Code-switching is prevalent in multilingual communities but lacks adequate high-quality data for model development, especially for African languages. To address this, we present AfroCS-xs, a small human-validated synthetic code-switched dataset for four African languages (Afrikaans, Sesotho, Yoruba, isiZulu) and English within a specific domain—agriculture. Using large language models (LLMs), we generate code-switched sentences, including English translations, that are rigorously validated and corrected by native speakers. As a downstream evaluation task, we use this dataset to fine-tune different instruction-tuned LLMs for code-switched translation and compare their performance against machine translation (MT) models. Our results demonstrate that LLMs consistently improve in translation accuracy when fine-tuned on the high-quality AfroCS-xs dataset, highlighting that substantial gains can still be made with a low volume of data. We also observe improvements on natural code-switched and out-of-domain (personal finance) test sets. Overall, regardless of data size and prior exposure to a language, LLMs benefit from higher quality training data when translating code-switched texts in under-represented languages.