Chatbot service providers (e.g., OpenAI) rely on tiered subscription plans to generate revenue, offering black-box access to basic models for free users and advanced models to paying subscribers. However, this approach is unprofitable and inflexible. A pay-to-unlock scheme for premium features (e.g., math, coding) offers a more sustainable alternative. Enabling such a scheme requires a feature-locking technique (FLoTE) that is (i) *effective* in refusing locked features, (ii) *utility-preserving* for unlocked features, (iii) *robust* against evasion or unauthorized credential sharing, and (iv) *scalable* to multiple features and clients. Existing FLoTEs (e.g., password-locked models) fail to meet these criteria. To fill this gap, we present Locket, a more *robust and scalable* FLoTE to enable pay-to-unlock schemes. We develop a framework for adversarial training and merging of feature-locking *adapters*, which enables Locket to selectively disable specific features of a model. Evaluation shows that Locket is effective (100% refusal rate), utility-preserving (≤ 7% utility degradation), robust (≤ 5% attack success rate), and scalable to multiple features and clients.