This paper explores retrieval with sentence embeddings by fine-tuning sentence-transformer models for classification while preserving their ability to capture semantic similarity. To evaluate this balance, we introduce two opposing metrics – polarity score and semantic similarity score – that measure the model’s capacity to separate classes and retain semantic relationships between sentences. We propose a system that augments supervised datasets with contrastive pairs and triplets, training models under various configurations and evaluating their performance on top-k sentence retrieval. Experiments on two binary classification tasks demonstrate that reducing the margin parameter of loss functions greatly mitigates the trade-off between the metrics. These findings suggest that a single fine-tuned model can effectively handle joint classification and retrieval tasks, particularly in low-resource settings, without relying on multiple specialized models.