@inproceedings{knowles-2021-stability,
    title = "On the Stability of System Rankings at {WMT}",
    author = "Knowles, Rebecca",
    editor = "Barrault, Loic  and
      Bojar, Ondrej  and
      Bougares, Fethi  and
      Chatterjee, Rajen  and
      Costa-jussa, Marta R.  and
      Federmann, Christian  and
      Fishel, Mark  and
      Fraser, Alexander  and
      Freitag, Markus  and
      Graham, Yvette  and
      Grundkiewicz, Roman  and
      Guzman, Paco  and
      Haddow, Barry  and
      Huck, Matthias  and
      Yepes, Antonio Jimeno  and
      Koehn, Philipp  and
      Kocmi, Tom  and
      Martins, Andre  and
      Morishita, Makoto  and
      Monz, Christof",
    booktitle = "Proceedings of the Sixth Conference on Machine Translation",
    month = nov,
    year = "2021",
    address = "Online",
    publisher = "Association for Computational Linguistics",
    url = "https://preview.aclanthology.org/ingest-emnlp/2021.wmt-1.56/",
    pages = "464--477",
    abstract = "The current approach to collecting human judgments of machine translation quality for the news translation task at WMT {--} segment rating with document context {--} is the most recent in a sequence of changes to WMT human annotation protocol. As these annotation protocols have changed over time, they have drifted away from some of the initial statistical assumptions underpinning them, with consequences that call the validity of WMT news task system rankings into question. In simulations based on real data, we show that the rankings can be influenced by the presence of outliers (high- or low-quality systems), resulting in different system rankings and clusterings. We also examine questions of annotation task composition and how ease or difficulty of translating different documents may influence system rankings. We provide discussion of ways to analyze these issues when considering future changes to annotation protocols."
}