This paper presents WikiQA-IS, a novel question-answering dataset focusing on Icelandic culture and history, along with an automated pipeline for dataset generation and evaluation. Leveraging GPT-4 to create questions and answers based on Icelandic Wikipedia articles and news sources, we produced a high-quality corpus of 2,000 question-answer pairs. We introduce an automatic evaluation method using GPT-4o as a judge, which shows strong agreement with human evaluations. Our benchmark reveals varying performances across different language models, with closed-source models generally outperforming open-weights alternatives. This work contributes a resource for evaluating language models’ knowledge of Icelandic culture and offers a replicable framework for creating similar datasets in other cultural contexts.