Shaurya Vats


2023

pdf
LLMs – the Good, the Bad or the Indispensable?: A Use Case on Legal Statute Prediction and Legal Judgment Prediction on Indian Court Cases
Shaurya Vats | Atharva Zope | Somsubhra De | Anurag Sharma | Upal Bhattacharya | Shubham Nigam | Shouvik Guha | Koustav Rudra | Kripabandhu Ghosh
Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2023

The Large Language Models (LLMs) have impacted many real-life tasks. To examine the efficacy of LLMs in a high-stake domain like law, we have applied state-of-the-art LLMs for two popular tasks: Statute Prediction and Judgment Prediction, on Indian Supreme Court cases. We see that while LLMs exhibit excellent predictive performance in Statute Prediction, their performance dips in Judgment Prediction when compared with many standard models. The explanations generated by LLMs (along with prediction) are of moderate to decent quality. We also see evidence of gender and religious bias in the LLM-predicted results. In addition, we present a note from a senior legal expert on the ethical concerns of deploying LLMs in these critical legal tasks.