The reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) play a critical role in many downstream tasks, yet depend strongly on the quality of training data. Despite various proposed data construction methods, their practical utility in real-world pipelines remains underexplored. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of open-source datasets and data synthesis techniques for mathematical reasoning, evaluating them under a unified pipeline designed to mirror training and deployment scenarios. We further distill effective data selection strategies and identify practical methods suitable for industrial applications. Our findings highlight that structuring data in more interpretable formats, or distilling from stronger models often outweighs simply scaling up data volume. This study provides actionable guidance for integrating training data to enhance LLM capabilities, supporting both cost-effective data curation and scalable model enhancement. We hope this work will inspire further research on how to balance “more data” versus “better data” for real-world reasoning tasks.

Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance across various applications, but their conversational abilities decline sharply as model size decreases, presenting a barrier to their deployment in resource-constrained environments. Knowledge distillation (KD) with Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has emerged as a promising approach to enhance the conversational abilities of smaller models using a larger teacher model. However, current methods primarily focus on “black-box” KD, which only uses the teacher’s responses, overlooking the rich distributional information within the teacher’s probability distribution. This paper addresses this gap by introducing daDPO (Distillation-Aware DPO), a novel framework that integrates the teacher’s distributional information into DPO distillation while preserving theoretical guarantees. Our framework offers a unified objective that enhances both preference optimization and distribution-based distillation. We provide rigorous theoretical analysis and empirical validation, showing that daDPO outperforms existing methods in restoring performance for pruned models and enhancing smaller models within the same LLM family. Notably, in in-domain evaluation, our method enables a 20% pruned Vicuna1.5-7B to achieve near-teacher performance (-7.3% preference rate), and allows Qwen2.5-1.5B to occasionally outperform its 7b teacher model (14.0% win rate).