this mixture into the mould in Steps 9 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture, which needs to be done before it can be poured into the mould in Steps 9 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture briefly before beginning to layer it in the mould, which must occur before Step 12 where the remaining cream mixture is poured over the arranged vegetables.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring an initial layer of the cream mixture into the mould to set the base, while Step 12 involves adding the remaining cream mixture after arranging the vegetables, and both steps are part of the layering process that can be adjusted as needed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which advises using a silicone mould for easier removal, is a preparatory step that can be done before pouring the cream mixture in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves arranging the vegetables in the mould before pouring the remaining cream mixture in Step 12, so Step 11 must occur before Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin which is necessary before it is added in Step 6, well before the refrigeration in Step 13.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be done before they are arranged in the mould and set with the cream mixture in steps 11 and 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves running the cooked vegetables under cold water to stop them from cooking further, which must occur immediately after cooking them in Step 2, long before the terrine is refrigerated in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is added to the cream mixture in Step 6, long before the terrine is refrigerated in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling cream and yogurt, which is necessary to mix with the gelatin and sorrel in subsequent steps to create the cream mixture that binds the terrine, all of which must occur before refrigerating the terrine in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which must occur before the cream mixture is poured into the mould and refrigerated in steps 9 and 12, well before the terrine is set in step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture and must occur before pouring it into the mould (Steps 9 and 12), which is well before the terrine is refrigerated to set in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture briefly before layering in the mould, which must occur before refrigerating the entire terrine in Step 13 to set.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the initial layer of the cream mixture into the mould and must occur before arranging the vegetables and adding the remaining cream mixture in subsequent steps, which precede refrigeration in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which involves choosing to use a silicone mould, should ideally occur before filling the mould in Step 9, not after the terrine has set in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves arranging the vegetables in the mould before pouring the remaining cream mixture in Step 12, which must occur before the terrine is refrigerated to set in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the remaining cream mixture over the arranged vegetables, which must be done before Step 13, where the terrine is refrigerated until firm.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 78, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin which is necessary before it is added in Step 6, well before the terrine is set and served in Steps 13 and 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 79, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must be done before they are arranged in the mould and set with the cream mixture in steps 11 and 12, long before demoulding in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 80, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which is necessary before assembling the terrine in Step 11, long before demolding in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 81, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is needed in Step 6, long before the terrine is set and served in Steps 13 and 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 82, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling cream and yogurt, which is necessary to mix with gelatin and sorrel to form the terrine's base before refrigerating, and must occur before the terrine is set and served, not after.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 83, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which is essential for forming the terrine's structure before it is refrigerated to set in Steps 9 and 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 84, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture and must occur before the cream mixture is poured into the mould in Steps 9 and 12, which is well before the terrine is set and potentially released from the mould in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 85, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture briefly before layering, which is necessary before assembling the terrine in Step 9, long before demolding the terrine in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 86, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the initial layer of the cream mixture into the mould and must occur before the terrine is refrigerated and set in Step 13, which is well before demoulding in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 87, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 is a recommendation for the type of mould to use before assembling the terrine, while Step 14 is a method for removing the terrine from the mould after it has set, which are independent actions.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 88, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves arranging the vegetables in the mould before the final refrigeration to set the terrine, which must occur before Step 14 where the terrine is released from the mould.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 89, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the remaining cream mixture over the arranged vegetables, which must occur before the terrine is refrigerated and set in Step 13, and long before it is released from the mould in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 90, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 14?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 14?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves refrigerating the terrine until firm, which must occur before attempting to release it from the mould in Step 14.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 91, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves softening the gelatin which is necessary before it is added in Step 6, thus it must occur before the terrine is assembled and refrigerated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 92, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the vegetables which must occur before they are arranged in the mould and set with the cream mixture in steps 11 and 12, well before the terrine is served in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 93, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves cooling the vegetables immediately after cooking to stop the cooking process, which is necessary before assembling the terrine in Step 11, long before the terrine is served in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 94, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the sorrel which is used in Step 6, long before the terrine is chilled and served in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 95, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves boiling cream and yogurt, which is necessary to prepare the cream mixture before assembling the terrine in Step 9, well before the terrine is served chilled in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 96, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves adding the chopped sorrel and gelatin to the cream mixture, which is essential for forming the terrine's structure before it is refrigerated to set in steps 9 and 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 97, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves mixing the sorrel and gelatin into the cream mixture, which must occur before it is poured into the mould and refrigerated in subsequent steps to form the terrine.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 98, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves cooling the cream mixture briefly before layering, which is necessary before assembling and refrigerating the terrine in steps 9-13, all of which occur long before serving the terrine in step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 99, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the initial layer of the cream mixture into the mould and must occur before the terrine is refrigerated to set in Step 13, which is well before demoulding in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 100, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10, which involves using a silicone mould, should occur before filling the mould in steps 9 and 12, not after the terrine is served in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 101, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves arranging the vegetables in the mould before the terrine is set in the refrigerator (Step 13), which must occur before demoulding and serving in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 102, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves pouring the remaining cream mixture over the arranged vegetables to complete the assembly of the terrine, which must be done before it is refrigerated and set in Step 13, well before serving in Step 15.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 103, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 13 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 13 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 13 involves refrigerating the terrine until firm, which must occur before it can be served in Step 15.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 53, "title": "vegetable-terrine", "question_idx": 104, "steps": ["Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.", "Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).", "Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.", "Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.", "In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.", "Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.", "Mix well and remove from heat.", "Set aside and cool for a few minutes.", "Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.", "It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.", "Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.", "Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.", "Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.", "If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.", "Serve chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "why_question": "Why must Step 14 happen after Step 15?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: vegetable-terrine\n\nProcedure:\n1. Add the gelatin in a bowl of cold water until soft.\n2. Heat the stock and cook the vegetables one after the other in the stock (15 minutes for the carrots and beans, 10 minutes for courgettes and celeriac, 5 minutes for the peas).\n3. Run the vegetables under cold water to stop them cooking.\n4. Wash the sorrel, add the olive oil to a frying pan and cook for 3 minutes, chop then set aside.\n5. In a saucepan, bring cream and yogurt to the boil.\n6. Add the chopped sorrel and gelatin.\n7. Mix well and remove from heat.\n8. Set aside and cool for a few minutes.\n9. Pour approximately 1cm of the cream mixture into a mould and refrigerate.\n10. It is better to use a silicone mould, it will be easier to remove for serving.\n11. Arrange the vegetables, alternating according to shape, starting with the matchstick vegetables on the bottom and peas in the middle.\n12. Pour the remaining cream mixture on top.\n13. Refrigerate the terrine for several hours until firm.\n14. If you did'nt use a silicone mould, immerse the mould in boiling water then turn it over - it should release.\n15. Serve chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 14 happen after Step 15?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 14 is an alternative method for releasing the terrine from the mould if a non-silicone mould is used, and it should occur before Step 15, which is serving the terrine.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which can occur simultaneously with crushing the biscuits in Step 2, as these tasks do not depend on each other.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which is necessary to be ready for baking and does not depend on the mixing of biscuit crumbs and vanilla seeds in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing the biscuits to create crumbs, which are then used in Step 3 to mix with vanilla seeds, so Step 2 must occur before Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, does not depend on the completion of Step 4, which involves preparing the crumb mixture.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing the biscuits to create crumbs, which must occur before Step 4 where the crumbs are mixed with melted butter.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the crushed biscuits with vanilla seeds, which can be done before or after drizzling them with melted butter in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1, preheating the oven, must occur before Step 5, pressing the crumb mixture into the tin, to ensure the oven is ready for baking immediately after the cheesecake assembly is completed.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing the biscuits to create crumbs, which are then used in Step 5 to form the base of the cheesecake, thus Step 2 must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the crushed biscuits with vanilla, which needs to be done before pressing the mixture into the tin in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing the crumbs with melted butter, which needs to be done before pressing the mixture into the tin in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must be done before baking the cheesecake in Step 11, and is not dependent on the mixing process in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form a base, which must be prepared before the cream cheese mixture of Step 6 is added to it.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves preparing the biscuit base which must be ready before the cream cheese mixture is added in Step 9, hence it does not need to follow Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crust by mixing the biscuit crumbs with butter, which needs to be done before the cream cheese filling is prepared in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves preparing the crust by pressing the crumb mixture into the tin, which must be done before adding the cream cheese mixture in Step 9, not necessarily after beating the cream cheese and sugar in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before baking the cheesecake in Step 11, and is unrelated to the mixing process in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form a base, which must be prepared before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, thus it does not need to follow Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the biscuit crumbs with vanilla seeds for the crust, which must be prepared before the cream cheese filling in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, whereas Step 7 involves beating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which is unrelated to the preparation of the crumb base.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be prepared before adding the cream cheese mixture in Step 9, thus it does not need to follow Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar until smooth, which is necessary before adding eggs one at a time in Step 7 to ensure proper incorporation and texture.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before Step 8 where the cheesecake mixture is poured into the base and needs to be baked immediately.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form a base, which must be prepared before the cheesecake filling made in Step 8 is added.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the crushed biscuits with vanilla seeds to prepare the crust, which must be done before the filling is added in Step 9, thus it cannot happen after Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the biscuit base which must be completed before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, which is prepared in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, which follows the mixing of ingredients in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar until smooth, which needs to occur before adding the other ingredients in Step 8 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves incorporating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which must be done before adding the additional ingredients in Step 8 to ensure proper mixing and consistency.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven which must occur before Step 9 where the cheesecake is baked; thus, Step 1 cannot happen after Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to create the base, which must be prepared before the cheesecake filling is added in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the crushed biscuits with vanilla seeds to prepare the base, which must be done before pouring the cheesecake mixture onto it in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before pouring the cheesecake mixture into it in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be done before pouring the cheesecake mixture into it in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar, which must be done before adding this mixture to the biscuit base in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the biscuit base in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves blending the cheesecake filling ingredients, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the biscuit base in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the cheesecake in the oven in Step 11, thus it should happen before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form a base, which must be prepared before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before the baking process in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the biscuit crumbs with vanilla, which is part of preparing the crust before the filling is added and baked, thus it must occur before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, which occurs before Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before placing the baking dish with water in the oven in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the biscuit base in Step 9, which occurs before placing the cheesecake in the oven in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which must be completed before pouring the mixture into the biscuit base in Step 9, and well before placing the cheesecake in the oven in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the cheesecake filling, which must be done before pouring it into the base in Step 9, and thus before placing the cheesecake in the oven in Step 11, which follows Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the mixture into the biscuit base, which can be done before setting up the water bath in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before placing the cheesecake in the oven to bake as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form the base of the cheesecake, which must be prepared before the cheesecake filling is added and baked in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the biscuit crumbs with vanilla seeds to prepare the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, which occurs before baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9 and baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar to create the cheesecake mixture, which must be done before it is poured into the biscuit base and baked in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which must be done before pouring the mixture into the biscuit base and baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves mixing the cheesecake filling which needs to be done before pouring it into the base and baking in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the mixture into the biscuit base which must be done before placing the cheesecake in the oven as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves placing a baking dish with boiling water in the oven before the cheesecake is baked, which can be done before or simultaneously as placing the cheesecake in the oven in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cheesecake in Step 11, not after the cheesecake has cooled down in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form the base of the cheesecake, which must be done before the cheesecake filling is added and baked in Step 11.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the biscuit crumbs with vanilla seeds to prepare the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before the cooling process in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before the cooling process in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9 and baking in Step 11, all of which occur before the cheesecake is cooled in the oven in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar, which is necessary to prepare the cheesecake filling before baking in Step 11, whereas Step 12 is for cooling the cheesecake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which must occur before baking the cheesecake in Step 11; Step 12 involves cooling the cheesecake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves adding ingredients to the cream cheese mixture before baking, while Step 12 is part of the cooling process after the cheesecake has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the mixture into the biscuit base before baking, while Step 12 is about cooling the cheesecake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves placing a dish of boiling water in the oven before baking the cheesecake, which is necessary for creating a moist environment during the baking process in Step 11, whereas Step 12 involves cooling the cheesecake after it has been baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves baking the cheesecake, which must occur before Step 12, where the cheesecake is allowed to cool down in the turned-off oven.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preheating the oven, which must occur before baking the cheesecake, not after it has been refrigerated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves crushing biscuits to form the base of the cheesecake, which must be done before the cheesecake filling is added in Step 9.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing the biscuit crumbs with vanilla seeds to prepare the base, which must occur before the cheesecake filling is added in Step 9, and long before the cooling and refrigeration steps in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves preparing the crumb base which must be done before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9, well before the cooling and refrigeration steps in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves pressing the crumb mixture into the tin to form the base, which must occur before adding the cheesecake mixture in Step 9 and subsequently baking in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves beating the cream cheese and sugar, which is essential for preparing the cheesecake mixture before baking, whereas Step 13 is about cooling and refrigerating the already baked cheesecake.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 involves beating in eggs into the cream cheese mixture, which is essential before baking the cheesecake in Step 11, whereas Step 13 is about cooling and refrigerating the already baked cheesecake.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves adding ingredients to the cream cheese mixture which must be done before baking and cooling the cheesecake as described in steps 9 through 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9 involves pouring the mixture into the biscuit base and must occur before baking (Step 11) and cooling (Step 12), which are prerequisites for refrigeration in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves placing a dish of boiling water in the oven to create a moist environment during the baking process, which must occur before the cheesecake is baked in Step 11 and long before it is refrigerated in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves baking the cheesecake, which must occur before Step 13, where the cheesecake is cooled and refrigerated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 54, "title": "very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.", "Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.", "Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.", "Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.", "Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.", "Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.", "Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.", "Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.", "Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.", "Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.", "Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.", "Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.", "Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: very-vanilla-ry-cheesecake\n\nProcedure:\n1. Preheat oven to 150 C / Gas 2 and lightly butter a 26cm springform tin.\n2. Place the biscuits into a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin.\n3. Pour the crumbs into a bowl and mix with the scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean.\n4. Drizzle the crumbs with melted butter and stir to combine.\n5. Press the crumb mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of the springform tin and set aside.\n6. Place the softened cream cheese and sugar into the work bowl of an electric mixer and beat for about 3 minutes on Medium speed, until the mixture is smooth.\n7. Beat in the eggs one at a time, incorporating each egg before adding the next one.\n8. Add the scraped seeds of 2 vanilla beans, vanilla extract, soured cream and double cream and beat on Medium-High speed for about 1 minute, until the mixture is blended and smooth.\n9. Pour the mixture into the biscuit base, leaving about 5cm of space from the top of the tin for the cake to expand as it bakes.\n10. Place a baking dish onto the bottom rack of the preheated oven and fill it halfway with boiling water.\n11. Place the cheesecake onto the middle rack, above the tin of boiling water and bake until a small knife inserted into the middle of the cheesecake comes out clean, about 1 hour and 20 minutes.\n12. Turn the oven off and let the cheesecake cool down inside the oven for 1 hour.\n13. Cover the cheesecake with cling film, then foil and refrigerate at least 4 hours or overnight before serving.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 involves cooling the cheesecake in the oven, which must occur before Step 13, where the cheesecake is covered and refrigerated.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must happen before Step 2 because the water needs to be boiling in order to cook the lentils.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water for cooking lentils, which is independent and can occur before seasoning the tomatoes in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking lentils which can be done independently of seasoning the tomatoes in Step 3.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water for cooking lentils, which is independent and unrelated to seasoning the tomatoes in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking lentils which is independent of seasoning the tomatoes in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves seasoning the tomatoes and setting them aside to sit for 15 minutes, which is covered in Step 4, thus these steps are sequential and Step 3 does not depend on Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves boiling water which is necessary before cooking the lentils in Step 2, thus it must occur before Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the lentils, which must be done before they can be drained and mixed with tomatoes in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves seasoning the tomatoes and setting them aside to marinate, which should be done before mixing them with the lentils in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, which involves setting aside the seasoned tomatoes, can occur simultaneously with the cooking of the lentils in Step 2.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 must occur before Step 2, which involves cooking the lentils, and this is necessary before mixing them with tomatoes in Step 5 and serving in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves cooking the lentils, which must be done before they can be mixed with tomatoes and served as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves seasoning the tomatoes which must occur before they are mixed with the lentils in Step 5, and therefore before they are distributed in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4, setting aside the seasoned tomatoes, must occur before mixing them with the lentils in Step 5, which is prior to Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 55, "title": "warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["Bring a large pan of water to the boil;", "add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.", "Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.", "Set aside for 15 minutes.", "Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.", "Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: warm-puy-lentil-and-tomato-salad\n\nProcedure:\n1. Bring a large pan of water to the boil;\n2. add lentils and cook over low heat for 30 minutes.\n3. Put tomatoes in a small bowl and season with salt.\n4. Set aside for 15 minutes.\n5. Drain lentils and tomatoes and mix together.\n6. Distribute mixture evenly in 6 individual bowls or ramekins, sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve warm or chilled.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves draining and mixing the lentils and tomatoes, which must occur before they are distributed into bowls and served as described in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 0, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 2?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 2?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which must occur before Step 2 where the yeast is allowed to proof and form a creamy foam.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 1, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is necessary before adding salt and oil in Step 3.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 2, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 3?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 3?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves allowing the yeast to proof and must occur before adding other ingredients like salt and oil in Step 3 to ensure the yeast activates properly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 3, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which must occur before adding flour in Step 4 to ensure the yeast can properly interact with the ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 4, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 must occur before Step 4 as it involves allowing the yeast to activate and foam, which is necessary before adding flour in Step 4.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 5, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 4?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 4?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which needs to be done before adding flour in Step 4 to ensure even distribution of ingredients.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 6, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is necessary before kneading the dough in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 7, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves allowing the yeast to proof and must occur before adding other ingredients like flour in Step 4 and kneading the dough in Step 5, as it is essential for activating the yeast.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 8, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which must occur before kneading the dough in Step 5 to ensure these ingredients are evenly distributed throughout the dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 9, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 5?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 5?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which is necessary before kneading the dough in Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 10, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, while Step 6 involves coating the kneaded dough in oil, which occurs later in the sequence.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 11, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves allowing the yeast to proof and must occur before adding other ingredients like salt and oil in Step 3, which precede placing the dough in an oiled bowl in Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 12, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is necessary before the flour is added and the dough is kneaded, as described in Steps 4 and 5, which occur before Step 6.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 13, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the dough can be kneaded (Step 5) and placed in an oiled bowl (Step 6).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 14, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 6?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 6?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth before it is placed in the oiled bowl in Step 6, so Step 6 must follow Step 5.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 15, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before the dough can rise as covered in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 16, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves proofing the yeast to ensure it is active before adding other ingredients, which is necessary before the dough can rise in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 17, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for preparing the dough before it rises, covered in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 18, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the dough can rise as described in Step 7.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 19, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth, which is necessary before it can rise in Step 8, which follows the covering in Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 20, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 7?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 7?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves coating the dough in oil before it rises, and Step 7 involves covering the dough to rise, which does not necessitate Step 6 to follow Step 7.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 21, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before the dough can rise as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 22, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves proofing the yeast to ensure it is active before adding other ingredients, which is necessary before the dough can rise in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 23, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is necessary before the flour is added and the dough is first kneaded, all of which occur before the dough rises in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 24, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the dough can rise as described in Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 25, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth before it is allowed to rise in Step 8, so it must occur before Step 8.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 26, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6, which involves placing the dough in a well-oiled bowl and coating it, must occur before Step 8, where the dough is allowed to rise, as the dough needs to be in the bowl to rise properly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 27, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 8?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 8?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, covering the dough with a damp cloth, must occur before Step 8, allowing the dough to rise, to prevent the dough from drying out and to create a suitable environment for rising.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 28, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before the dough is first kneaded and allowed to rise, as described in later steps including Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 29, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves proofing the yeast to start the fermentation process, which must occur before the dough is first kneaded and allowed to rise, as outlined in steps 5 through 8, well before punching the dough down in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 30, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for developing the dough's structure and flavor before the first rise, whereas Step 9 involves punching down the already risen dough.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 31, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves initially mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the first rising and punching down of the dough in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 32, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves initial kneading to make the dough smooth before its first rise, while Step 9 involves punching down and briefly kneading the dough after it has already risen, indicating these are separate and sequentially necessary actions in different phases of the bread-making process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 33, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the kneaded dough in a bowl to rise before it is punched down and kneaded again, which occurs in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 34, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves covering the dough with a damp cloth, is meant to facilitate the first rise of the dough in Step 8, and does not depend on the dough being punched down in Step 9.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 35, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 9?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 9?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves allowing the dough to rise until doubled in bulk, which must occur before Step 9 where the dough is punched down to release gas and redistribute yeast.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 36, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before kneading and shaping the dough in later steps.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 37, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves proofing the yeast to create a creamy foam, which is essential before mixing other ingredients and kneading, thus it must occur before steps involving mixing and kneading such as Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 38, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for developing the dough's structure and flavor before the initial kneading and rising processes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 39, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves initially mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before kneading and shaping the dough in steps 5 and 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 40, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves initial kneading to make the dough smooth before it rises, while Step 10 involves kneading the dough again after it has risen and been punched down, serving different purposes in the bread-making process.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 41, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the initially kneaded dough in a bowl to rise, which occurs before the dough is punched down, kneaded again, and divided in Step 10.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 42, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7 is part of the first rising process and occurs before the dough is punched down, kneaded again, and shaped into loaves in Step 10.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 43, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8, which involves allowing the dough to rise until doubled in bulk, must occur before Step 10, where the dough is punched down and kneaded again.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 44, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 10?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 10?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves punching the dough down, must occur before Step 10, where the dough is kneaded again and divided, to release any gas bubbles formed during the first rise.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 45, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before the dough can be shaped into loaves in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 46, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves allowing the yeast to proof and must occur before adding other ingredients like flour and oil, which happens in subsequent steps well before shaping into loaves in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 47, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for developing the dough's structure and flavor before the initial kneading and rising processes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 48, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the dough can be kneaded, shaped into loaves, and placed in tins as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 49, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth before it undergoes its first rise, while Step 11 involves shaping the already risen and punched-down dough into loaves, which are distinct and sequentially separate processes.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 50, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the kneaded dough in a bowl to rise before shaping into loaves, which occurs before Step 11 where the dough is shaped and placed into loaf tins.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 51, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, covering the dough with a damp cloth, is meant to facilitate the first rise in Step 8, which occurs before shaping the loaves in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 52, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves the first rise of the dough to double its size, which must occur before shaping the loaves and placing them in tins in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 53, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves punching the dough down, must occur before shaping the loaves in Step 11 to release any gas bubbles and redistribute the yeast.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 54, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 11?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 11?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves kneading and dividing the dough, which must be done before shaping into loaves and placing them into tins as described in Step 11.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 55, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves dissolving sugar and activating yeast, which is essential to begin the bread-making process, and must occur before the dough can be formed and proofed as described in later steps.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 56, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves allowing the yeast to proof and must occur early in the process to activate the yeast before mixing with other ingredients and before the dough rises.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 57, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for preparing the dough before it is first allowed to rise, well before shaping and the second rising in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 58, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which must occur before the dough can rise and be shaped into loaves as described in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 59, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth, which is necessary before the first rise in Step 8, well before shaping the loaves and the second rise in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 60, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves placing the kneaded dough in a well-oiled bowl to rise, which must occur before shaping into loaves and the second rising in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 61, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, which involves covering the dough with a damp cloth, is meant to facilitate the first rise of the dough and should occur before the second rise described in Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 62, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "```json\n{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves the first rise of the dough to double its size, which must occur before shaping the loaves and the second rise in Step 12.\"\n}\n```"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 63, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves punching the dough down, must occur before Step 12, where the dough is allowed to rise in the loaf tins.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 64, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves kneading and dividing the dough, which must occur before shaping into loaves and allowing them to rise in the tins as described in Step 11 and Step 12.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 65, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 12?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 12?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves shaping and placing the dough into loaf tins, which must occur before Step 12 where the dough rises in those tins.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 66, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 1 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 1 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 1 involves preparing the yeast mixture which is essential to start the bread-making process, and must occur before the baking step (Step 13).\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 67, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 2 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 2 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 2 involves proofing the yeast which is essential for the dough's initial rise, and must occur before the dough is baked in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 68, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 3 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 3 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 3 involves mixing salt and oil into the yeast mixture, which is essential for preparing the dough before it is baked in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 69, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 4 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 4 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 4 involves mixing in flour to form the dough, which is essential before baking (Step 13); thus, it must occur before, not after, baking the bread.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 70, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 5 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 5 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 5 involves kneading the dough to make it smooth, which is necessary before it can rise and be baked as described in later steps, including Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 71, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 6 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 6 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 6 involves coating the dough in oil before the first rise, which must occur before baking the bread in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 72, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 7 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 7 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 7, covering the dough with a damp cloth, is part of the rising process before baking, which must occur before Step 13, the actual baking of the bread.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 73, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 8 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 8 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 8 involves allowing the dough to rise before it is baked, which must occur before Step 13 where the dough is actually baked.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 74, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 9 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 9 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 9, which involves punching the dough down, must occur before baking (Step 13) to release gas and redistribute yeast, essential for proper loaf structure.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 75, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 10 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 10 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 10 involves kneading and dividing the dough, which must occur before baking (Step 13) to form the loaves properly.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 76, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 11 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 11 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 11 involves shaping and placing the dough into loaf tins, which must occur before baking the dough as described in Step 13.\"\n}"}
{"plan_idx": 56, "title": "white bread", "question_idx": 77, "steps": ["In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.", "Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.", "Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.", "Mix in flour about 125g at a time.", "Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.", "Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.", "Cover with a damp cloth.", "Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.", "Punch dough down.", "Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.", "Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.", "Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.", "Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes."], "question_type": "nondependent_fake_after", "binary_question": "Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "why_question": "Why must Step 12 happen after Step 13?", "model_name": "gpt-4-turbo-2024-04-09", "prompt_key": "basic_binary_explain", "model_input": "Given a goal, a procedure to achieve that goal and a question about the steps in the procedure, you are required to answer the questions.\n\nGoal: white bread\n\nProcedure:\n1. In a large bowl, dissolve the sugar in warm water, and then stir in yeast.\n2. Allow to proof until yeast resembles a creamy foam.\n3. Mix salt and oil into the yeast mixture.\n4. Mix in flour about 125g at a time.\n5. Knead dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth.\n6. Place in a well oiled bowl, and turn dough to coat.\n7. Cover with a damp cloth.\n8. Allow to rise until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.\n9. Punch dough down.\n10. Knead for a few minutes, and divide in half.\n11. Shape into loaves, and place into two well oiled 23x13cm (9x5 in) loaf tins.\n12. Allow to rise for 30 minutes, or until dough has risen 2.5cm (1 in) above tins.\n13. Bake in a preheated 180 C / Gas 4 oven for 30 minutes.\n\n\n1. Must Step 12 happen after Step 13?\n2. Explain why or why not.\n\nFormat your answer as JSON with the key value pairs \"binary_answer\": \"yes/no answer to Q1\", \"why_answer\": \"one sentence answer to Q2\"", "model_answer": "{\n  \"binary_answer\": \"no\",\n  \"why_answer\": \"Step 12 must occur before Step 13 as the dough needs to rise in the tins before it is baked.\"\n}"}
